Barholomae Use Of Error Analysis

Improved Essays
Those who do not write often or feel the process of writing meaningless may not come to agree with the argument that Bartholomae is showing his readers. Bartholomae is arguing that strategy of error analysis. Error analysis is basically the act of reviewing your own failures and learning from them. These failures can be seen in anything that one does in their lifetime. In Bartholomae’s case we are talking about error in writing. Error analysis is commonly used on those who are learning a second language but it is also extremely common for English professors to use when getting their students to become more engaged with their writing skills. With the use of error analysis we as writers have the opportunity to look back at our own writing and gain the knowledge of what we have done …show more content…
If a mistake is missed those who do not agree with this method will argue that you are more likely to make that mistake a second time. However those such as Bartholome see the greatness of error analysis. With the use of error analysis it helps teachers track their own students and see how their writing skills have improved and how the writer is developing. A quote that stood out while I was reading Bartholomae’s The Study of Error was “We need to treat the language of basic writing as language and assume, as we do when writers violate our expectations in more conventional ways, that the unconventional features in the writing are more evidence of intention and that they are, therefore, meaningful, then we can chart systematic choices, individual strategies, and characteristic processes of thought” (340). In this quote Bartholomae is explaining to readers that writers do make mistakes we violate our expectations. As a student who has been writing for years now I can agree with this quote. There has been numerous occasions in which I was writing and I had expected my paper to be

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Shafaq Siddiqui ENGL 1302- Online Prof. Piercy 10-25-2017 Rhetorical Essay How can I compare two articles when one author is clearly questioning the fact whether the right way of composition writing is being taught to the students, whereas the other writer knows for sure what works in teaching composition? The two articles that we will be comparing today are “Are We Teaching Composition All Wrong?” by Joseph R. Teller and “We Know What Works in Teaching Composition” by Doug Hesse. Both of the authors have very different perspectives as to how the students should be taught composition (creative writing) and whether the process of the writing should be more important or the outcome.…

    • 940 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the 2007 Douglas Downs and Wardle article, "Teaching about Writing, Righting Misconceptions, the focus is on the topic of how to operate a successful first year college writing class. Douglas Downs and Wardle discuss a change to the way in with first-year writing instruction had been taught. The change purposed was based on the results of a test course they developed. The goal of the course was to encourage more realistic conceptions of writing. Douglas Downs and Wardle focus on the concept of Writing about Writing (WAW).…

    • 1467 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Jane Cogie’s paper, “Avoiding the Proofreading Trap: The Value of the Error Correction Process.” Cogie advocates for writing center tutors to resist becoming “cultural informants”. Where when there are “relatively few sentence-level errors, the cultural informant approach… can begin to feel a lot like proofreading, with the student becoming increasing passive, knowing that the tutor will be there to help.” From there, the other authors in the piece introduce a frankly, excessive, chart that promote students to us a “learner’s dictionary minimal marking, and error logs.” I disagreed with Cogie’s argument because I believe there is value in being a cultural informant to non-native students.…

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mistakes don’t lead to good, but when they do it’s usually pretty good. Mistakes are needed for discovery,Heinrich Schliemann found out and Percy Spencer. Heinrich Schliemann was an archaeologist and was reckless when it came to digging. Percy Spencer left a candy bar in his pocket near a Magnetron and made a discovery which lead to the microwave. On the other hand, mistakes can be pretty costly.…

    • 395 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    n the article “ 4 Reasons to Embrace Your Mistakes, as Told by a ‘Wrongologist’’’ Jenni Gritters mentions Kathryn Schulz’s opinion that when people avoid making mistakes , they are actually making a mistake. We don’t get upset while we do something wrong the real problem begins once we discover that we actually made one just like the Wile E. coyote. We should rely on learning from our mistakes not blaming ourselves for the mistake in this case we can be successful. Being perfect is something that all of the people desire but as a matter of fact it is not a good habit and it can cause us harm in so many ways.…

    • 181 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Roy Peter Clark’s essay, “I Won’t Use Writing as Punishment, I Won’t…,” proposes to eradicate the predisposed thought that writing is a penalty for doing something wrong. The analysis of feelings by Sigmund Freud in comparison to the punishment and reward system of B.F. Skinner, introduced students to the predisposed phobia of writing that has been embedded by our education system. Clark pints out that teachers petition the use of writing to gain control and create the impression that writing is an instructive and beneficial tool. However, writing used as punishment, offers no constructive fundamentals of education.…

    • 193 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Their goal was to develop “good analytical writing,” which not…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Writing Etiquette While reading the letters written by Abigail and John Adams, I noticed that they were written differently than if someone from today’s society had written them. They were written well, clearly thought out and pleasantly worded. There may have been an occasional misspelled word; however, despite that, it is obvious that both Adams were highly intelligent. It is a shame that people today do not give the same careful attention to their written communications. Writing properly has become a lost art.…

    • 430 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The barrier language that I have between Hmong and English is what makes my writing difficult to understand from the start of the school year, not only that, but also just me trying to throughly write an explanation of what I have thought of in mind. Sometimes it doesn’t come out on the paper as I have, have in my thoughts. Which in return create flaws in my level one, two, or three writing paper that affect my writing skills. The flaws that I have slightly improve on my writing: create a clear and stronger thesis statement, subject- verb agreement, and transitioning. Constructing a firm claim and allowing the reader to be able to identify which position I’ve take through my writing by creating a rough draft of what I am going to say in…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After reading the article, “The Maker’s Eye” by Donal Murray, I agree with the author on how writing isn’t a one step process and one strategies to become better writers. Murray states that when writers write and pause to look at others point of view, they go back and change their writing. It is true when he says that most writers are harsh on their writing and themselves. Reflecting upon myself and high school years, I believe that it’s true to look at other’s point of view and edit because I knew I wasn’t the best writer therefore making me not believing in myself. Murray explains the lack of editing and rewriting and its true that most students these days will only write one draft and believe they are done after that.…

    • 955 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many people struggle with the thought of failing, though failing is not the real thing you should be worried about, but rather the actions taken afterwards to improve your wrongs. Biologist Lewis Thomas describes this as being “ the very base of human thought, embedded there, feeding the structure like root nodules.” Without the mistake there is nothing to grow from and expand your knowledge on. If you were to get everything correct at all times there would be nothing to educate yourself with after the fact, making the reaction to be considered worthless. The beginning of mistakes is the beginning to a new solution that has not been discovered yet.…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Critical reflection Reflecting back on what I have learnt about myself as a writer is that it is okay to be aware of your weaknesses and using the necessary tools to support and strengthen them. As a writer it is good to step outside of your comfort zone and experiment with new genres. Let your writing take you on an emotional journey, and let your emotions lead your writing into a new journey. As a writer you need to expand your vocabulary and use powerful descriptive words to really create a mental image for your readers. I have learnt to understand the importance of sentence structure, drafting, and proof reading and not over using commas creating sentences that are too long.…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    English 101 became better than predicted once the fear of procrastination disappeared, the writing became an expression. I feel now that I can write without being judged, and I can make the mistakes I need in order to excel. Likewise, the feeling of being confident in writing is the uttermost important lesson that this class has provided me with. Writing is not something that should be feared, but something that should be…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I have always considered my relationship with writing to be very insignificant. Although I enjoy spending time verbally expressing my thoughts and feelings to others, it becomes difficult when these thoughts and feelings are expressed through writing. Throughout my adolescent years, I would often receive feedback for my writing given by the teacher in the form of a grade. Being unable to effectively organize my thoughts and ideas into words and sentences, I would feel reluctant to continue writing confidently whenever I received an undesirable grade.…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Last year, I was stuck on the myth of perfect first drafts. When I was assigned a writing assignment, I would go straight to writing; no planning or actual thinking. And as soon as I would finish my paper, I would turn it in. I was so confident that my paper was perfect, but when I received my paper back, it was not the grade I had expected; I was very upset considering I had devoted so much time into that paper.…

    • 140 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays