Bartholomae

Improved Essays
Those who do not write often or feel the process of writing meaningless may not come to agree with the argument that Bartholomae is showing his readers. Bartholomae is arguing that strategy of error analysis. Error analysis is basically the act of reviewing your own failures and learning from them. These failures can be seen in anything that one does in their lifetime. In Bartholomae’s case we are talking about error in writing. Error analysis is commonly used on those who are learning a second language but it is also extremely common for English professors to use when getting their students to become more engaged with their writing skills. With the use of error analysis we as writers have the opportunity to look back at our own writing and gain the knowledge of what we have done wrong. Peer editing is also …show more content…
With the use of error analysis it helps teachers track their own students and see how their writing skills have improved and how the writer is developing. Bartholomae is explaining to readers that writers do make mistakes we violate our expectations. As a student who has been writing for years now I can agree with this . There has been numerous occasions in which I was writing and I had expected my paper to be perfect. Eventually I had reviewed it I found mistakes that if I had not gone back and looked at it I would have never found these mistakes. I can come to agree with the study of error as Bartholomae has described since I have been using the method throughout my years as a writing. Without editing and looking back over your work whether it be alone or with the help of a peer you will not grow as a writer. To grow as a writer you need to be able to come to terms with the mistakes you make and edit them so that it will not happen again. Those who are opposed to this method may argue differently but I can personally say that with the use of error analysis it has helped me grow as a

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    “Revising” In Joseph Harris’s article, “Revising”, Harris emphasizes the differences between drafting, revising, and editing, and the impact that each of these elements has on drafting a well-written paper. Harris dubbs the first step “drafting”, or formulating the content of the paper. Drafting involves the development of ideas into a larger body of text that can be easily followed. The next step in this process is “revising”, or further developing and adjusting the current body of text. Harris reaffirms that revising is not simply editing for spelling in grammar, but rather revising focuses on building upon the text that is already developed.…

    • 297 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the 2007 Douglas Downs and Wardle article, "Teaching about Writing, Righting Misconceptions, the focus is on the topic of how to operate a successful first year college writing class. Douglas Downs and Wardle discuss a change to the way in with first-year writing instruction had been taught. The change purposed was based on the results of a test course they developed. The goal of the course was to encourage more realistic conceptions of writing. Douglas Downs and Wardle focus on the concept of Writing about Writing (WAW).…

    • 1467 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Jane Cogie’s paper, “Avoiding the Proofreading Trap: The Value of the Error Correction Process.” Cogie advocates for writing center tutors to resist becoming “cultural informants”. Where when there are “relatively few sentence-level errors, the cultural informant approach… can begin to feel a lot like proofreading, with the student becoming increasing passive, knowing that the tutor will be there to help.” From there, the other authors in the piece introduce a frankly, excessive, chart that promote students to us a “learner’s dictionary minimal marking, and error logs.” I disagreed with Cogie’s argument because I believe there is value in being a cultural informant to non-native students.…

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His audience is focused on other teachers who require essays, students and any individuals who reads his essay. His credibility is strengthened through the use of professional writers and experiences of that relate to poor writing or strict grading. In additon, because he is an english teacher and discuess other professions, who we can asume are also educators requiring writing assignements in their course materical, his paper is more valid. The text he uses is sophisticated yet understandable in a way that becomes informative and empathetic. Although his tone could both strength his paper and word choice because he tends to lead towards an towards an informal tone which makes it difficult to follow his reasoning and believe he is a professional; this also allows students to relate to the lack of conventions.…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Their goal was to develop “good analytical writing,” which not…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When reading The Everyday Writer, written by Andrea A. Lunsford, director of the program in writing and rhetoric at Stanford University, I realized the importance of revising and reviewing of writing. Learning the process of writing will help greatly; therefore, assignments in the future will be more advanced and proper. In fact, peer editing is a fantastic strategy for the perfect paper; sometimes when one edits their own work they might overlook a few things, having someone else edit the paper gives another perspective to the writing. Being open to another opinion and attaining other opinions can open the mind to improve the writing. Seaman High School, where I attend, offers the Writing Center, ran by students and staff is to help improve…

    • 195 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Society constantly progresses at a rate unfathomable to even individuals 20 years ago. The catalyst for such progression? Discoveries. Moreover, discoveries which occur through calculated predictions, or most importantly unexpected results/mistakes or risks. Moreover, if it wasn't for mistakes and taking risks our society wouldn't have gotten to its current state; for mistakes can help people view past discoveries in a different angle or reveal flaws which we can improve upon.…

    • 935 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Joseph Harris's Revising

    • 284 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In order to prepare for writing a summary of Joseph Harris’s “Revising”, I first felt it was necessary to skim through the article once again to refresh my memory of the article. After re-reading the article, I tried to identify the main idea that Harris was trying to communicate. I believed that the main point could be identified through Harris’s emphasis on the fact that revising is not just correcting grammatical errors, but rather seeking out these errors was a part of a larger whole. I also referenced our in class discussion to identify the other main points of the article. From there, I worked on a general idea of what I would talk about in my summary and made note of what order I would do that in.…

    • 284 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The barrier language that I have between Hmong and English is what makes my writing difficult to understand from the start of the school year, not only that, but also just me trying to throughly write an explanation of what I have thought of in mind. Sometimes it doesn’t come out on the paper as I have, have in my thoughts. Which in return create flaws in my level one, two, or three writing paper that affect my writing skills. The flaws that I have slightly improve on my writing: create a clear and stronger thesis statement, subject- verb agreement, and transitioning. Constructing a firm claim and allowing the reader to be able to identify which position I’ve take through my writing by creating a rough draft of what I am going to say in…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My life took a drastic change when I transitioned from a public to private school. I ended up at Lighthouse Christian School where I was taught to write research papers. It started with memorizing all the grammar rule and format that was expected from my English teacher, Mrs. Dennis Carroll. At first, I was timid to know the preparation and information before beginning to write a paper. Into one month of school, I received my first writing assignment was gathering background information on…

    • 937 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Parents and teachers often have trouble deciphering what they wrote, and also students struggle with reading their own notes sometimes. Graham remarks that, “All beginning writers struggle with fluency and legibility to some extent, and that inevitably affects their approach to composing. Young writers typically cope with the multiple demands of handwriting and composing by minimizing the composing process (planning, organizing, etc.)” (Graham, 2010, p.50). If there is early attention put into handwriting about student’s legibility there will be a decrease in the likelihood of them becoming poor writers in the…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Reflection is to revise, to rethink and to take a step back and make sure something is at your best preference. This term is one that I always knew existed, but didn’t apply it to my own work or to my own life. However, now that I know exactly where to apply it, I realize it doesn’t have to be only in education. It could be used in education, in one’s career and life says Sandra L. Giles. It’s interesting because I know exactly what it is, yet I never found the urge to actually apply it.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Critical reflection Reflecting back on what I have learnt about myself as a writer is that it is okay to be aware of your weaknesses and using the necessary tools to support and strengthen them. As a writer it is good to step outside of your comfort zone and experiment with new genres. Let your writing take you on an emotional journey, and let your emotions lead your writing into a new journey. As a writer you need to expand your vocabulary and use powerful descriptive words to really create a mental image for your readers. I have learnt to understand the importance of sentence structure, drafting, and proof reading and not over using commas creating sentences that are too long.…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mistakes cannot always be seen as a negative, as you can move on and correct them to better your knowledge. From my first essay this semester to my last I have seen a vigorous amount of improvement. Not only seen in my grades, but in the way my writing has transitioned between paragraphs and topics. This has helped my work flow more and added a keen sense of intelligence. I have seen much improvement in my essays but have seen the most significant change from my first entrance essay “My season”, to my major events essay “Wayward Feelings”, to my final argumentative essay “A Helpful Hand”.…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his article The Process Writing Method (2002), Daniel J. Jarvis summarizes the Process Writing approach as outlined in Gail Heald-Taylor’s book, Whole Language Strategies for ESL Students (1994). Jarvis claims that the method has played an important role in teaching throughout his career. He describes the method while providing examples from his own experience as an ESL teacher. He also demonstrates how he adapted the method by incorporating illustrations into students’ writing. Jarvis provides the reader with the basic stages of a novel approach to teaching writing.…

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays