Plato And Aristotle Analysis

Improved Essays
Human beings are often misunderstood because of the various beliefs that each possesses. Whether it is a view that happiness comes from material things or whether it comes from non-material things, live in care for your soul. Both Plato and Aristotle have their respective views on the way that they believe is the greatest of human beings. Plato takes the approach that is contemplative which the main point is that theory and intellectual contemplation of ultimate truths are best in life. Aristotle takes a political view where you have to be involved on politics and informed in what is going on to be able to achieve the highest good for yourself. Whether it is a contemplative or political approach, both have strong arguments as to why a person …show more content…
“Wisdom is both our highest good and the ability to use other goods well and beneficially. So, wisdom should be the first concern of anyone who wants to live well and be happy—that is, everyone” (Shaw). Plato believes that wisdom is more important than goods such as health and honor. He expresses that through his writing The Republic. In The Republic, he tells the story about the prisoner that was able to escape and get out of the cave. The person that was able to escape would choose to stay outside the cave and contemplate his life from the cave. Plato states that the most fulfilling activity for man is mental activity. “Plato says that happiness is the possession, or the possession and correct use, of goods” (Shaw 2). Plato’s thinking is that if you possess things that will make you happy, but there is also that possession of bad things. He thinks that we do everything for the sake of happiness and we do not need anything beyond …show more content…
Plato believes that conflicting interests can be harmonized one way or another. The best way to lead a harmonious unity of society and allows the parts to flourish is thought to be his best political order. Unlike Aristotle’s thinking of the theoretical and practical knowledge, Plato believes that they are both impossible to reach without virtue. Plato was involved in politics in his younger life and was influenced by it as well. He was a pupil to Socrates and thought of him as “the most just man of his time” (Korab-Karpowicz 2). When the court voted for Socrates’ execution on an unjust charge, Plato came to the conclusion that government was bad and past the point of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    As philosophers, by contemplating the good they are also closest to the good. They 're happy because they know how to act in accordance with beliefs. They make true choices about the value and worth of their actions, thus resulting in happiness. Plato fought against “sophists” who claimed that there was no truth, only opinion, which is ruled by basic needs and desires rather than reason. Plato argued that it is through reason that we find the good.…

    • 1141 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Plato, a greek philosopher, is best known for calling himself a lover of wisdom. He took great pride in being an elite philosopher as oppose to a philodoxer, which is a lover of belief (Republic, Book V 480a). When reading Plato, his vast wisdom regarding many essential worldview questions is unpacked and explained on a deep level. Throughout Plato’s writings, the reader can see evidence that his worldview was based on the ability to be a good man, a positive belief of death, the importance of just actions, the absolute beauty of the soul, and the significance of having a king who was wise. To begin, Plato believed that a man’s tendency was to believe pleasures to be good in contrary to true knowledge which is what the more refined believed (Republic, Book VI 505b).…

    • 972 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This makes one self-motivating, good and consistent in the society with themselves and others. Justice becomes the sole front of internal harmony and good in a society. The origin and nature of justice is an arrangement that one comes to and is only valuable as it keeps a certain kind of order, predictability and safety. Plato claims that anyone who embraces justice is better off in times of despair and misfortune. He asserts that it is more advantageous for one to be just than unjust because that affects the human soul.…

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Socrates felt happiness and the Good went together. He believed that physical objects did not make a person happy and that what each person’s soul wants is what will bring true happiness (“Moral Philosophy”). Later on in the article it develops this idea more by stating, “Happiness consists in the lasting goods which are within us, it consists in having a mind free of agitation, dedicated to lofty knowledge and…

    • 1365 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the Gorgias and Apology Socrates presents noble statements that are not necessarily realistic. To suffer wrong rather than to do it and that nothing bad can befall a good man in either life or death are principals that Socrates believes just men live by. In reality, Socrates presents two claims that are incredibly hard to live up to. Analyzing the surface of these claims it would be easy to refute based on human nature presented by Callicles. The strongest of humans survive, to survive one must take what they deserve.…

    • 1235 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Plato Leadership Analysis

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages

    There would be one way of living for everyone, no exceptions. The leaders would be great deceivers and nothing would seem amiss; However, in a platonic society, people would live their lives in a more productive way, touching others, and creating metaphysical things to take with them from this earth. In conclusion, there are pros and cons to both Thrasymachus’s ideal leader and a platonic leader, but Plato describes the more ideal one. With philosophers as leaders, people are able to understand what…

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To expand, when Socrates spoke, “[t]hroughout my life, in any public activity…I am the same man as I am in the private life,” (Apology, Plato 33a) expressing the view that virtue is habitual and is not something that is merely chosen every so often. To further how habitual it is Socrates, “would much rather die…than live after [defending himself without virtue],” (Apology, Plato 38e). Using the fact that Socrates himself lived a virtuous life, one can come to the conclusion that virtue is rather habitual being that Socrates acted the same no matter whom he was…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thrasymachus’ opinion of justice was that whoever possessed the most power over another was just “Justice is merely the advantage of interest among the stronger” (Clark and Poortenga, 2003 p 9). Conversely, Plato, a philosopher and student of Socrates, creates an elaborate picture of justice, which supports the views of morality and an absolute truth. Plato stated that being just was a fulfillment that people strive for to become righteous and moral. He breaks his response into two sections, the first is stated that a just person receives rewards while an unjust person will be eventually punished either on earth or in the afterlife “everyone is judged according to his or her deeds; the righteous go upward into heaven and the wicked drop down into Hades” (Clark and Poortenga, 2003: p 14) This provides a reason for people to pursue justice due to the potential consequences they may…

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At the beginning of Euthyphro, “Socrates” announced the reason showing up around the Porch of the King. He happens to have an “indictment” (Euthyphro 2a) before the King. Meletus, an unknown youth, accused “Socrates” “of corrupting those of his own age” (Euthyphro 2c). “Socrates” believed that the youth dared to charge him was a correct beginning and praised him as “the cause of the most and greatest good things for the city” (Euthyphro 3a). Being able to view things philosophically without personal emotions, “Socrates” considered the action did by Meletus excellent, even it would charge “Socrates” to death.…

    • 1195 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kallipolis is a perfectly structured society in which justice is achieved at the social and interpersonal realms. It is ruled by a philosopher king, who maintain the peace and harmony in the ideal society. According to Plato in The Republic, the philosopher king possesses the qualities to be the rightful king to rule in Kallipolis. Philosophers are qualified to rule because they have a understanding of the Forms or the truth, their wisdom allows them to understand justice and their knowledge makes them superior than others. However, a philosopher can be a tyrant in disguise.…

    • 1641 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays