Being Sane In Insane Places Analysis

Improved Essays
Insane or Sane?
After reading the article “Being Sane in Insane Places”, I was actually not surprised by the results. I believe it is difficult to diagnose mental disorders because physicians are not given direct results to interpret. It consists of a series of questions and speculating possible reasons based only on the patient’s answers. According to the article, some individuals act out for no reason, but does that mean they are suffering from a mental disorder? Of course not, but I believe that physicians struggle with this because there is no concrete answer. I believe that they are trying to link how a person feels to symptoms of a mental disorder to fix the issue. This is why I think physicians could accidentally diagnose a healthy individual
…show more content…
It illustrates how an individual is quickly identified as a schizophrenic after stating he heard voices. This experiments shows that physician could easily misinterpret a healthy individual as sick within the psychiatric medical system. I have experienced this first hand after seeing multiple doctors for mental health. Each of them asked me similar questions, but struggled to pinpoint the exact reason for what I was feeling. This caused the physicians to contradict each other because one would diagnose me with one mental disorder, while the other would say the complete opposite. I believe that my experience and this experiment shows how the psychiatric medical system needs to improve. The system needs to find a more effective way to diagnose patients because taking medication for something they do not have could be harmful. For example, an individual with bipolar disorder could be mistaken for having depression. This results in that person taking anti-depressants and that increases the risk of a manic episode within bipolar …show more content…
This could cause some “odd” individuals to pursue into more deviant behaviors because they might believe that it is how they are supposed to act. This relates to the experiment because the labels caused a skew in results since the pseudopatients were viewed as insane. As mentioned in the article, the pseudopatients had their freedom limited by being stripped of personal privacy and trying to communicate with the staff. This stigmatization may have caused the individuals to think that maybe they are actually “crazy” and that idea may have been carried out into the real world. According to the textbook, this may have negatively affected their ability to function normally and efficiently. This may have resulted in others who knew about the experiment to think that they actually suffer from a mental disorder. This could create a confusion within family and friends of the individual to think that he or she is sick, but in reality he or she is

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Anxiety Vs Anxiety

    • 1479 Words
    • 6 Pages

    There is no way to medically test if someone is depressed. The way depression is diagnosed is from the patient giving the doctor self-reported symptoms. This is dangerous because once a patient convinces the doctor they are depressed they can be prescribed an antidepressant. What if they weren't feeling as well as they wanted to? This question is just one of the many that led psychologist to study this topic.…

    • 1479 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This child must of felt as if she did something wrong. She might have been frustrated because she could not understand why people were acting that way. She might of felt unequal to everyone else due to the lack of interest and interaction those around her displayed. Stigmatization can affect people in so many ways. Jobs may not be given to certain people who have illnesses because of the stigma that it carries.…

    • 1150 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thomas notes historic research in which several patients had warts that were destroyed after a hypnosis session, where the therapist made suggestions to the patient and the warts eventually disappeared. Spanos’ research proves he agrees that hypnosis could be viewed as a successful way to approach the treatment of warts. He noticed in his research that there was a correlation between the hypnotic procedure and the medical treatment, allowing the medical treatment to become more effective. However, it has been reported that the high expectancy of successful hypnotic treatment of warts is not necessarily predictive of a positive treatment outcome. “More specifically, these findings indicate that neither a hypnotic induction procedure nor instructions for relaxation enhance the efficacy of suggestions at inducing wart regression” (Spanos, 257).…

    • 1045 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Often times those that are forced to receive treatment (such as with Baker Acts) form a mistrust for the helping professional. This can lead to a refusal of services in the future they may have otherwise accepted. Those under Baker Acts generally feel they are “imprisoned” even though they have not broken any law. In addition, the mentally ill are commonly appointed a guardian. This can be a good or bad thing as there are concerns of caregivers/guardians abusing their power.…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ethics Of Mortality

    • 1019 Words
    • 4 Pages

    By countermanding the DNR order in the interest of providing a better outcome for the patient, it allows time for the patient to be treated for their mental illness. This is similar to when a patient is involuntarily hospitalized for their self-destructive behavior. This can result an improvement in mood or depression, leading to no further wishes of committing suicide. However, DNR laws do not provide clear guidance for clients who are mentally ill (Cook, 2010). Because of this, the author Geppert concludes that, the patient should only be resuscitated if they have a likelihood of recovering from the event…

    • 1019 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The author explained that in one particular study, they found that even the patients, if told they had a chemical imbalanced, became pessimistic about their outcome. He wrote that people who had negative reactions to a chemical imbalance explanation also had the same reaction if the explanation was heredity or brain disease. Haslam argues that we need to be mindful of using biogenetic labels, that they may be doing harm to mental health…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Vaccines: Article Analysis

    • 1319 Words
    • 5 Pages

    It is also unethical to let a human die in a trial of a new drug, but they are not comparable because one was intentional and the other accidental. The author is trying to use ethos and pathos to make you question the motives and the testing of vaccines. Perkins is also trying to make readers feel sympathy for those who suffer from vaccination testing, and use that sympathy to arise anger towards corporations. The…

    • 1319 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is shown because the Oedipus case study only explains meanings about itself. In addition, the case of Anna O by Freud and Breuer ( ) fails to meet the criteria of science because it cannot be tested. testability. However, Hinshelwood (2010) points out that single cases studies can be tested. Some academics argue that psychoanalysis is not a science because it cannot be falsified.…

    • 1086 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    By learning about illnesses and disorders that I had heard of before, but did not know anything about, I can understand why people can think “people with schizophrenia are crazy” or “suicidal people need to be thankful for what they do have.” However, I believe that it is up to psychologists, future psychological workers, or just the average person to inform people of the symptoms and unfortunate experiences that people who are suffering from mental illnesses are going through. More simply put, one should not talk about things that he/she does not know anything…

    • 2068 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One disorder I would love to specialize in would be Schizophrenia. It is one of the many disorders that scientists and psychologists cannot cure. Although they have found treatments to help, they have not been able to fully cure schizophrenia or even come close to it. Patients still struggle with taking medication since schizophrenia is a personality disorder, patients tend to believe someone is telling them that they are better and do not need to take medication anymore. Some studies believe that electroconvulsive treatments are misunderstood and tend to work best.…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays