Campus Carry Analysis

Improved Essays
The campus carry law refers to policies that allow appropriately licensed students and faculty to carry a handgun on campus as long as the gun is hidden from sight. Several states, including Texas, have passed a bill allowing campus carry; as a result, polarizing debates have ensued over the effectiveness of the law, or more specifically, whether campus carry is truly effective in decreasing gun violence on campus. In the article “How Guns Could Censor College Classrooms” the author, Firmin DeBrabander, argues against the law allowing the concealed carry of firearms in college campuses. DeBrabander believes that “[c]ampus carry will make students and faculty less inclined to engage in the critical intellectual work that must take place in the …show more content…
To begin the article, he includes several quotes from the University of Houston’s faculty members such as, “ ‘[b]e careful discussing sensitive topics’ ‘[d]rop certain topics from your curriculum’ ‘[don’t] go there if you sense anger’ ” (DeBrabander). Starting his article with these quotes, DeBrabander tries to grab the audiences attention, while setting up his argument that guns would censor the classrooms. Throughout the text, the author uses phrases such as, “open discussion”, and “free speech” (DeBrabander). He includes such phrases—which suggest freedom—knowing that his intended audience care about such issues, thus helping to influence his readers to stand against guns on campus. To further persuade the readers—especially students and professors—the author also tries to appeal to the emotion of concern about the effects of campus censorship and abandonment of intellectual engagement. He does so by stating that allowing guns to censor intellectual debate is “damaging to the country’s democracy” and a “threat to free speech”; furthermore, there will be a “lack of creativity among new generations of voters”, and the “American democracy will be poorer for it” …show more content…
For people who are concerned about the possibility of losing freedom of speech and expression and intellectual engagement in classrooms, this article may be convincing, especially since it’s written by a professor with expertise in political theory. However, this article will be difficult to persuade the opposing side. One reason for that is the people arguing in support of campus carry might value their right to exercise the second amendment more than the right to freedom of speech or intellectual engagement in classrooms. Furthermore, they prioritize their safety over intellectual engagement. Also, as mentioned by Hsiao, one of the weaknesses of DeBrabander’s article is that his critique of guns on campus is not very open minded and he does not provide enough empirical data. Thus, people in support of campus carry would consider his article biased, and may be unwilling to believe his

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    For example, when appealing to the academic audience, I will focus on specific data and statistics from faculty, students, and administrators stating their view on gun control and why they should not be allowed on campus. When appealing to the civic audience, I will pretend that my audience is made up of college students. With this I will be able to focus on relating this issue to students because of the controversy of guns being allowed on college campuses. I will discuss the different concerns of administrators, if the law allowing guns on college campuses follows through. This group of college students will generally value the opinions of faculty members.…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Mechanics and Impact of Campus Carry Should students, faculty, and staff be allowed to carry gun on college campus?This has been the controversial topic of gun control in several sates.Tragic events like Sandy Hook elementary, Oregon, Virginia Tech, Umpqua Community College and UT in 1966 inspired legislature too sanction conceal weapons in college campus. Senate bill 11 pass and will take place in August 2016 in all public Texas university.There is an abundance of feeling about Senate bill 11but the overall concern is safety. Safety is the well-being of the students,professor, security in mental and physical. Gun should be allow on college campus because they will offer safety, it 's a constitutional right, and will accustom person to…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Concealed Carry In Schools

    • 1401 Words
    • 6 Pages

    For instance, Fiske reports, a former Navy SEAL does not think the students will be safe having guns on campus. Therefore, by keeping guns off campus will not guarantee safety for students. Thirdly, it also affects the academics. To illustrate, Fiske tells a neuroscience professor Max Snodderly, that it is an “encroachment on academic freedom.” Hence, keeping guns away from school affects not only safety but also academics. For all these reasons, the new Texas gun law is receiving…

    • 1401 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Allowing students to have a concealed carry permit will only create more possible violence on college and university campuses, therefore this should not be allowed. The people that are for the right to have concealed handguns on campus argue many good points. They say that permitting guns on campuses would allow students to defend themselves from anything that will harm them, making people think…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In other words, Taylor Woolrich is arguing how colleges should all students the right to carry a concealed weapon in order to protect themselves in a life or death situation. In addition, Taylor has also stated that she carries mace and has considered carrying a taser but feels that without a gun, she cannot defend herself from any attackers…

    • 1226 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A two part comparative public notice image. Both signs would be posted in the parking lot and entrance to a school. The image is clearly designed to deter crime on the campus. A sign that states that the teachers are not only armed but are also trained would prevent another school tragedy. In the state of Texas legislators are hotly debating the benefits of allowing guns on college campuses.…

    • 520 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    William Spelman, a Public Affairs professor at UT and a working group members said that the possibility of guns being banned from classrooms is unlikely due to the fear of the Texas Legislature or the Board of Regents overturning the ban. The rules and regulations enacted will mostly focus on establishing gun free zones such as facilities that contain dangerous lab equipment and locations that sell alcohol. Also gun safety and gun storage for concealed handgun owners. On Sept. 31, and Oct. 5, the University of Texas held a forum for people to share their concerns and opinions to the working group. Speakers stepped up to the microphone to share their opinion, with a majority of speakers speaking against SB 11, urging the working group to implement the most restrictive policies…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Campus Carry Impact

    • 1214 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Mechanics and Impact of Campus Carry Should students, faculty, and staff be allowed to carry gun on college campus?This has been the controversial topic of gun control in several sates.Tragic events like Sandy Hook elementary, Oregon, Virginia Tech, Umpqua Community College and UT in 1966 inspired legislature too sanction conceal weapons in college campus. Senate bill 11 pass and will takes place in August 2016 in all public Texas university.There is an abundance of feeling about Senate bill 11but the overall concern is safety. Safety is the well being of the students,professor, security in mental and physical. Gun should be allow on college campus because they will provide safety, its a constitutional right, and will accustom individual…

    • 1214 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    According to Haidt and Lukianoff, “The ultimate aim, it seems, is to turn campuses into ‘safe spaces’ where young adults are shielded from words and ideas that make some uncomfortable” (Haidt and Lukianoff 44). To the students, the goal is to create restrictions on the academic discussions about uncomfortable topics by implanting trigger warnings. To them, trigger warnings will help them feel more comfortable in collage by knowing what material to expect as they can plan to skip the lesson. While trigger warnings makes them feel more secure, it destroys the purpose of universities. Universities help strengthen students’ academic minds and to prepare them for the real world.…

    • 1517 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Due to all the recent disturbances of violent shootings on college campuses, many have argued that both students and teachers should be allowed to carry a concealed handgun on campus to defend themselves. These people who are suggesting this are only thinking about their own safety and not thinking about the consequences that will flourish due to guns on campus. Guns on campus would not only lead to an escalation in violent crimes, but will lead to an increase in the number of suicides by college students. Guns on campuses would also distract from a learning environment. Imagine how uncomfortable most students would feel knowing that one of their classmates may or may not be carrying a weapon of their choice around campus.…

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays