Aristotle's Ethical Dilemma Case Study

Superior Essays
Guided by moral virtue and clear path of what individuals need to follow in life to be an ethical individual of society, has been reflected, broken down and disclosed by Aristotle. He was one of histories for most prolific philosophers. I have chosen to use the summary of Aristotle’s Nicomanchean Ethics as presented by Erin Kuykendall. I will be applying this to the case which I presented of Jason’s ethical dilemma. There are clear applications that we can use from Erin’s analysis on Aristotle that gives us specific course of action which Jason should take, to ensure he makes an ethical choice.
(1) In our case Jason is facing a decision he must make about informing a young man by the name of Sam about a possible internship at his company.
…show more content…
The possibility that Sam might get chosen over others that are more deserving, make Jason upset, but the decision to actually hire him is not done by Jason though he might hold weight on the matter. He needs to realize that there is a bit of emotion built in to his thoughts. This is as well as when he thinks what if Sam does not end-up getting married to his niece, or what if she does? Jason considers this as well. These points though valid have an emotional basis. Sam getting the internship, over others can seem unfair, but the hiring process everywhere has multiple layers. The future is uncertain, but Jason can not make decisions based on Sam relationships, if he want those decisions to be ethical. In the summary Aristotle also mentioned that a man that makes lacking restraint in his choices will always choose emotionally and generally end up making an incorrect choice regardless because he makes this decision based on emotion. This is in contrast with a man that is aware and uses rational to choose, he can understand when his passions and emotions might get in the way of making smart decisions on choose the latter. Jason must choose the path that is not based on emotion but …show more content…
Upon applying the teaching of Aristotle, as analyzed by Erin Kuykendall, to Jason’s ethical dilemma we can take the points that are made in the summary. Jason must assure that he is choosing good and happiness over pleasure. Though Jason might not feel comfort in letting Sam know about the internship, he would have to lie to Sam that there was no internship, this would not be good, it would be ethical. He needs to take the road that leads him to a good decision and let Sam know about the internship. Jason needs to follow that path and let his manager know that Sam is looking for an internship. His manager asked and though Jason thinks of his status, he must reply to his manager, because this would be a choice that is based on virtue and not on what Jason wants for himself. The choices that Jason must make need to be ethical, and to do that based on Aristotle’s teachings, Jason needs to make sure that he lets Sam know about the internship. He needs to tell his manager, about Sam’s interest and not reflect on the feelings he has about Sam’s relationship with his niece or what other candidates are vying for the position as it is not up to him to hire him. Using good, moral virtue and making choices that are not based on emotion. Jason can choose what is ethical and meets are of the standards that Aristotle explains in his

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    He was wanting to set off a set of steers who were beginning to get sick. Jason was able to help Jeff derive the proper dosage rates that was needing to be fed to the steers. In these types of situations Jason is able to demonstrate and give Jeff his personal opinion on making sure that this is what was needed to be done. By helping Jeff’s business Jason is setting up a long term relationship that is going to help his business be successful…

    • 1404 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In April 26, 2016 a guy named Jason Cisnero, 19, was shot and killed for risking his life for a Woman for defending her from a victim right outside of Jason’s bestfriends house. " He sent me a message saying, 'I'm outside,' and then he was like, there's a lady honking, and this guy wants to hit her, he wants to kill her, something like that,' Salguero said. Additionally, Jason’s best friend ‘’Ivania Salguero’ heard two gunshots from inside her house. Why didn’t Jason just avoid the situation?…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The article I choose to connect to our topic is about a survivor of the shooting at an Orlando nightclub in 2016. Patience Carter was one of the 53 people injured that night. She was shot in both of her legs and luckily escaped. However, the bullet that was going to hit her, was blocked by, and killed a man by the name of Jason . It wasn’t until weeks later when she was at the Teen Choice Awards with the rest of the survivors, that she realized that Jason saved her life.…

    • 289 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kind Officer Summary: One homeless man pulls a knife on a police officer and attacks him. The officer's response ended up amazing the world. Introduction: Jason Macek did not have an easy experience growing up. During his childhood, he was bounced around from one foster home to another.…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    To conclude, Aristotle is a strong believer that in order to live a truly good life, a virtuous person is someone who performs the distinctive activity of being a human. Rationality is our unique activity, that is, the activity that characterizes us differently from animals. Since our rationality is our distinctive activity, its exercise is the supreme good. Moral virtue is simply a matter of performing well in the function of being human. In order to be virtuous, the end of human life could be called happiness (or living well).…

    • 185 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Health cares just trying to make profit. As a child we are told do something in life that makes you happy, if not you will be miserable your whole life. As a student planning on going in to the medical field I know I have a love for helping others. For me the job isn’t about the money, it's about the ability to help those are unable to do it themselves.…

    • 946 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Camp Jupiter Monologue

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages

    OK, for starters, she did not knock me out. The Gryffin must have when I was talking. OK .. I'm a half-blood... I don't get beat up by girls with sticks.…

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While analyzing the Tao-te-Ching, many major themes are apparent. From the inevitability of change to the importance of non-action, the Tao-te-Ching is truly full of life lessons that deserve extensive analysis; however, one of the most prevalent and recurring themes is balance and its importance. Throughout Cultural Perspectives, many authors have addressed this same theme. Siddhartha Gautama Buddha, Plato, and Saint Augustine have all discussed this important topic; however, Aristotle best complements and contrasts Lao Tzu’s Tao-te-Ching in his work Nichmachean Ethics. When comparing and contrasting these two texts, one can see that these two authors had very similar ideas on the concept of balance. When comparing the two texts’ thoughts…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    He gives three distinctions on how human beings make choices. They are based on whether they provide pleasure, usefulness, or are simply beautiful actions. It is from here that the relationship between virtue and friendship is conveyed. Aristotle attributes the same three choice-making elements (pleasure, usefulness, and beautiful actions) to describe friendship. For example, he points to that some human beings are friends for pleasure.…

    • 1649 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    While deontologists focus primarily on duty and obligation, virtue ethicists focus more on how one’s character affects their behavior. Aristotle believed that a virtuous person would fare better in life that a person who has lived a life of vice (Rachels,…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    • 3 Works Cited
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The ethical theories of both Aristotle and Epictetus, laid out in their books the Nicomachean Ethics and the Enchiridion, respectively, offer humanity insight into the most effective ways to achieve happiness and to exhibit virtue. Aristotle’s approach to happiness is that it must be looked at as the end to a means not as a means to an end. He feels that happiness should be viewed as the highest good within life. Although Epictetus agrees that happiness is the highest attainable good, he believes that the source of humanity’s misery is people’s inability to differentiate between what they can control and what they cannot. While both philosopher’s theories emphasize the importance of happiness and virtue in a person’s life, Epictetus’ view…

    • 1309 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Aristotle’s take on ethics is much different from any other philosopher. His view of ethics is very vague, do as the just man would do and for the same reasons as him. In saying this, Aristotle would reject Robert Nozick’s experience machine thought experiment. Though Aristotle’s ethics allow for less conflict that would come from a theory that contains rules, it is a problem that it is not very clear what one should do to be moral. Aristotle’s ethics are virtue ethics.…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Application of Virtue Ethics and Feminist Theory to Healthcare Sylvia and Jack’s decision to coerce Olive to donate a kidney to Nancy can be assessed using different ethical theories. Specifically, analysis of Jack and Sylvia’s decision using virtue ethics and feminist theory both indicate that Jack and Sylvia didn’t take the correct course of action, suggesting that there may be other ethical considerations that play a role in decision making. To determine whether Jack and Sylvia made the right decision, we must first understand virtue ethics and the feminist theory. Aristotle’s ethical thinking concerns how an individual can become a good person and develops good moral habits (Boetzkes, Waluchow xxxii). When using Aristotle’s method of ethical decision making, the virtue is a key concept to consider (Boetzkes, Waluchow xxxiii).…

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    In class, we have been discussing ethical theories as well as practicing placing these theories to cases. Ethical theories are a set of principles of right conduct and a system of moral values. The field of ethics involves systematizing, defending, and deciding different concepts of right and wrong behavior. In this day, philosophers are known to separate ethical theories into either metaethics, normative ethics, or applied ethics. I’ve chosen to focus on John Stuart Mill and Aristotle’s opposing argumentative theories which help teach me to analyze the cases provided to me.…

    • 1664 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Later in the novel, Jason reads a few profound statements that expose the danger of an identity crisis. It says, “Respect earned by integrity cannot be lost without your consent.” (213). There exists a cyclical nature of cause and effect, in which mistakes lead to failures and corrections lead to successes. If Jason were to express himself truthfully and show society his Inner identity, he would gain respect through integrity.…

    • 1678 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays