Pros And Cons Of Government Neoliberalism

Superior Essays
The theorist in this book sets out to show that penalization alone is not the answer to our current crime problems. Loïc Wacquant states that law and order and the penal system have distorted reality and created a crime issue. This claim asserts that the state has convinced the people that there is a crisis in the country and its was and is caused by the welfare state. According to the state the assistance given to the needy is causing the country to experience more crime the ideas of neoliberalism will change all that. The ideas of governmental neoliberalism consist of privatization of public systems such as the penal system, education, health and others. The neoliberal government is based on de-socialization of the people. It requires the …show more content…
Aspects remain, but the penal state took over. The state is symbolized by the Centaur. The centaur has a human upper body, and this is how the state views middle and upper class, as human. The bottom half of the Centaur is the beast, and this is the symbol the state uses for the lower and underclass, this is the class that needs to be tamed and programed to properly participate in society. Mass incarceration is the answer for those who cannot survive in the unequal state they have been forced into. The lower classes are pitted against the state, while the state caters to the upper class. Privatization and bureaucratization have become key to the marginalization of these people. As aid is removed, those who could not adjust became targets of the new state, this group consisted primarily of minority …show more content…
Garlands understanding of punishment is being to gain control. Control is needed because the neoliberal reaction has created a criminological predicament that is fueled by a state’s failing political endeavor and the attempt to cover it. Wacquant does not share this same sentiment and sees the workings of the state as a political success. Garland sees a crumbling system while Wacquant sees a revived state the can deliver justice. Garland also sees the states a lot of crime a little justice and a split reaction by the state. The cohesion Wacquant sees within the state to maintain control through tension while Garlands view is both an over and under reaction by the state. Bourdieu view is like Wacquant’s theory of the state. Bourdieu views an adaptive one that is limited in its responses to prevent crime and in return relies on penal part of the bureaucracy. He sees the actions of the government as several forces within the government competing for contracts and other public goods and striving to attain more definitions of the people and groups. These definitions, as stated before, give power. Garland approach deals with a reaction of a state in panic attempting to maintain control. Wacquant saw both aspects, he saw that states response of penalization as both an adaptation and acting out, at the administrative level and the political level response

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Civil Disobedience Mahatma Gandhi states, “Civil disobedience becomes a sacred duty when the State becomes lawless or, which is the same thing, corrupt” (Gandhi). Furthermore, within the dystopian world that Aldous Huxley proposes in “Brave New World,” the government is diminishing due to corruption. The society full of enslaved people are forced into conformity and dehumanization. These schemes that are conducted are pioneered by Ford, the Controller, and enforced by the Director. It is until Bernard and John the Savage start to question the corrupt government and propose civil disobedience to bring the society to realization and independence.…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Once money is added into the equation, we are left with both positive and negatives outcomes in society as a whole. Positive outcomes being progression and economic growth, and negative outcomes being greed and corruption. This connects back to the idea of people in power, who will inevitably influence society toward negative outcomes. The greed and corruption in government can cause criminal behavior, which according to Locke’s theory, is breaking the law of nature (better known as human reason) which everyone must…

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both texts discuss the dehumanization that comes from controlling Governments. George Orwell highlights Government methods of control and manipulation placed on societies and Fritz Lang demonstrates the great class struggle that comes with this implemented divide within society. However the two have very different messages. Lang demonstrates a hope and trust in mankind that all can be renewed if a problem is noticed and the masses come together to fight for equality however Orwell highlights a pessimistic view that an enforced dehumanization by a controlling Governing power will lead to a society that becomes unthinking, masses who will not rebel and the dehumanization of even those who…

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Tilly, the government claims to protect its citizens from outside threats, but the threats may have been created because of the actions of the government. By creating real or fictitious threats of war, the overall welfare of the people within society is threatened. Another way that the government shapes the state is by controlling violence. This control could be asserted through various ways including harm of people or property and the violation of desires and interests (Kivisto 245). By the government using war and violence to shape a state, Tilly believed that it could lead to democracy because their rights as citizens were not readily available to them.…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thomas More's Utopia

    • 1273 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The establishment of Tallstoria empowers More to criticise judicial aspects of society and provide a logical solution to the complications of the legal system simultaneously. Furthermore, in Book 2, More frames the argument that Utopians efficaciously utilise criminals as slaves, as opposed to imposing capital punishment through the rhetorical question, “Just how absurd it is to punish theft and murder in the same way” to emphasise his idea that execution is not rational. Moreover, the simile in Raphael’s dialogue “They say it’s just as unpleasant for the criminals as capital punishment and more useful to society” provides profound support for the Utopian model of justice as well as harsh criticism for executions. Additionally, More asserts the notion that capital punishment is not a viable solution in…

    • 1273 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The conflict view is that crime is a political concept created by the ‘haves’, those who powerful and have influence, and the ‘have-nots’, who are the working class, in order to maintain control over society. The conflict view believes that ‘true crimes’ are violations of human rights due to issues such as imperialism, sexism, and racism, police brutality, price-fixing, unsafe working conditions, and crimes of economic and political domination to name a few. One of the other major differences between the conflict ideation and the positive and classical schools of thought is that positive and classical schools view punishment as just response for crimes. The conflict view believes that the majority of those who are punished are the ‘have-nots’, who can be serious charged for minor violations whereas the ‘haves’ or the wealthy receive more lenient…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Their arguments are valid as they have observed and analyzed the economic dictatorships, puppet regimes, different rules and regulations of tax payments and the money system that it is to understand that they are being oppressed and repressed by the same government that has been elected and supported by the general public over the years. The new era has emerged; the generation of the OS13 would not stay blind, dumb, ignorant and tolerant to the kind of repression and oppression that are showered towards them. If the general public denies the rules and regulations imposed by the government and unify in masses in order to go up against and resist against the same government, then it is impossible for the government to stand a…

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With this in mind, the producers of Dexter make both a idealistic and realistic claim: the ideals of modern justice are catching criminals and penalizing them for their crimes, yet because the legal system and the people who serve it are flawed, the producers seek to critique the definition of justice and who has the right to enforce justice. This claim is most prominent in a flashback scene wherein, the…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Law and Justice Make Humanity When people are being killed by the people charged to protect them, there exists a large problem in a country as great as this one’s justice system. When said justice system is accused of skewed against a great fraction of the population, something needs to change. On the topic of criminal justice reform, both Hillary Clinton and Rand Paul decided that change is necessary. Rand Paul states that the cause of the militarization of police stations across the country is big government. Hillary Clinton, however, presents the idea that the cause is a lack of trust.…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Federal taxes or also known as the sixteenth amendment should be repealed because it interferes with people 's money and financial income to much. The 16th amendment has stirred up a lot of controversy in the country and taxes is one of the hot topics both destabilizing and developing the American economy; Taxes ties into politics in and of itself, taxes is a destructive and or developing moral within the people today and is sometimes not even used for its original purpose or intent, which is to support America 's economy and build its reputation. Some actions reveal the abuses of government. The 16th amendment is used to suck dry the American people of their financial state so that the governing system can benefit. The American people in and of itself is a system of different subjects focused on the same goal.…

    • 1100 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays