Gone With The Wind Book Analysis

Good Essays
Our world today has become arrogant, sensitive, and critical. Books are being banned in result of the sensitivity of our nation, including the novel Gone with the Wind by Margaret Mitchell. The novel takes place in the south during the Civil War era and follows a young woman’s romantic life and her survival through the war. She pursues the love of her life while in doing so must fight for her survival in the war plagued south. Despite the immense amounts of history in the novel, some believe the controversial content outweighs the history and therefore should be banned. Our critical world overlooks the accurate historical content and puts a spotlight on the sensitive topics. The hypersensitivity of the readers has led to the banning of not …show more content…
Many have challenged the book over it’s realism believing it is too graphic. Although violence and gore were present in Gone with the Wind, it was not excessive, and there was only enough to create an accurate depiction of the war. Margaret Mitchell became very knowledgeable of the Civil War through her grandfather, whom was in the Confederate Army. Kim O’Connell states that “it [the Civil War] showed up in books as it showed up in the lives of those who survived” (2). Margaret Mitchell used the details of her father’s war stories as a direct source for her novel no matter the amount of violence or gore. The authenticity and history in the novel are enough to overlook the violence and gore in the novel. The Civil War is known for being one of the bloodiest and most violent wars in history, but with that being said, Mitchell found a way to get that point across without focusing directly on the …show more content…
Often it 's challenged by those who feel offended by the language. Language can be a problem in certain circumstances, such as novels that include language that is unnecessary to the plot. Many accusations have been made that the language in Gone with the Wind is racially demoralizing and are discriminatory. The only problem with those accusations are that they took the words out of context. Most can agree that the n-word is a very offensive word, but when it 's used in the context of the novel, the word describes and characterizes how upper-class Southerners treated blacks in that time period. Elizabeth Leonard explains in her article "Slavery in Literature", that racially discriminating words in literature are present, but to only better describe what the slaves had to endure. Mitchell conscientiously put the n-word and other language in Gone with the Wind to describe to the reader the harsh treatment of slaves. The purpose of the language in the novel was to give the audience a more in-depth look at vernacular of the time period rather than antagonize them. The language used in Gone with the Wind does not justify it 's banning, but instead proves the importance of language in learning about the Civil

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The main point Stowe is trying to make is even though it looks all good it is still corrupt. It shows how Mr. Shelby and Mr. Clare are good slave owners but bad at the same time because they allowed slave owners, like Haley and Legree to treat slaves so cruel (Wren, 1998). Another literary devices Stowe uses tone. The tone of this novel is very serious because it tries to get the northerners to realize slavery is a serious thing. The narrator tries to educate the reader about the many terrors of slavery and how serious they actually got.…

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Morihei Ueshiba is quoted as saying, “Failure is the key to success; each mistake teaches us something.” If The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is banned, people would only be able to gauge Southern culture through history books—an informative, yet sometimes untruthful method of teaching (Ethos). Many history books tend to make the Southern population seem like a lot of racist, ignorant bigots. By reading one of Mark Twain’s greatest works of his entire career, people are able to develop their own opinion on the issues Pre-Civil War America. Since slavery and racism is such a controversial issue, many people condemn the scar that slavery has left on America. However, slavery is just as much of a part of American history and culture as the American flag.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In her novel Uncle Tom’s Cabin, the author Harriet Beecher Stowe accurately showed her readership her reasoning for advocating for the abolition of slavery by illustrating the heartlessness of slaveowners, the immorality of slavery under Christianity, and the wrongful stereotyping of slaves in this time period. Stowe showed her readers a more intimate view on how horribly slaves were treated by illustrating how rude and absolutley heartless slaveowners could be. In this time period, even some of those who were for abolition of slavery were unable to grasp the magnitude of what slaves went through every day, so it was important for Stowe to write this out in her novel to sort of be a wake-up call for those who were on the fence about abolition.…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    She mentions this quote as a guilty conscience to the south for their wrongdoings. Some saw Stowe’s novel as stereotyped and an excuse for her to apologize on behalf of America , which does not acknowledge the real truth about slavery “ ‘ That Stowe’s novel that she wrote to protest slavery as this evil that was going to damn the nation to hell if we did not abolish it became converted to an apology as the ‘good old days’ for almost immediately after the civil war’ ”(Hamilton 22).Stowe writing this book in her time period was not something that everyone had the guts to do, but she did to open the eyes of the people, to get them to understand that this was wrong.. At that point America really represses the truth about slavery and a change for equality was…

    • 1233 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Even today, war is shrouded in controversy as people across the country wonder if it is all worth it. The ideals he expresses in his novel still connect with these doubts. While writing, Vonnegut resorted to unheard-of-narrative strategies which allow it to be connected, even to this day. As Charles Harris says, “...the novel is not a conventional war novel at all, but an experimental novel of considerable complexity” (Harris 1). The flexibility of Slaughterhouse-Five is one of its greatest traits, as it can still be viewed and agreed with 50 years later.…

    • 1351 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The south tried to say that slaves were happy, but educated, heartfelt attacks on slavery written by people like escaped-slave Frederick Douglass said otherwise. The treatment of slaves varied depending on the owner, but families of slaves being separated and punishments like whipping was common. Though the war may have started as a way to preserve the Union which was breaking after the election of an anti-slavery President, Abraham Lincoln, it turned into a war that would decide the fate of slavery (“Slavery in the United States” 2014). The desire for change is what caused the civil war. The people of the northern states recognized that slavery should not be legal while the southern states wanted to expand slavery to the west.…

    • 1651 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Are We Rome Book Review

    • 2131 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Throughout his work, it is clear that Murphy prefers to relate Roman culture over an equal analysis of American society. This hinders his ability to fully address his thesis, he lacks a clear consensus to address the issues he raises about the future of America in the same way he dissects the fall of Rome. I agree with his thesis, I also believe that while we can recognize flaws today in the US, we are still in time to correct ourselves. Through, Murphy leaves the reader unsatisfied by limiting the solutions he proposes for these flaws, which also greatly degrades the literary quality of the…

    • 2131 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    J.C. Furnas is one of the critics that believes Stowe is to blame for certain stereotypes or certain details about African Americans that aren’t true (Levine 73). Many believe that even though Stowe is trying to be supportive the anti-slavery movement by writing Uncle Tom’s Cabin that she has done more harm than good. Another scholar named Donald Chaput also believes that Stowe has hurt the African American community by writing her novel (Levine 73). The views she used to write her novel have been seen as a set back to anti slavery movements. Other believe that her novel has helped the African American community even if her views were questioned she still brought a lot of attention to the slavery problem.…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “Law” came to his window and asked, “what’s happening?” Instead of spelling brother correctly, Sundiata spelt it “brutha”. By choosing these phrases and spelling choices the author is trying to best portray how African Americans are believed to have behaved. Although these actions might be true, it doesn’t necessarily mean that all people of that race act that specific way. This makes me believe that Sundiata is criticizing how the world paints people with a brush only based on the way they speak. Racial profiling plays its role in the way…

    • 1878 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    To eliminate the n-work form the original text in order to appease readers who may be angered by the repeated usage of the n-word would take away the true meaning of the novel. The word “nigger” was commonly used during the mid-1800s by Americans. During this time educated or uneducated Americans used the n-word. The word is used to highlight or emphasize the racism of the time. People today cannot fully understand why “nigger” was used back then I if they really knew how it was like to be a slave, then they would know how slaves were addressed.…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays