Bonnie Schmidt's 'The Greatest Man'

Improved Essays
Bonnie Schmidt’s The Greatest Man-Catcher of All : The First Female Mounties, the Media, and the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (2011) gives her readers an insight of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) program during the 1970s. She highlights the struggles that women face to get enrolled into the police force. The RCMP in the 1970s was consisted of mostly male and the images that RCMP promoted was masculinized. Meaning, emphasis was placed on what an the valued and traits a male police officer should possess. However, the RCMP training program instilled values of manhood in the Canadian society. We can argue that the RCMP is responsible for communicating to society of the qualities it takes to be man —a man should have courage, strength, …show more content…
For example,if you take a look at the movie Charlie's Angels (1976) where three independent women makes it their duty to become private detectives. But if you take a closer look, they are under the guidance of a male character. So, this whole idea of them being independent is problematic. However, I don't know if the media assumed that this is how society viewed women in the police forced and that they were giving the public what they want or they felt that portraying women as equal counterparts might compromised their interest of generating profits and public appeal. But what we do know, the media in the 1970s created gendered and racialized representation of women. Not only women, but men as well. I think that men were feeling some sort of pressure as well because they had to live up to Canadian idea of what it means to be a man in the RCMP. As a result, it caused them to resent women joining the police force as they felt that their job was being threatened.These hegemonic ideals of women was spread in the media to maintain the Canadian society normative standards that men are the only ones that can be enforces. This did this to protect their jobs and ideas. But what we need to understand is that maybe the stories that the Journalists wrote wasn’t their actual views of what they thought about women joining the RCMP, but rather the perspective of wealthy owners media enterprises. Women were depicted as being too feminine to fit into their uniform as result they will be a distraction to the men police officers, result in the inability to perform their job tasks. This was used to blindside society into thinking that women were obsessed with their

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    A sleep-deprived Catherine Galliford is running on adrenalin and ragged nerves after a wild week that saw the RCMP corporal rock her employer with claims that she was sexually harassed and bullied by senior officers, even as she served as the spokesperson for two of the biggest investigations in the force's history. Galliford was calm and competent on camera as the public face of the RCMP's investigations into the Air India bombings that claimed 329 lives, and serial murders committed by Robert Pickton on his Port Coquitlam pig farm. But while Galliford's allegations of harassment reached as far as the House of Commons this week, one of her most explosive claims is only now being made public. Galliford says the rampant sexism within the ranks of the RCMP that ruined her health and career may also have contributed to the mismanagement of the Pickton murder investigation, at a cost of many lives.…

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Why Do We Make So Much of Gender,” Allan G. Johnson argues against patriarchal beliefs as well as gender profiling. He begins by proving that religion and history play a key role in how cultural expectations develop. Johnson follows by giving examples that support the fact that gender profiling still exists to this day and proves that the mistreatment of women is more than a biological issue, but social as well. Johnson, with samples from other authors, proves the irony between how men and women are supposed to be portrayed. Throughout the article, Johnson makes some strong points on the issue, but also includes weak ones as well.…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Marilyn Frye Case Study

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages

    When it comes looking at social groups and social situations, Marilyn Frye distinguishes perspectives by classifying them either as microscopically or macroscopically. We need to look at these social groups and situations separately, which is where these two different perspectives come into play. When you look at something microscopically, it always refers to the individual: individual person or individual law. Microscopically, you are trying to find the single direct cause which is directly causing the harm. On the other hand, a microscopic view takes on a broader perspective.…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In this article, the author, Pamela Palmater, makes several arguments and some conclusions. Even her conclusions appear to contain smaller arguments. Either way, all the arguments center on one issue: crisis-level in Canada for violence against Indigenous women and girls. Palmater’s central argument is for an in-depth inquiry into the violence. She argues the inquiry must be both focused and general.…

    • 881 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The media is a wonderfully powerful force in our society. The media gives us everything from important world news to videos of cats. The media also gives us film and television, and while those are two of the most amazing inventions ever they have a major flaw. The media, especially film tends to struggle with female characters. This leads to women feeling like they have less power than men based on the ways they are portrayed in the media.…

    • 562 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Men in every era are seen to be powerful muscular guys who should protect and defend their country and loved ones. J.J Wilson’s article on Skating to Armageddon: Hockey and The First World War argues that during the first world war the men’s that were enlisted were apart of a hockey team. Hockey has criteria that make men the perfect candidates to be enlisted in in the first World war. During the 1990’s it was important that masculinity was implemented at a young age as it will prepare young kids to grow into men that perform their duty to their nation. Throughout this article it is seen during this era there is a huge value placed on men as there are little to talk about when it comes to women besides them not rising their little boys to be…

    • 1298 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    War has impacted Canadian women’s lives in so many ways, both negatively and positively. Despite the forward movement of women’s rights, the uncertainty and struggle, huge death toll, broken promises and the economic downturn post war affected the lives of many women. Perhaps one of the most troublesome acts during the wars was the internment camps where immigrants, both women and men who considered themselves Canadian, were detained and imprisoned for being considered enemy aliens. Despite the hardships of war, World War One had been the turning point for improving women status in Canadian history from one of discrimination to one of recognition. Women’s roles changed from mothers to munitions workers.…

    • 415 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The title Miss Representation is the first clue as to the content of the documentary will center on: the play on words of “misrepresentation” vs “Miss Representation” gives the sense of beauty pageant, in which women (although some pageants include contestants as young as toddlers) compete to win a superficial title based primarily on looks. The premise of the documentary is to reveals the complexities of women’s role in society, and the double standards that create the gap between the reality of women’s appearances and self-esteem, and the media portrayal of women’s bodies, which are – as the title indicates – severely misrepresented. In the film, there are several examples of the disparities between what is expected of women and the reality…

    • 895 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stereotyping Analysis

    • 313 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In this today world, Stereotypes plays an important role. Stereotyping is defined as a fixed conventional notion or conception of an individual or group of people. It may be basic or complex which people may apply to individuals or groups on the basis of their appearance, belief, behaviour. Stereotypes are found everywhere. It has been observed that our world seems to be improving in various ways that it is impossible to liberate it from stereotypes.…

    • 313 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Aboriginal women are victimized by violence far more than their non aboriginal counter parts due to various factors which steam from the systemic, intersectional oppression of social construct in Canadian society. Society views these women as if they are not apart of society; they are otherized and thus, treated as such which leads to violence, abuse and the dismissal of harming issues regarding Aboriginal women. “In far too many instances,extreme racialized violence against Aboriginal women leads to their disappearances and even murder”- (Harper,A. (2009) The abuse inflected on these women such as violence, even murder have high record rates in Canada; efforts to expose and inform the public (Canadian Society ) such as the ‘Red Dress’ Organization are implemented, exemplifying and help the understanding of the public of how these Aboriginal Women are being citizens by violence and how great the numbers are. The Red Dress organization/ movement in Canada is a showcase of red dresses hanging, each dresses repressing another ‘sister’- Aboriginal women, lost and taken victim of the violence affecting indigenous women in Canada.…

    • 1309 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Unfortunately, discrimination plays a part in these cases even past the point of the murder. Racial stereotypes are making it so some Aboriginal women have distrust in Canadian authorities, in fear that they will not take their cases as seriously. However; these assumptions are not far from the truth. In many cases, reports of missing and murdered Aboriginal women get less attention from media and the police force than other races of women (Missing 1). Not all cases involving missing and murdered bAoriginal women and girls are properly investigated to the RCMP’s full ability (Benjamin 1).…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The misrepresentation of women in the media is a large issue when it comes to how gender stereotypes are perpetuated. Young children are taught early on by various movies and television programs that there are certain attitudes, tasks, and positions for males to hold. They are taught that these behaviors, tasks and positions are different from those that women should hold based on their gender. The creation of these societal norms creates a divide when it comes to how men and women are to behavior respectively within a society. These gender roles are particularly noticeable when it comes to views on positions of power.…

    • 1509 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Women of Canada and Britain played a very important part in World War 1 and 2. They had to take over many jobs that men had to leave in order to go fight in the war. Women were very eager to join the army and serve their country but propaganda from the government made the difference in how many women joined. Women back home wanted a heroine role during World War 2 and working for the army was an excellent way to meet that goal. The poster I chose has the caption “they serve – that men can fly.”…

    • 1106 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    People are unaware of what is being presented to them through the media unless they analyze the significance behind the script. Further deconstructing the media’s script such as television, the most pervasive form of media, will surely summon the point that media is fundamental in creating the social norms. In addition, gender roles are being surfaced through many television shows, and stereotypes are distorted excessively among these shows. Two and a Half Men encompasses and enforces both gender roles and stereotypes towards men and women. This television series provides many examples enhancing how society view these gender constructions over time.…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Women equality in the media has increased over time, but it is still not equal to the men's. Women are seen as “Just women” and the media is inferring that women are not capable of the same things that men are. Women are put in a box that labels them in negative ways. In my research paper I will be explaining the inequality for women in the news, sports journalism and also entertainment. News journalism is a demanding field for both women and men, so why is it when you turn on your daily news you're less likely to see a women representation?…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays