Electoral College Case Study

Improved Essays
1) Hamilton argues that the electoral college was created specifically to elect the president and was voted on by the people so that such an important decision was being made my official that the represent the people. He also asserts that this small group of educated electors would better able to analyze the necessary factors to determine if a candidate would make a good president. Basically he is saying that the electors are more educated then the masses and the masses trust them to make decisions because they voted on them. The electors are also unbiased because they were selected purely for the purpose of selecting the next president which prevents their votes from being bought beforehand. Furthermore, members cannot be close to the …show more content…
From what we learned in class and what I understood of Hamilton’s arguments it is an outdated and frankly somewhat elitist system. First Hamilton makes the point that the electors are more educated and therefore more qualified to elect the president. I have two issues with this. One, as whole our population is more educated than they were when the constitution was written. Second, this argument gives me the impression that we are discriminating against people because of their education level. Don’t get me wrong, there are some very uneducated people out there who maybe shouldn’t be allowed to vote, but that does not justify discrimination. If people are paying taxes and citizens of this country, they should have the right to directly vote of their leader. Next, Hamilton writes in length about corruption and how the electoral system prevents a variety of corruption. However, I do not see one example that would not also be solved by a direct vote from the people. In our day and age, it is simple matter to count the popular vote but because of the Electoral College four of our presidents have lost the popular vote meaning that even if the electors do represent the people, the people are still not getting what they voted for. We are intelligent enough to vote for our own president, we do not need electors to make the choice for …show more content…
We are a country founded on greed. I knew about what we did to Natives populations. What I was really surprised by was the Revolutionary war and the early government of the United States. After learning about the war and declaring independence I truly believe that the states were being unreasonable and had no right to declare independence. This was an interesting realization to come to about my own country. The revolutions and the events leading up to it were a very intelligent movement on the part of the rich to keep their wealth. I was also surprised by much the colonies did not want freedom from Britain. Independence really was the last resort for them. After they gained independence the government they set up catered to rich white landowners. There really wasn’t that much equality at that time. I don’t think that everything about America is bad, but I think that we are taught a glorified version of our history and that does not do anybody and favors. How are we supposed to learn from our mistakes if we do not know what they are? After taking this course I feel like I have a more complete, in depth understanding of my countries history. I have also learned to look critically as history even if it was written or presented by a credible source because it’s important to understand that there are always

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Citizens make up the state, so if you do not have citizens you would not have states. Then if we were to get rid of the Electoral College; then the candidates would pay attention to other states more than they do now. They are more worried about the winner take all system that they ignore the state they already know their vote for them. Which disenfranchises voter who supported the losing candidates. This system favors some citizens over others, which denies some people their choice of president.…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is a possibility that more citizens would use their right to vote if they know for certain that their vote matters and makes an impact. If people know that the president becomes elected based off of the popular vote rather than only a small elite number of people, then they may want to go out and vote so that the person they view as most qualified will be elected into office. Therefore, I believe that the electoral college should not exist because it provides an opportunity for presidents to be elected who did not receive the overall majority from the popular vote. This means that in a democratic society, the nominee who the people want to be their representative may lose due to the number of electoral college…

    • 1995 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Every citizen’s vote should count in America, not just the votes of the partisan insiders in the Electoral College. The Electoral College was necessary when communications were poor, literacy was low, and voters lacked information about out-of-state figures, which is clearly no longer the case.” This quote by Representative Gene Green reveals the faults in our current presidential voting system and the need for it to change. It has been an example and a basis to newly formed democracies all over the world, but the election to choose our nation’s leader isn’t as fair as it seems. While every citizen’s voice is heard in the public polls, ultimately it’s the Electors’ votes that select the new president. Therefore, I believe that our election…

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How would you feel if your vote in deciding the next president of our country didn’t matter? Well, this is true for many people due to our broken Electoral College system of voting. I strongly feel that we should get rid of it for many reasons. My first reason is that it doesn’t give equal representation to certain states. My second reason is that it doesn’t match up with the popular votes that were taken by the people.…

    • 507 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Other branches of the government are not directly chosen by the popular vote. To begin with, people do not directly vote for the President, but the voting system was created to pick electoral college representatives to vote for the presidency. In other words, people do not get to pick the President of their country by their will, but the selected representatives will do the picking for them. Although people choose the electoral college members from the political taste that they have, it would not necessarily match their wills. For example, in 2000, there was a presidential election, and the result of this election shows the difference between the popular vote and electoral college vote.…

    • 1566 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the general presidential election, the votes of the people are not influential in any way. The electoral college has been in place since our government was created and it has does its job electing the president relatively well; so well some people do not know the system exists. But, it is time for our government to evolve like everything else in the world has. With the advantages in technology, American citizens have the resources to know all about the candidates who are running, unlike in the past. To create a better democracy and for the people of America to truly feel that they have an influential part in the government, the electoral college needs to be done away…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Electoral College does not provide a straightforward process to elect president. As specified in Document D, “It favors some citizens over others depending solely upon the state which voters cast their votes for president…” In view of the fact that a state has less people than another does not necessitate that, they should obtain extra electoral votes. It should be fair and just let the votes be based off the number of senators and representatives. With political equality, all citizens are equal and it allows citizens to participate in state affairs. It includes the right to vote and the right to challenge elections.…

    • 1009 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Penrod reflects that President George W. Bush’s simple language leads most Americans to poorly regard intelligence because, again, it is an example of uneducated success. I am able to agree that a president’s uneducated success can be very influential because I have noticed the effects among my peers. They believe that they don’t need an education if a president can be successful without one. A discussion should be included, in the article, that it seems as if people are willing to elect an uneducated president because they don’t feel as if education is a necessary quality. Though the uneducated success of such influential people causes anti-intellectualism, the wealth of these individuals is another…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What Is Autocratic Power

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages

    These are just a few of the actions the government does that get people upset, and they should be upset that the government does not have their best interest at heart. The best way to strengthen American democracy is to have a strong America. If the lower and middle class just comes together and realize that there is far more of us than it is of the one percent we could have real political change. So we have to have to vote, campaign, and rally seriously for what we want they have to give it to us. Though it is popular opinion that the U.S. government can do whatever they want they can not because of the people.…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Electoral Process needs to be Reformed The election process in the United States is flawed and has caused serious controversy in past elections on whether or not the process is fair. First, the states all have equal representation to their House and Senate members. Secondly, the election process was set up for the lesser populated states versus the largely populated states. This amendment should be ratified because the Electoral College takes the power away from the people, does not allow a voter to vote for the candidate directly, and will help third parties compete fairly in elections. Some people argue that the election process is working just fine for the United States.…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays