Blue Collar Brilliance Analysis

Improved Essays
Whether at a job, at home, or in between, any experience can be just as educational as a class at a university. In “Blue Collar Brilliance”, the author, Mike Rose, uses anecdotes from his family’s experiences to prove how although his family members might not have had much formal education, they all were “intelligent” due to the lessons they learned at work. Given my family’s own experience, I can attest to that.

Throughout all of the generations of my family, half have attended a traditional university, while the others went to work or had a different experience, some even had both. In the recent decade though, my cousins and I have leaned towards traditional classroom learning because that is what was taught to us in a class. At same time,
…show more content…
An education in which students receive not only normal education in Math, English, and history, but they also are able to focus on learning a trade at the same time.

My freshmen year I wanted to go to our local vocational school to study Biotechnology, but my mom always looked down on non traditional sources of education. “Vocational school is for people who do not want to go to college,” my mom would say. “I went to vocational school and I turned out fine,” my dad would reply.

My dad went to our local vocational school to be trained in carpentry and though he never got a job directly tied to carpentry, he still retained all of his lessons and used his knowledge to help his friends, family, and to lend a hand to his dad’s drywall business. To this day he is one of the smartest people I know and most of his education he learned from working at his various jobs. He learned organization working the night shift at a grocery store; he perfected his carpentry craft building furniture for his family; he cared for people at a nursing home; and now he continues working in the shipping department of a medical laser company and has been for the past 18
…show more content…
He memorizes the maze of the building like the back of his hand, knows exactly what every part that goes into the lasers he ships does, and over years of experience, he has been able to apply his previous carpentry skills and decode the engineer 's’ notebooks in which they had to go to school to learn to write. He also has maintained and improved the skills that Rose uses for examples of skill that carpenters hone through experience rather in structured lessons:“An eye for length, line, and angle”.(911)

Skills that make someone intelligent come in many forms. From everyday analysis, to Math, to speaking and writing in a foreign language. and anywhere in between, are all skills that require brain power are intellectual skills that can be learned inside and outside of the classroom. The problem in today’s society though, is everyone 's definition of “smart” is different although the majority view being smart as being caused by going to school. Despite society heavily supporting traditional education, people still find ways to be successful and gain intelligence in their own

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Rose’s uncle was also very intelligent blue collar worker. Joe had worked many jobs such as Pennsylvania Railroad,Navy,Returned to the railroad, and eventually joined his brother at General Motors. Joe working at the shop provided something school never could, joe had to learn the most efficient way to use his body. We reinforce this notion of defining intelligence…

    • 413 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Intelligence is not what one can acquire from books, but how one can effectively react to non-receptive content. In the article “Blue-collar Brilliance”, Mike Rose contends that workers in the professional field are not more resourcefully adequate than blue-collar and service workers. Being successful in the labor or service field requires the same set of mind tools as doctors, lawyers, scientists, and other professionals. The way a doctor generates a diagnosis based on intuition and medical credentials is the same way a mechanic generates a diagnosis on a vehicle based on sound and mechanic accreditation, yet we presume the doctor’s in-grained mental capacity is exceedingly advanced because of his educational background. Blue collar workers develop exclusive…

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the essay, “Blue Collar Brilliance,” Mike Rose, a UCLA professor, uses a series of personal experiences to justify the level of intelligence of blue-collar workers in comparison to the stereotypes they are viewed by. His reasoning for this is that, “If we think that whole categories of people–identified by class or occupation–are not that bright, then we reinforce social separations” (283). He uses the examples of his mother Rosie and his brother Joe to illustrate what he perceives as the exceptional intellect of blue-collar workers. Rose begins the essay by talking about his mother Rosie who is a waitress at a restaurant.…

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Trust me, I know stuff: A summary of Gerald Graff’s “Hidden Intellectualism” In the essay “Hidden Intellectualism,” Gerald Graff explores the idea that the educational system fails to recognize street smarts as a valid form of intellect. In particular, Graff suggests that schools and educators are at fault for overlooking street smarts because of the assumption that such intellect is invalid and of no use to academic learning. Although some people believe that being knowledgeable about sports, fashion, or cars is not a proper type of intellect, Graff implicitly argues that if an individual is passionate enough about a specific subject, they would eventually develop excellent academic skills, just as how he did through sports. Ultimately, what…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    - In both articles, authors were talking about how the academic and non-academic learning can be more valuable in the society, we found many facts that tell us how society can respect you if you are an educated individual. “Blue-collar Brilliance”, Professor Mike Rose address that society’s blind views on the intellectual ability of the people operating jobs related to serving or manual workers. Rose indicated that blue collar workers miss focusing on the intelligence needed in their businesses. Besides, he stated that the relationship between certain never proclaims worker intelligence.…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Menand begins with a personal anecdote, about a student asking why he was required to buy a book for class. This question sparks Menand to contemplate the three fundamental theories on the role of college. Theory 1, Menand states, is the belief that college is essentially a “four-year intelligence test” (2). Subscribers of this theory believe that college weeds out less competent members of society and sorts individuals based on their skill set. Then there is theory 2.…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What is education? Education is information about or training in a subject. Most people think that education is related to school. Education can apply to any subject, or activity as long as you are improve in what you’re doing you’re being educated. People only believe in school smarts they leave out other subjects that students have high interest in.…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Richard Rodriguez’s article, “The Achievement of Desire,” is a dynamic piece about many hardships Rodriguez faces while growing up in a working class family that is very different from him. Rodriguez’s parents worked as laborers, an occupation that made it very difficult to live off of. With this idea in mind, Rodriguez learned to push himself to the top of the class when it came to school. Rodriguez’s had a strong desire to learn, which led Rodriguez to learn at higher levels, foreign to the rest of his family. Rodriguez quickly surpassed his parent’s knowledge and became more and more independent as he got older.…

    • 1637 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Any Topic (Writer's Choice) The article “What’s Wrong with Vocational School?” by Charles Murray is a great article that highlights what ails the education system and the United States of America’s economy. Murray prods the readers to question why the vocational schools are not taken seriously in the United States of America. The American higher education system has been overrated to the extent that all parents would like their children to end up in the best colleges and universities even if their IQ does not allow them to excel in them. Murray is addressing parents and students and urging them to rethink their attitude towards vocational education in order to improve the society by joining them in groups.…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dweck And Isaacson

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Dweck and Isaacson’s Contrasting Views on Intelligence “There is no substitute for hard work.” -Thomas Edison. No one is born with intelligence. It is developed through various forms of work and the actions one exhibits. One has to work hard in order to achieve their goals.…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “The American Dream is still alive out there, and hard work will get you there,” said Bill Rancic. “You don’t necessarily need to have an Ivy League education or to have millions of dollar startup money. It can be done with an idea, hard work and determination”. That quote defines my high school journey. All my life consisted of education, education, and education.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    , Stephanie Owen and Isabel Sawhill in their article “Should Everyone Go to College?”, and Mike Rose in his article “Blue-Collar Brilliance” argue. They acknowledge that college has its benefits, but they also realize that it has some drawbacks. These authors believe that college promotes social inequality,…

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Blue-Collar workers do have a certain kind of education that gives them the authenticity they provide in their jobs, then again in today’s world it is getting harder and harder to get by as an uneducated individual. The examples Rose provides are ideal through examples, nonetheless they do not apply to how modern society works, they apply to the 1950s way of life. Although I grant that on the job experience is extremely better than learning from a book, I still maintain that one should stay in school and push themselves to get degrees. For it is from this education that an individual would learn more and create less trial and error in the on the job…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    03 Feb. 2016. Emily Hanford, writing from the American RadioWorks, discusses the value and importance of a college degree and a college education. Hanford briefly provides a history of education prior to and after World War II and discusses how only a small group of Americans went to college because of the job in the 70s didn’t require a degree. Hanford then continues her article by introducing today’s standards for education and how education is required to survive in today’s society. Hanford then continues her article by introducing subtopics such as the rising value of education, “a class dimension”, and value in “some college”…

    • 1631 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    School. If you live in the United States, you have probably encountered going to school in any shape or form due to our laws of compulsory education. However, many argue that our education system is not as great as it should be. As America is one of the worlds most developed countries, yet we still constantly fall beyond is rankings of education. Why is this?…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays