Big Brother Meets Big Mother Analysis

Superior Essays
Parents are the foundations of a child’s success and welfare, whether they choose to monitor their teens or not. The introduction of surveillance, especially online, has allowed parents to easily track their children's activities in this modern era. In the newspaper article “The Undercover Parents” (2008), Harlan Coben informs parents that using spyware is a good tool in monitoring teens’ activities but also suggests that parents do not make their surveilling a secret. In another newspaper article, “Big Brother Meets Big Mother” (2007), Ellen Goodman criticizes overprotective helicopter parents who use spyware to monitor their teen’s every activity because it prevents the teens from being independent and having privacy. To illustrate the best …show more content…
In order to avoid the dangers, parents should monitor the teens frequently because it would help them become aware of online threats. Coben expresses the downfall of the lack of online supervision through real life examples of the “young boy unknowingly conversing with a pedophile or the girl who was cyber bullied to the point where she committed suicide” (8). This fact shows that if parents are unaware of the dangers online, they risk their adolescents walking right into mistakes with no guidance. Also, if parents were to monitor their child frequently, they would be always able to look out for dangers. Due to the reason that anything could happen at any moment, it is best to look out for suspicious actions than to miss it because of the lack of surveillance. Coben mocks the guardians who let the dangers happen by asking, “Would a watchful eye have helped?” (8) to show how parents overlooked hazardous activities when they decide to not surveil their adolescents. Also, Coben further supports his argument by using an allusion to compare parents to the NSA since they are using spyware in order to look out for “dangerous chatters” (11). As a result, the parents become the watchful eyes that would prevent the risks of an adolescent online. Overall, the use of monitor frequently by parents are shown to be helpful when looking out for inappropriate …show more content…
Although there are possible dangers everywhere, teens need independence and privacy to discover their own identity and make their own future-affecting choices. As Anna Quindlen once said, “Children should have enough freedom to be themselves - once they’ve learned the rules.” For me, my parents do not monitor me, but I am able to maintain my grades. Although, they don’t monitor my whereabouts they tell me their rules and I follow them. However, I cannot say the same for other people since they are raised differently. This topic is something I am passionate about because I feel that surveillance should not be used to track a child’s action but to look out for dangers. Even though my parents do not have a physical device to track me, they use their every little ability in order to keep me safe, whether by rules or a simple phone

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Have you ever thought of putting spyware on your child’s computer? In the article ‘‘Undercover Parent’’, Harlan Coben discusses how most parents won’t even consider putting spyware on their child’s computer. From my point of view parents should put spyware on their child’s computer. Some parents will say that it’s better to use parental blocks that deny access to risky sites. For example, if your child looked up porn, your child would not have access to that website.…

    • 202 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his essay “Undercover Parent,” Harlan Coben supports the idea of using spyware on teenager’s electronics by parents. Using this spyware you have the ability to “log every keystroke your child makes” (2) and invading their private space. While this idea is valid because most parents who do this are loving and only want to protect their children from harm, by placing this spyware on a teen’s electronics you are not only evading their privacy but also their trust. This is because more than likely parents are doing this behind the child’s back, which could ultimately lead to distrust and resentment due to the lack of trust in the teen to be able to make their own decisions. However, spyware on computers would, in fact, help to prevent situations…

    • 259 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Harlan Coben’s article “The Undercover Parent” (2008), he argues that parents should use spyware to protect their children. He says that there is a line on how it should be used, but not using it would be negligence. Coben believes monitoring a child through spyware is a good way to protect them from harm. After reading Coben’s article, I have found that I disagree with his opinion. In the article, as coben writes while referring to a child, he states clearly “Shouldn’t he learn now that the Internet is not a haven of privacy?”…

    • 390 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In this article “The UnderCover Parent” Harlan Coben claims,that parents should put spyware on their kids computers, and phones etc, that kids couldn’t be trusted on the internet for the reasons that kids could be on websites they shouldn’t be on . Do you think parents should put spyware on their kids technology devices ? I disagree with Harlan for the reason that, Harlan is saying that children shouldn’t be trusted on the internet , I disagree because if you have a bond with your child (son/daughter) they wouldn’t abuse the internet and if they have a problem they should be able to come to you as a parent for advice . Another reason why I disagree with Harlan is because if you are spying on your kids you’re investing in their privacy…

    • 347 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Harlan Coben posted an online news editorial, titled “The Undercover Parent” (16 March 2008) that suggests to parents that they should have conversations about their teens, and let them know spyware, on their computer, is a possibility. The author was first told about spyware by his friends at a dinner; since then, he has explored the thought of placing spyware on children’s computers. Coben’s purpose was to persuade parents to place spyware on their children’s, or to at least think about it, to monitor their children’s internet usage. The intended audience of this article is parents with children/teens who go on or use the internet.…

    • 347 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Abby Bailey Mrs. Duffy PAP English 9- 2nd Period 12 May 2017 Technology’s Strong Hold on Our Youth In the dystopian novel of Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury, Guy Montag - pain stricken- discloses the idea that “‘We need to be really bothered once in awhile.’”…

    • 1346 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Harlan Coben, in the article “The Undercover Parent” (2008), explains how parents should install spyware on their children’s devices to monitor them and keep them safe from the dangers of the Internet. Coben supports his claim by first comparing first thoughts of spyware to Dick Cheney sitting in a dark room, looking suspicious and shady and then he provides scenarios of things that have happened to those kids who were not being monitored. The author’s purpose is to inform parents of the dangers of the internet and the benefits of monitoring their kids in order to try and convince them to install spyware and keep their children safe. Coben writes in an urgent tone for guardians to increase the seeming need to watch their child’s actions on the internet.…

    • 657 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By pointing out that “we’ve all read about the young boy unknowingly conversing with a pedophile,” (66) he pulls at a parent’s natural instinct to protect their children. He wants people to read his essay and feel empathy for the parents that use spyware. He gives an example of a friend who used spyware on his daughter’s computer and found out about his daughter using drugs. By using the spyware to obtain…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Is spyware a good idea to keep your kids safe from dangerous chatters online? Harlan Coben, author of “The Undercover parent”, discusses that spyware may not be such a bad idea. Although it may sound like a good idea, there might be some invasion of privacy. I agree and disagree with Coben’s argument about putting spyware in your kids computer. From my point of view, I do and I don’t think it’s a good idea to keep your kids safe by putting spyware in their computer.…

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Coban identifies both the positive and negative options of how spyware can be used to watch over teenagers and their internet activity. He encourages families and parents who…

    • 465 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Harlan Coben the author explains in this article named, “The Undercover Parents.” Explains how parents should monitor their kids. I agree with Harlan Coben that parents should monitor their kids for many reasons. Coben also explains how the internet is dangerous for teenagers, because they might share information about their parents or about their life. That might affect them in the future for sharing information.…

    • 582 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “The Undercover Parent,” a newspaper article written by Harlan Coben (in March 16, 2008), Coben insists that parents install spyware on their children’s computer, but to use it only to a specific level. He argues that parents should have this software to make sure that their kids are guarded and that they are not contacting with anyone that may cause them any harm. However, he also understands that parents should not use it to find out personal information or to read the gossip that happens at school. He supports his points by giving many real life examples and connecting them to what parents care about most: their children’s safety. I have come to agree with Coben’s position as I also believe that parents should have this software because…

    • 1272 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I believe that when parents use spyware it is a huge invasion of privacy. You are seeing your child's inner thoughts and what they are saying to others. I think parents can monitor their children by putting web page blockers on their computers they should also talk to them about the dangers of the internet. Parents should ask questions when their child goes out or they should pick them up and drop them off to confirm what their child said is true. I agree with coben because parents should make sure they aren't being bullied, they not being the bully, or they aren't doing things they aren't supposed to.…

    • 659 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Harlan Coben’s OpEd piece “The Undercover Parent” is a powerful piece written to convince parents that the benefits of spyware greatly outweigh the invasion of privacy. Throughout his essay, he maintains a friendly, parent-to-parent tone that one can compare to a conversation over coffee. As a college student without children, I found it difficult to understand the importance of monitoring children’s internet activities. However, when I forced myself to take on the perspective of a parent, I found Coben’s argument to be far more compelling, and found myself understanding the importance of spyware on computers that children have access to. In his article, Coben assumes that readers will have a negative response to the concept of spyware, but he uses his argument effectively to persuade the reader that spyware is not only harmless, but an asset in the toolbox of good parents.…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Imagine that you were back in middle school and had just developed a crush on one of the boys or girls in your class and they asked you out, that business is your business and whoever you want to share it with. It is personal and something you only tell your closest friends at sleepovers, but what if your parents had been reading and recording every single conversation about it you had ever had, then it wouldn't be so secret anymore now would it. However this is not just a quick little made up story this is reality, parents are actually seriously using spyware on their kids, and can even listen in on your every conversation which is pretty freaky that some kids are being treated like former criminals, considering the technology being used.…

    • 1651 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics