Beck's Theory Of Depression

Good Essays
Depression is one of the most prevalent psychiatric disorders widely found and one of the most to be frequently diagnosed. As depression increases, multiple approaches to treatment have been sought after to effectively treat the disorder. Many of the psychological studies have shown individual and biomedical therapy to be efficient treatments to help depressive people. Some psychological views believe that the disorders are caused by biological factors and some adopt the approach the cause to be in the mind. In discussing the effects of cognitive therapy and or antidepressants medication to treat depression, findings have showed how they are similar in neural mechanism and how they are distinct from each other. Individual therapies are one …show more content…
A symptom of depression is distorted thinking where negative self-schemas bias a person’s thinking. Psychologists have been led to believe that by replacing one’s negative cognitive process with more realistic and positive ones, they will be able to help people with depression – this is based on Becks theory of cognitive restructuring. In researching this theory, the Riggs et al. (2007) were able to study the effectiveness of the cognitive behavior therapy (CBT) in combination with a placebo or an SSRI. This was a randomized double blind study that used 126 adolescents from ages 13-19 that have suffered from depression along with substance use disorder and conduct disorder. Physicians rated the participants by “very much improved” or “much improved” after four months. The physicians found that 67 percent of the patients in the CBT and placebo group improved and 76 percent of the patients in the SSRI drug and CBT group improved. This study has shown that using cognitive behavioral therapy is an effective treatment because the participant’s …show more content…
Compared to biomedical therapy, individual therapy is cost effective because they’re not usually involved in prolonged treatment. As shown in the Riggs et al. (2007) study, cognitive therapy is quite an effective form of treatment and has no negative effects. On the other hand, the biomedical approach towards treatment has some ethical issues because the drugs may develop side effects. In this case, the use of Prozac in the Kirsch and Sapirstein (1998) study has potential side effects such as headaches, nervousness, loss of appetite, difficulty sleeping and sexual dysfunction. This can be considered as putting harm on the participants or clients, and violates the ethical standards. Although each type of treatment, whether it was cognitive therapy or biomedical therapy, has shown in both study (Riggs et al. and Kirsch and Sapirstein) that the treatment helped alleviate depressive symptoms, they each differ in the amount of effectiveness towards treating depression. Individual therapy relieves depressive symptoms through resolving problems and help clients to develop coping strategies. This helps the clients to change underlying schemas and thereby prevents relapse. Compared to individual therapy that may serve as a long term treatment, drug therapy is an effective way to treat depression in the short term because clients need to continue using the drug

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    This makes antidepressants an effective way to treat various forms of depression, whether it would be long term or short term. Antidepressants can boost a person’s mood so that they can get out of the depression stage. Depression is known as “the common cold of mental illness.” In psychology we use our brains to process certain behavioral activities. If one is not behaving normally it can be hard to observe the person’s actual actions due to them not being able to…

    • 1665 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It explains this as a neurotransmitter (serotonin) has shown to have progressively low levels within a patient suffering from depression. This has enabled them to be able to produce a drug to increase these levels with the hope of eradicating the depression all together. Although they believe the chemical imbalance is the cause, patients may also be prescribed with some form of counselling or therapy alongside the prescribed drugs. A Behaviourist theory on the cause of depression would be that the patient may have not received enough positive enforcement throughout their childhood or adult life. But to achieve an explanation it would focus on observant therapy to assess the patient and discover the problem.…

    • 1492 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    According to the Depression and Bipolar Support Alliance states that psychotherapy can help, “Understand your illness, define and reach wellness goals, overcome fears or insecurities, cope with stress, make sense of past traumatic experiences, separate your true personality from the mood swings caused by your illness, identify triggers that may worsen your symptoms, improve relationships with family and friends, establish a stable, dependable routine, develop a plan for coping with crises, understand why things bother you and what you can do about them and end destructive habits such as drinking, using drugs, overspending or unhealthy sex” (“Psychotherapy” 1). Having a session weekly with a psychologist could, in the long run, help the overall mental health of the patient and give someone the opportunity to be more mentally healthy than ever before. Also, understanding what kind of therapy to take could be very important to the improvement of the patient 's health. According to an article, “Behavioral therapy concentrates on your actions; cognitive therapy focuses on your thoughts; and interpersonal therapy looks at your relationships with others” (“Psychotherapy” 1). There are many different types of therapies that all focus on different things involving the mental health, understanding what the individual is struggling with and getting the right kind of therapy could make miles of improvement upon the alternative of antidepressants.…

    • 1723 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Before the client takes any medication, the client must be informed of the process and side effects that the medications may have. Some side effects include lack of hunger, weight gain or sexual dysfunction. A few examples of medication for depression are antidepressants such as Cymbalta oral, Lexapro oral, Effexor XR oral or Celexa oral. Cymbalta oral with the generic name of Duloxetine is used to treat depression and anxiety, it improves mood, sleep, appetite and energy level of the user. Lexapro also known as Escitalopram is used to treat the same as Duloxetine but it works by restoring balance of certain natural substances in the brain and improve energy and feeling of being.…

    • 1516 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Benefit Of Placebo Effect

    • 1828 Words
    • 8 Pages

    For instance, psychiatry researchers have looked at diagnostic changes in research participants who receive placebo control treatment for depression. Some humans could be more like minded to agree on the effects of the placebo due to their current mind state. In a low-power study, researchers from the University of Texas at San Antonio were able to show that in people with depression, both placebo effect and treatments with fluoxetine resulted in similar changes in glucose system our measured by positron discharge tomography filter. The mechanics of the placebo are quite interesting to say the least that some subjects will respond while others might not even show a response. Even though the evidence in a real situation the things we can find from the placebo effect is how positive emotions and thoughts can work to wellbeing and…

    • 1828 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Although these different therapies focus on side effects of suicide, it can still be used as treatment to reduce the thoughts of teenagers. DBT treats people with borderline personality disorder (BPD) which is involved with suicidal thinking and actions massively. A recent study found that DBT decreased suicidal thinking and actions more than other treatments. CBT has two different forms of therapy included in one which is cognitive therapy and behavioral therapy. CBT helps a person focus on the problems they are experiencing and solving it with the help of the therapist.…

    • 1578 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Medication can be used on its own, although studies show that it is more effective when paired with therapy. Medications can help to manage the symptoms of certain mental illnesses and can therefore improve individual functioning and reduce distress. For example, if an individual with Major Depression does not benefit from psychotherapy alone, they can be referred to a psychiatrist and begin taking prescribed medication to reduce their symptoms. Medications may also be the first choice of treatment depending on the type of disorder, disease, or the severity. For example, a child with ADD may benefit from a stimulant and a patient who hears or sees things that are not real would likely need an antipsychotic medication.…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Seeking treatment is an important step after diagnosing depression. Depression should be treated because it can lead to suicide or the development of a physical illness. Treatment options include medication and psychotherapy. Treatment is personalized based on the individual’s symptoms and body. The medicine used to treat depression is called an antidepressant.…

    • 881 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Why administer medication, that may help the individual psychologically but ruining their organs and metabolic processes. For example, much of the marketed medications of depressions or ADHD list “suicidal thoughts and behaviors” as a main side-effect. Although, helping depression symptoms it’s creating suicidal ideation in patients, not quite the benefits expected. However, using psychological treatments that has been proven to be effective of depressive disorders does not place patient at risk of suicidal thoughts. Furthermore, what is great about including psychology treatments more intensively in the health care system is that if there is needed for the administration of medication, it can be done so as a complement to treatment.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Antidepressants are used for more than just depression. They not only work for episodes of “mild or moderate depression;” they also help those who feel despair. The drug can, however, use the placebo effect to cause a patient believe that they are getting better when, in fact, nothing is happening. Psychologist Robert DeRubeis concluded that the antidepressant lift could be “all in your head” (Kramer 1). The reason some people question antidepressants is because “subjects who don’t really have depression are included” in the experiments.…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays