'Teach Writing As A Process Not Product'

Improved Essays
Article Synthesis The article by Janet Atkins, “Reading and Writing with Purpose: In and Out of School,” talks about how teachers should teach with a student’s purpose and passion in mind. Donald Murray’s article, “Teach Writing as a Process Not Product,” discusses his view that teachers should teach writing as a process, not a product. Both articles touch on how to teach English, though the message they convey is different. Both articles share several common rhetorical concepts, but differ others, they have a common audience and purpose, while their message is different. Atkin’s article is tailored heavily towards teachers of English. Atkins consistently uses language and examples that are deliberately chosen to have the best impact possible on teachers. In her article, she states “we need to be active, engaged readers and writers ourselves” (Atkins 13). Her word choice shows that she intended the article to be read by teachers, talking about how “we” as teachers …show more content…
In the first sentence of the article, Murray states “Most of us are trained as English teachers by studying a product” (Murray 3). From the first sentence, it is clear what audience he wrote this for. He assumes that the audience is teachers, that is who he is writing to. This is evident throughout the article; he talks about how the person reading the article can improve their teaching. He continually talks to the audience as if they were teachers. For example, in the 3rd page, he writes “How do you motivate your student to pass through this process?” (5). Murray talks directly to the audience, about how they can improve their teaching. By having a clear audience, and talking directly to his audience, he is able to better convey his message. Murray can talk directly to teachers, telling them how best they can improve their teaching methods, something that would be more difficult if he had a wider

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Stephen King, in his piece “What Writing Is”, claims that “it’s writing, damn it, not washing the car or putting on eyeliner. If you can take it seriously, we can do business”. Not only is writing an intellectual and reflective activity, it is a vital skill in all fields of work and academia, and can be learned through abundant reading and practice. Effective and engaging writing can bring about change. Claim:…

    • 1883 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They argue that there are five key principles that underlie the various critical approaches to teaching basic writers. These principles included assuming all students are capable of learning, engage students in student-centered work, address “higher order” issues alongside “lower-ordered” issues, integrate academic writing and reading instruction, and embrace the conflict between what they already know and what they need to learn (21). Mutnick and Lamos suggest that there are four major basic writer pedagogical approaches that go with theoretical changes since its conception. One of the four approaches is error centered, which is based on Shaughnessy’s theory of the logic of errors. They focus on the student’s errors he/she produces, view Standard Written English as “normative and neutral rather than ideological and culturally biased” and are still used to help students learn grammar conventions (22).…

    • 922 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Red Pen Rhetoric Analysis

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Some people have been lucky enough to experience the privilege of being educated. Whether or not one has been educated, he or she knows education is an important life aspect because it allows people to learn valuable life lessons and skills. Everyone has their own views on which teaching style is the best, including Mr. Steve Wyrick. In an argumentative essay entitled, “Red-Pen Rhetoric: Looking at the Response to Student Writing in Freshman College Composition Courses,” graduate student and teacher assistant, Mr. Steven T. Wyrick, focuses on what he believes to be the best relationship between student and teacher.…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brooks was unable to encourage all of her students to stay engaged in the material, and she was unable to influence her students to love reading and writing (p.93). Brooks stated that some of her students who did engage in the material only wrote poetry for the entirety of the year. She could not encourage her students to explore different genres of literature, and her time-constraint made it difficult to successfully transition into new genres in a way that encourage further literature exploration (p.94). Brooks expressed that even though she followed Atwell’s advice, she could not engage all the students in her class. Brooks admires Atwell’s beliefs, however in her opinion the beliefs published in In the Middle do not fully explain how a teacher can apply Atwell’s theories within their own classroom.…

    • 2432 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Journal Response The chapter “Helping Writers Think Rhetorically” by John C. Bean describes how important it is to have students thinking about their audience and purpose before starting to write their compositions. Bean explains how thinking about a targeted audience will give the writers a better idea about their audiences´ thinking before reading their papers and the expectations after having read their works. In the study, Bean comments that most of the times students mistake by thinking of their teacher as their only audience for their composition project. Therefore, Bean highlights the need to have students practicing writing to imaginary audiences in order to develop their skills to target different mindsets using different rhetorical…

    • 585 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If these “experienced readers” are so good and still manage to fail in some areas, when are we going to be good enough to carve this skill to perfection. Teachers are into this too, this article refers to both students and teachers because everybody needs to upgrade in something. I observed that Haas and Flower’s article was meant for teachers as well when they said, “Seeing reading as a constructive act encourages us as teachers to move from merely teaching texts to teaching readers” (Haas & Flower 169) as well as “Many of our students are “good” readers” (Haas & Flower…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Jerone Hunkins, a first year student, attends the University of St. Martin and is currently obtaining an Associate’s Degree in General Liberal Arts. In the English Composition II course, she has learnt how to write various essays such as the Beliefs and Values, Argumentative, Art Critique Essay. She learned when it is appropriate to be objective and subjective, how to write an essay without using personal pronouns and how to critique her peer’s essay bearing in mind that people have different backgrounds. Furthermore, she has mastered the art of critiquing, by providing both positive and negative feedback. In addition, she has improved her exhibition of the MLA format.…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The National Curriculum (2014) and the impact it can have on teaching pupils Literacy In Primary Education, teachers are responsible for ensuring pupils reach age – related expectations which are noted in the National Curriculum (NC) (2014). The NC provides statutory and non – statutory guidance for every subject including English which assists teachers. The purpose of the programmes of study in the NC is for teachers to understand what pupils need to learn and helps teachers to plan effective lessons. The NC covers aims which include the teacher’s responsibilities to: “Promote high standards of language and literacy by equipping pupils with a strong command of the spoken word and written word, and to develop their love of literature through widespread reading for enjoyment” (DfE, 2014: 13). The aims also comprise conventional literacy skills which the National Early Literacy Panel…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Through the following three essays, “Why I Write,” by George Orwell, “Why I Write,” by Joan Didion, and “A Way of Writing,” by William Stafford, a reader can interpret the importance of writing in daily lives. The three authors discuss the significance of writing and it has impacted their personal lives. I was most compelled by Joan Didion’s “Why I Write” because of its ability to encourage everyone to develop an interest in he topic.…

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “ I had to demonstrate that I was not the stereotypical English teacher: a fussbudget who would pick through their essays in search of misspellings and trivial errors.” (605) Connor's first experience teaching was not successful although he had his mind set for what he wanted the students weren’t doing what he wanted them to do making his approach unsuccessful. “So, in my second year, I answered the questions with a 50-minute lecture. … which argued that people write better when they don’t worry about spelling.” (605) This year he decided to take a similar approach, but explain the reason why to his students.…

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The extent to which schools provide for true education, to which is the actuality of learning versus memorizing, is set more in thought than towards the reality of what students need to excel. Schools play an important factor in a student’s success, so a failing or succeeding one sets up a student for failure or success in the future. “The ultimate price we pay for a failed school is the loss of hope for present and future generations - a price we simply can’t afford to pay any longer.” Waiting for Superman, page 80. A student’s success begins in school, to which a failing one has consequently failed the student.…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lucy Calkins Writing Style

    • 1371 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Lucy Calkins advocates that students need to write about personal stories, or what matters most to them (Calkins & Harwayne, 1991). Writing with a purpose is a major part of writing workshop (Calkins & Harwayne, 1987). I will go more in depth, on the topic of writing with a purpose, in the motivation section of this paper. Self-assessments are another key component during independent writing time (Calkins, Hohne, & Robb, 2015). Lucy Calkins, et al.…

    • 1371 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As I think about my experiences throughout the semester of English 101, I have realized that I have learned some very important requirements that are important to help improve my writing. “Progress is impossible without change, and those who cannot change their minds cannot change anything (George Bernard Shaw).” During this course, reading and comprehending the materials given was not only a tough task for me but it was also demanding. I was challenged to change my thought process on what it was to be a good writer. The concept of understanding the value of correctly communicating thoughts differs from learning to apply the techniques needed to communicate successfully.…

    • 1486 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Literacy Reflection

    • 1082 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Reading and writing is everywhere in this world and as teachers we must push our students to understand literacy no matter what content we are teaching. Literacy is included in all subjects, it might not be the main source of a certain subject but it is important in every subject. Other teachers might not understand that literacy is needed for every course that they teach. In the article Literacy and Language as Learning in Content-Area Classes: A Departure From "Every Teacher a Teacher of Reading" Douglas Fisher and Gay Ivey explains why literacy is important in every subject. Literacy has now been a national focus and is receiving the attention that is requiring for students to become successful.…

    • 1082 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    381). It is important for educators to understand that children need specific experiences with written texts in order for them to grasp a stronger understanding about the ‘communicative nature of written texts’ and ground specific purposes of the texts that have been written (Fellowes & Oakley 2016, p. 392). This understanding could be beneficial to me as a practitioner, where I am required to instruct writing for young children that allows them to move from unconventional forms of writing to more conventional ways (Watanabe & Hall-Kenyon…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics