Arguments Against Lifeboat Ethics

Improved Essays
Human’s sometime act out in ways they know are wrong because the outcome would be greater for oneself or someone else, and the outcome is worth the consequence. For example in a story we read in class there was a man whose wife was dying in the hospital with a rare disease and there was only one drug that could possibly cure her. So, the husband went to the man who created the drug with all the money he could find $1,000 but, the drug was $2,000 even though it only cost $200 to make. The husband offered the man a deal he would give him the money he had now and slowly start paying him back when he got the money, if he gave him the drug to save his wife right then. The man declined his offer, so the husband decided to steal the drug from the …show more content…
I think, we should help people that don’t directly impact our lives when it’s convenient, and doesn't put our lives or future at jeopardy. This is called lifeboat ethics meaning, the rich and powerful people shouldn’t help everyone or they will sink. Just like a lifeboat the more you add in the faster it’ll sink. For example one main topic in politics is the immigration laws. Some people believe that we need to help everyone and allow them the rights we have as American citizens but, I believe those rights shouldn’t just be handed to you and that people should just be allowed to enter our country. I believe we should help in ways we can but our main focus should be keeping the American citizens in our country safe. I think that we shouldn’t allow people into our country when we don’t have a set system that can make sure everyone is as they say. This is an example of helping people that don’t directly impact our lives but, doing so in a way that’s convenient to us and to keep our lives safe first. Another example is take the husband and wife story from the paragraph before but, imagine instead of that being his wife it is a complete stranger. Now i'm guessing most of us are like, I wouldn’t steal a drug for someone I don't know. But why do you say that? I think it’s because the conquest is so large most of us are like ya we might save a life but mine will be ruined

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In Garrett Hardin’s essay, Lifeboat Ethics, he emphasizes on the ethical issue of how to judiciously help the poor and the argument behind it. In the beginning of the essay Hardin responds to the comparison of Earth as a spaceship, by stating that it can be dangerous when used by misguided idealists to justify suicidal policies for sharing our resources through uncontrolled immigration and foreign aid. Interestingly enough, he prefers to address the issue with a lifeboat metaphor, in which refers to the rich nations (such as the United States) as being aboard the boat, as well as the poor nations who are swimming around the boats for…

    • 109 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Have you ever came across two people who have opposite personalities but have so much in common? It does not seem possible, but it is. In S.E. Hinton’s novel, The Outsiders, two characters, Dallas Winston and Johnny Cade are very similar and also different at the same time. Dally and Johnny are very similar because both of their parents do not care about them, they ignore them, and they are are abusive and neglectful. Also, Dally and Johnny both place little value on their lives.…

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Winger Theme

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages

    A Dead End Road The theme on the book ‘Winger’ by Andrew Smith is a very relatable theme to this book. The theme is ‘Bad decisions lead to bad consequences’. This theme heavily supports Winger because of the fact that when the main character Ryan-Dean does something inappropriate or just plain stupid, he gets punished for it. That’s why this theme ‘Bad decisions lead to bad consequences’ fits this book perfectly. Ryan-Dean has made a terrible mistake.…

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Commonly recognized milestones in human life are birth, growth, reproduction, and death. In reality, life is much more incredibly complex than this. There are so many minute nuances that make the human experience what it is. Each individual’s life is a delicate combination of many experiences: accomplishments along with failures, friends turning to enemies, and love ending with heartbreak. Since the beginning of civilization, using art as a medium, people constantly seek to express their perspective on this phenomena while trying to understand it.…

    • 1108 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the most potentially dangerous and aggravating ways that things are not always what they seem is apparent in the way people act. Sometimes people can be attempting to be nice, but instead have evil intentions. In Modern World History the other day, we watched a video of a man named Darren Brown who used diversionary techniques to pickpocket…

    • 307 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    No reader can closely read a good piece of fiction literature without extracting some type of revelation about human nature. Fiction reveals these two sides of human nature with techniques that authors use to help the reader get the theme or idea that the text portrays and it is important that readers understand what these revelations can tell them about themselves. In these short stories, “Ambush” by Roger Woodward, the “Tell-Tale Heart” by Edgar Allen Poe, “The Treasure of Lemon Brown” by Walter Dean Myers and “Suitcases and Snow Globes” by Lara Ferrari, these techniques can be seen in action, thus revealing both the good and evil sides of human nature nature and why they are important to decipher. One of the two examples of techniques that…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout The Life Of Pi, Pi suffered turmoil and hardships. Even before the tragedy of the Tsimtsum sinking and Pi having to suffer for 227 days at sea, he had to deal with troubles at home. Pi was bullied, and I don't believe that anyone enjoys being bullied. Students and even teachers are purposely pronounced his name wrong. Fellow classmates taunted him by calling him "pissing".…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In defense of the survivors’ guilt arising from not helping the poor, he claimed that “the net result of conscience-stricken people giving up their unjustly held seats is the elimination of that sort of conscience from the lifeboat”. He defined guilty about one’s good luck as a type of conscience and the newcomer’s lack of guilt about the rich people’s loss as conscience drain; but the author deliberately omitted the morality of rich people’s indifference to the poor asking for help. Counting the negative effects on total conscience in the lifeboat if no rescue is attempted, the final solution to the lifeboat dilemma might be changed. Essentially, the author’s negligence of social injustice against impoverished people and the ethical issue indifference is just a result of his bias for the rich countries.…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Out of fear, blame is often presented to those who come off as an easy target. Taking the easy way out seems a lot simpler then risking oneself pride and status, and this way creates a multitude of problems. Not only is the blame made off of assumptions and past grudges, but oftentimes the accusations are made from a type of deeply felt resentment that boils below. Whether this blame is made based on skin color or reputation, or whether the accusation is made out of a sense of greed and want for more, the scenario is that oftentimes taking the easy way out becomes a much more complicated circumstance.…

    • 1435 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is a novel about the consequences of taking risks and following your dreams when they are not thought through. People often take risks, not planning properly, which can possibly lead to the death of an individual. Jon Krakauer illustrates the consequences of not being prepared, taking a risk, and ultimately dying for a dream. In the novel, Into the Wild, Jon Krakauer depicts Chris McCandless as an unprepared, vulnerable individual, who shuts himself off from the outside world, eventually leading to his death. Chris McCandless’s unpreparedness and unawareness of what he is about to face is one of the main reasons for his death.…

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Imagine staring at a jail cell wall all day. You didn’t consider yourself a bad person. So where did you go wrong? This is the daily life of many inmates. “Psychology of Fraud: Why Good People do Bad Things.”(2012)…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even though it is easier for people to look the other way once they get on the boat because they are now safe and secure, it is important to help the needy. Another reason why everyone should come together and help the poor and unite is because it can very easily be one of the rich people in or one of the…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Garrett Hardin’s “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor”, Hardin argues about “a world that must solve real and pressing problems of overpopulation, hunger and moral duty.” Hardin sets the stage by first giving his analysis on the structure of the world today by describing the earth as a lifeboat rather than a spaceship. He then dives into how population control, the tragedy of the commons and immigration are some of the main reasons for the problems we have today. Hardin argues that simply helping people and giving charitably will not solve these problems. Peter Singer, in “Famine, Affluence, and Morality” seemingly goes against Hardin by saying that “if it is in our power to prevent something bad from happening, without thereby…

    • 994 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Humans decisions are in the hands of each own. Their opportunity to make use of each decision expresses our free will. In life, humans determine whether their freedom of making their decision is too extreme, and if they should make that decision or not. Sometimes that pushes us to our limit and forces us to do things we are not usually accustomed to doing. While we express the opportunity to showcase free will, there are limits that can stop the idea of it, for example laws.…

    • 768 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Did the End Justify the Means? An ethical dilemma is a situation where one has to make a decision between two moral options; both of these options would end up with a negative result. In the movie called, “John Q”, John Q Archibald has a son who has a fatal cardiac condition and needs surgery as soon as possible. However, the parents do not have nearly as much as they need to even pay the deposit.…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays