Big Tobacco Deal Went Bad

Improved Essays
Introduction and Background “How the Big Tobacco Deal Went Bad” written by Jim Estes attempts to cause reform by educating the public about the misuse of funds for self-interest by the government politicians.
The New York Times The New York Times is a periodical published daily in New York and its online newspaper. The target audience of the newspaper is educated and younger individuals that have political affiliations. This newspaper has liberal political views while raising awareness on social issues. It is one of the most popular newspapers in the United States and has a very large circulation both digitally and in print. It is significant that The New York Times published this article because New York was one of the states that accepted
…show more content…
The use of the large sums puts the problem in perspective. The use of the large numbers is to incite anger amongst voters and taxpayers. The aim of his article is to provoke policy change by educating individuals about their politicians. The evidence presented in the article is mostly convincing because Estes offered examples of the states mishandling public funds. However, the one finding in the article that was shocking was that despite the politicians diverting these funds to other projects and personal gains, the sales of cigarettes is going down (Estes, 2014). This evidence is contradictory because it shows that tobacco sales can go down without the support of government programs. Additionally, it was surprising that the Tobacco Master Settlement Agreement of 1998 allowed tobacco producing companies to be exempt from legal liability (Estes, 2014). This reveals the greedy intentions of policymakers who are looking for a payday and not towards the health of the public. The government wanted to capitalize off the profit of these large

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Martha Derthick’s Up In Smoke is a detailed look at federal regulation, legislation, and litigation through the lens of the tobacco industry. By providing a detailed chronology of tobacco regulation in the United States, Derthick is able to shed light on the centers of influence connected to the development of policy concerning nicotine and cigarettes. The narrative attempts to illuminate the relative power of industry lobbyists, health administrators, congressmen, and tort lawyers in these dealings. In particular, the book focuses on the power struggle between non-elected officials and private interests groups in determining regulation. Because non-elected officials and interest groups have no formal legislative power, their attempts to influence policy and regulation is often referred to as “subgovernment.”…

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Brilliant Essays

    Human Resources Management (KM) Walgreens has recently launched a corporate university program that serves and encourages employee learning. Senior vice president and chief human resources officer had this to say about why Walgreens decided to launch such a program, “We wanted to create an innovative and agile talent pool, one that’s diverse and fosters a powerful cross section of thoughts and ideas. From our leaders in our community centers to our store managers, learning and growing every day is essential to delivering our business strategy”. The program offers courses to employees at any level of employment.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Brilliant Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the early 1950s, when scientific research began to document the link between smoking cigarettes and cancer, the tobacco industry went into a ‘PR fallout … [known] as the 1954 emergency’ (smoking hacks). The panicked industry formed a phony front group titled The Tobacco Institute Research Committee (TIRC). The roll of the TIRC was to ‘lull the public into a false sense of security concerning smoking and health’ (smokers hacks); and they ‘promised to learn the facts’ (smokers hacks). This is an example of astro-turfing. Astro-turfing is when corporations create paid lobby groups, posing under the cover of genuine concerned citizens, whose objective is to promote their own businesses.…

    • 189 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The article “Md. Cigarette Taxes Have Unintended Consequences” discusses the issues surrounding an excise tax on cigarettes and cigars. Authors Dee Hodges and Jeff Ferguson, highlight the negative consequences that resulted from the enforcement of “sin” tax by Maryland officials based on their normative decision that smoking is detrimental to one’s health therefore, the government must intervene to reduce the demand of tobacco products. There are a few economic ideas that figure prominently throughout the article. Firstly, tobacco has an inelastic demand. Despite Maryland’s tax imposition, consumers still consumed nearly the same number of cigarettes they normally did because tobacco is an addictive product and its demand did not vary with…

    • 239 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As stated, “responsible organizations devoted to the “public interest” are encouraging the harassment of those who smoke” (Scott 28-31). Consequently, Scott goes on to enumerate and bash some organizations that he believes are causing tension between smokers and nonsmokers. As a result, he hopes to persuade the audience to be against and question these organizations. Using this generalization is prejudicial because not all anti-smoking organizations reinforce the idea of harassment. As a result, the fallacies used ravage Scott’s argument.…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the main and most important principles of the United States foundation is the protection of peoples’ rights and choices. Therefore, when a policy is drafted that limits these rights, there is bound to be discussion over its paternalistic qualities. Paternalistic public policies are generally frowned upon, but, in rare cases, restrictions have to be put in place to protect citizens’ deeper preferences (living a long, healthy life) rather than allowing them to participate in their surface preferences. Robert Goodin discusses smoking; a rare case in which a paternalistic policy could save many smokers from ruining themselves and why the policy is permissible. He proposes four different reasons as to why making paternalistic decisions about smoking is permissible.…

    • 1524 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Commentary: (750 words) Government intervention, specifically taxes, are used in almost every market system in order to serve as a solution to market failures, such as negative consumption externalities. A negative consumption externality is a situation where a good or service is consumed and a third party (someone not directly involved with the transaction) experiences a loss as a result of the transaction. Market failure is defined as any situation where the allocation of resources by a free market is not efficient. This article discusses how the All-Party-Parliamentary Group wants the tax rate of tobacco to increase to 5%, using the extra money towards anti-smoking projects in order to increase the rate of decline in smoking. Tax rate is the tax…

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    government in this instance (Ball and Dagger 19). An argument could be made that the government pushing its way into business affairs violates an important quality of classical liberalism, namely, that government should concern itself with the protection and preservation of individual rights only. The problem with this stance may lie in whether or not the rights guaranteed to individuals under the classical liberal view can or should be extended to include a corporation. If individual rights do include corporations, then the harm principle, which states that “government and society should not interfere with an individual's activities unless that individual is somehow harming or threatening to harm others”, would apply here as well and would provide the Big Tobacco corporations with another argument against government intervention into its business practices (Ball and Dagger 24). If corporations should not be granted the same rights as individuals then this line of argument does not apply and the government is within its right to attempt to exercise control in the manner that it…

    • 646 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    For a long duration, the major tobacco companies concealed the truth about the calamitous effects of smoking. Adding to that, some of the companies also instilled extra nicotine and a variety of other chemicals into the tobacco to increase its addictivity. The companies, like Brown & Williamson, didn't impart these activities to the government or to their customers (The Insider). A film released in 1999, The Insider, tells the story of two whistleblowers.…

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Preview: Thanks to the modernization of electronic-cigarettes, the substitution of vaping versus traditional cigarettes has saved countless lives and is more accessible than ever. If the FDA is allowed to fully enforce their motives behind keeping vaping out and big tobacco in within the smoking industry. then healthier options will be minimized and nullified within the future. One possible reason the FDA wants complete control over the market is to ensure the US is still able to heavily reap from vape-related products, and it’s growing 10 billion-dollar industry, just as it does from the big tobacco industry. but this comes at the potential cost to the entire industry as a whole.…

    • 1593 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tobacco has been the cause of death of millions of people from when it was first introduced. They didn't know it at first, but even after exclusive scientific studies linking cigarettes and cancer appeared in the 1920s and subsequent studies which showed cancer could be induced by using nicotine-free tobacco, which means that tar, with or without nicotine, was carcinogenic became overwhelming in the 1950s, they still denied it. They still held that there was no direct evidence linking tobacco and it's supposed harmful effects. Tobacco companies funded think tanks and lobbying groups, started health reassurance campaigns, ran advertisements in medical journals, and researched alternate explanations for lung cancer, such as pollution, asbestos and even pet birds.…

    • 250 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In America obesity has become a growing issue to the extent that it is one of the most talked about issues in the United States alone. Another topic that is constantly talked about is the abuse and excessive use of tobacco and the health repercussions that arise. Over the past decade many American’s have taken a stance against tobacco, yet select few have taken a stance against the fast food industry. The trend between both the food industry and tobacco industry are strikingly similar even though they appear to have no direct relation. . The conflict within the United States is that fast food has become an addictive product to the point that it has become a new form of tobacco.…

    • 1116 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Introduction of critical review This report will criticize the ' Cigarete tax avoidance and evasion: findings from the International Tobacco Control Policy Evaluation project '. This article is written from G Emmanuel Guidon, Pete Driezen, Frank J Chaloupka and Geoffrey T Fong. The article was published online on 13 November 2013.…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tobacco Industry Equal

    • 635 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The tobacco industry has been a victim of such bias and majority of the people in the society have a negative insight against the tobacco industry and the companies involved in this industry. It is particularly unethical because the companies in the tobacco industry are businesses like any other business and they ensure that they are licensed in agreement to the specified laws and regulations (Rowell). The tobacco industry is a controlled industry and any company venturing in this industry has to comply with numerous…

    • 635 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Libertarianism On Drugs

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Unfortunately, politicians benefit from keeping the poison on the streets for anyone to buy. Tobacco is a huge industry with large firms that make every effort to make their environment as an unregulated as possible. They do so by hiring professional lobbyists to whip representatives to vote in their favor, by bribing donating to their campaigns. In this case, politicians place the needs of their own pockets in front of the needs of their own people. Analogously, when researching scientific literature, journals which claim heart benefits of red wine are typically published by laboratories that receive funding from the alcohol industry.…

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays