Australian Legal System Analysis

Improved Essays
English colonisation of Australia was problematic due to the British lack of acknowledgement of indigenous people’s proprietorship of the land for thousands of years. When English settlers colonised Australia, their actions suggested the land was terra nullius; a legal doctrine claiming land to be ‘occupied by no one’ (Bailey, 1997). Under this principle the British government colonised Australia establishing British sovereignty and imposing their laws to govern the land under the Crown (Indigenous Notes). However, terra nullius does not legitimize British colonization of Australia as there was little or no negotiation with indigenous inhabitants, due to British beliefs that indigenous people were inferior to white settlers; colonists were …show more content…
Overrepresentation of Aboriginal people in the legal system (statistics indicate Aboriginal people are 13 times more likely to be incarcerated than non-Aboriginal people ) remains a complicated issue caused by social, economic and political factors, causing great indigenous disadvantage. Whilst indigenous people comprise less than two per cent of the total population they make up approximately nineteen per cent of the prison population due to inherent problems in traditional criminal justice system responses to processes and to the indigenous individuals offending. Criticism of the Australian Legal System suggests that the system may be working exactly how it was intended to; refined by privileged civilians with unintentional but present discrimination towards indigenous individuals. This indicates the system may not be damaged, but must adjust to comply with our progressive societal values.
The relationship between Indigenous Australians and the Australian Legal System did not initiate positively, changing only after Mabo and the invalidation of terra nullius as the legal system moved positively towards acknowledging Indigenous disadvantage and cultural uniqueness. To advance Indigenous Australians rights in our legal system, programs enabling indigenous groups to engage in the community and legal system need to be maintained. Furthermore, these problems can only be resolved by understanding the issues causing disadvantages towards Indigenous

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    INTRODUCTION This essay examines the Australian court hierarchy, and the extension power the High Court attains as it has the ability too overturn decisions made by the Supreme Court. As it is the final court of appeal therefore reintegrates the point that the power of appointment is held within the body of the High Court. As the Australian Federal system consists of national court and a court system for each individual state and the two territories.…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Murri Court Case Study

    • 213 Words
    • 1 Pages

    The Murri Court operates under the goodwill of the Magistrate in collaboration with section 9 (2) (o) of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld). The legislation states that if the offender is an Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander person then three things can be taken into account: the offender’s relationship to their community; or any cultural considerations; or any considerations relating to programs and services established for offenders in which the community justice group participates. The magistrate of this court is assisted in a number of ways by Indigenous Elders. The Elders assist the magistrate by advising them on cultural issues, providing background information about the offender, explaining to the offender, if required,…

    • 213 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A significant event for the civil rights of Aboriginals and Torres Strait Islander people was the Mabo Decision which occurred in 1982 and ended in 1992. The Mabo Decision a case for which Eddie Koiki Mabo fought for the tradition rights and ownership of the Island of Mer otherwise known as Murray Island. During 1788 Australia was claimed ‘Terra Nullius’ by the British and as a result all land that traditionally belonged to the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders was taken away. Soon Aboriginals didn’t have the rights of the land that they lived on and were not counted as an Australian citizens. Eddie Koiki Mabo was an Indigenous activist that fought for the civil rights of Indigenous Australians and believed that the land he lived on belonged to his ancestors.…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The population of Indigenous Australians living in Australia is predicted to be approximately 650,000 in 2016, comprising of approximately 2.7% of the total population of Australia (ABS, 2014). Nevertheless, Indigenous Australian youth are consistently over-represented in the CJS, as both offenders and victims (Carpenter and Ball, 2012, 91). A report published by Amnesty International, A Brighter Tomorrow, found that although Indigenous youth only represent 5% of Australia’s population of 10-17 year olds, they make up 59% of their detention. This means that Indigenous youth are 25 times more likely than non-Indigenous youth to be imprisoned (Amnesty International, 2015). These statistics demonstrate disadvantage as more Indigenous youth are in juvenile detention and less are attending school, setting them behind non-Indigenous students academically and thus leading them to lesser opportunities to succeed in life, that is, life chances.…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Australian legal system is adversarial. This means that the parties to a case present evidence and argue their position before a judge who makes a decision based on the law and evidence. For this to be fair the parties usually engage a lawyer who can represent them in court. On 17 December 1986, Olaf Dietrich flew into Melbourne Airport from Thailand. The Australian Federal Police arrested Dietrich for importing at least 70 grams of heroin concealed in condoms that he had swallowed.…

    • 168 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Social and human service workers are likely to become involved with the processes of the Australian legal system as part of their evolving practice. The legal system and human services professions may function in parallel or even mutually opposed. However, they often seek the same outcomes or changes, especially in relation to the disadvantage and protection of vulnerable people (Kennedy, Richards, & Leiman, 2013). This paper will describe a case observed at Beenleigh Magistrates Courthouse, its role and place in the Australian legal hierarchy of courts. Then it will explain the roles and responsibilities of the court personnel, including the potential roles of social work/human services personnel in this case.…

    • 1577 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 2011, Aboriginal people were reported as imprisoned at a rate of 756 per 100,000 in contrast to non-aboriginal Canadians at a rate of only 76 per 100,000 (Jeffries, 2014). However, why are Aboriginal People in Canada overrepresented in prison? Could it be sentencing policies or are these citizens more harmful to society? Many factors are involved in this presumption, including high rates of poverty, substance abuse, and a large percentage of judges will decide jail for their sentence even when there are laws against jail being the first option. Even with laws put into place to consider other alternatives, judges have the final say and most of these Aboriginal people are still sent to jail over rehabilitation (Jeffries, 2014).…

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Opinion Essay: Over-representation of Aboriginals as Offenders Amy Brown ID #201591413 Diversity and the Justice System – CRJS 1013-001 Professor Aulakh Harpreet Tuesday, February 3. 2015 In 2006, Statistics Canada found that 21% of people sentenced to custody and 18.5% in federal institutions were in fact of aboriginal descent (King & Winterdyk, 2010, p. 63). In a graph presented in the text by King and Winterdyk (2010), from Statistics Canada, the graph suggests the highest percent of over-representation of aboriginals were found in Saskatchewan, Manitoba and Yukon (p. 64). This information given provides a hard truth in our country, and I believe it exists for several reasons. The reasons being that First Nations are being over-represented in the justice system is due to alcoholism, violence, and residential schools.…

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The exclusion of Indigenous people from the nations constitution took place in the early nineteenth century. Henry Parkes the premier of the colony of New South Wales called for all six Australian colonies to unite and create a great national government for ALL of Australia. Parkes initiated a constitution based on common racial and British custom on which this nation was supposedly founded. Throughout her speech “Indigenous Exceptionalism and the Constitutional ‘Race Power’ Marcia Langton argues that any idea of race and the ability of the parliament to use race in law making should be removed from the Australian constitution. The detailed history of legislation applied to Indigenous peoples demonstrates this is many ways; Indigenous people…

    • 1170 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Aboriginal youth are overrepresented in Ontario correctional facilities at a much higher rate than Aboriginal adults. Canadian Aboriginals are more likely to be charged with crimes, particularly on reserves then non-aboriginal Canadians. Also even though Aboriginals account for 4% of the Canadian population, but they account for 20% of Canada's prison population. Adult aboriginals are more likely to be convicted of a crime at 6 times higher than the national rate. Also parole is denied at a higher rate than non-aboriginals.…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example, 28% of aboriginal prisoners in New South Wales (NSW) prisons were intoxicated at the time of the offence that led to their imprisonment (Butler, Levy, Dolan, & Kaldor, 2003). In addition, the results from McDonald (1992) national survey on aboriginal Australian detainment, found that 46% of police aboriginal arrests were for public drunkenness. The examples discussed, highlight that alcohol misuse is a contributing factor to aboriginal contact with the criminal justice system and raises great concern for aboriginal communities as alcohol related crime and public drunkenness for aborigines is three times the proportion among non-Aborigines (Kahn, Hunter, Heather, & Tebbutt,…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The overrepresentation of indigenous people is a substantial issue in our country that requires attention in order to maintain a positive relationship with the Aboriginals and remove any negative stigmatization against the indigenous culture (Welsh & Ogloff, 2008, pp. 492-494). This remains an issue in our society because there are increasing numbers of indigenous people in prison throughout the provinces due to systemic racism within the legal system, crimes committed due to socioeconomic challenges and cultural or language barriers (Fitzgerald & Carrington, 2008, pp. 524-525). Moreover, alternative courses of action should be addressed in order to decrease the overrepresentation of indigenous people in the criminal justice system.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How is Aboriginal Incarceration rates being addressed and how viable are these legal solutions? Circle sentencing is an alternative method of sentencing adult Indigenous offenders. It involves the local Indigenous people to get directly involved in the process of issuing sentences to the offenders, with aims of making the criminal justice system a little more meaningful and also confidence improving.…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    "Given the history of the European colonisation of Australia, many Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people are wary of white institutions and social welfare’ (Chenoweth & McAuliffe 2015, p.268). Identify and discuss one or two policies or pieces of legislation that have impacted on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people and how the effects can be seen today. During the European colonisation of Australia, oppressive laws functioned to subjugate and control the indigenous population. The Aborigines Protection Act, 1909 (APA) (Cth) and the child removal policy were particularly devastating, stripping Indigenous people of basic human rights and freedoms, and robbing generations of their connection to their families and culture. Although the Act was abolished in 1969, the trauma…

    • 1586 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Australian Pride

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Australian Pride Australia being a nation of wealth and prosperity, that dignifies itself on its “Aussie pride” rather than human rights is the main reason as to why we haven 't secured a seat at the United Nations human rights council (UNHRC). While Australia is commendable for some of its approaches to HR, they continue to face issues with their harsh mandatory detention and turn back policy as well as over representation of indigenous people in the criminal justice system. Additionally, Australia continues to struggle to find a balance between national security and HR, thus causing difficulties to maintain the unbiased and democratic ideals of our multicultural country. The problem with Australia is that issues are recognised and talked…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays