Arguments Against Genetic Discrimination

Better Essays
People are worried about being rejected for a job, because of their genetic information. No company should have the right to hire, fire or judge people based on their genetic background. Genetic discrimination is when people are treated unfairly because of the differences in their DNA and their chance of getting a disease. A number of laws have passed that have protected people under the law. For example, GINA, which protects people from genetic discrimination from employers and health insurance providers. Even though laws have been passed to help protect people from genetic discrimination, companies have broken the law, paid a penalty and were free to go. The laws that are too be passed must be hard on the employer and act as some kind of …show more content…
Also the company threatened to terminate a contract of one worker who refused to get himself tested. This shows that companies violated the law and that there should be stricter laws than just paying the penalty. This wasn’t the only case linked to genetic discrimination; other cases have been reported where the insurance companies have stopped covering healthcare for patients because they were diagnosed with a genetic disease. The council for responsible genetics wrote “Seven-year-old Danny is in perfect health, but a genetic tests reveals that he has a gene predisposing him to a heart disorder. Even though he takes medication that lowers his risk of a heart attack, he is denied health insurance. His insurance company argues that since his gene has been present since birth, this qualifies as a pre-existing medical condition.” Another case reported by the council of responsible genetics was “Kim is a social worker with a large human services agency. During a staff workshop on caring for people with chronic illnesses, Kim mentions that she was the primary caretaker for her mother who died of Huntington’s disease. Kim herself has a 50% chance of developing this fatal genetic condition. One week …show more content…
The verge stated “What’s even more striking, however, is that 30 percent of participants said that they became more worried about genetic discrimination after reading about GINA.” Which means that people were actually worried that this is becoming a problem. The US government needs to educate its people on the rights of its people and how they can get justice. People are afraid to get genetically tested and have that data listed on their medical record because they think, that it might affect their career and that will judge them. GINA does not cover life insurance, so that means that people can be refused a policy, if the company requests a genetic testing to be done. However, at this rate of advancements in the science industry, “genetic discrimination” might not exist, because every treatment will be gene based and there is a chance that none of us will have mutated genes. However, the government needs to find a way to reassure the

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Is Human Cloning Possible

    • 1372 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Scientists only want to create clones in order to have better organ donors. Besides, if cloning is imperfect, it would be dangerous to use the organs of the clones for the natural human race. Instead of helping the original humans, clones would be a danger to us. Moreover, the clones were never asked if they wanted to be an organ donor, so it is unethical to force the clones to donate their organs to the original person. It is also wrong to give something life and kill them later on because they have something that you want.…

    • 1372 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Monsanto Pros And Cons

    • 1820 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Another point that genetic engineering is disastrous is because mega corporations are in control of them. Biotech companies like Monsanto and Du Pont are not running for helping the general public, but they are there to only mass produce genetically modified crops spray with herbicides and sell them in order to make a profit. In their case, there is no need to think to the lives of people today and in future generations. Although, many people-advocates, the U.S. government, and biotech companies- are saying otherwise and that genetically modified organisms is what the population needs. These individuals and larger groups might say that they have done their…

    • 1820 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Should the government be giving half a billion dollars to an organization with such little regard for human life? Many came to the conclusion that all federal funding of Planned Parenthood should cease because American citizens don’t want to be funding the organization, the group is constantly skirting the law, and the services provided are immoral and unacceptable. The opposition would say that without federal funding, Planned Parenthood could not continue to provide life saving health care for women nation wide. However, if Planned Parenthood was to close it’s doors tomorrow, clients could still receive the same services for similar prices elsewhere. A Pro-Life group launched a website, GetYourCare.org, to provide women with alternative organizations to Planned Parenthood.…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    As a result, parents think that children should not be given the MMR vaccine, but they don’t understand and research the reality of the symptoms’ occurrence time. When they choose not to vaccinate their children because of a simple misunderstanding, it effects many people other than their children. Other diseases like sickle cell can be linked to genetics but although autism is somewhat linked to genetics, vaccines are the easy blame but it is wrong (Mnookin,Seth). Scientists say correlation simply doesn’t imply causation, despite the assumption that so many parents make. It is similar to when a person becomes sick and assumes the last thing they have eaten is what made them sick.…

    • 2130 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    There are also many arguments against stem cell research. People argue that destroying embryos is also destroying innocent lives. Stem cells should only be used from babies that were aborted. Abortion isn 't a good thing, but at least the unborn babies will have somewhat of a purpose in life. A lot of taxpayers don 't think their money should be going towards something that they all don 't agree with.…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Pro Euthanasia Debate

    • 1594 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Also, those who want to follow the homicide laws, also plead that if physicians were allowed to practice physician assisted suicide, it will violate their Hippocratic oath with says, “To please no one will I prescribe a deadly drug nor give advice which may cause death.” Because of this oath, many medical professionals do not support euthanasia, because it puts them “in a precarious ethical, professional, and legal position.” Many physicians also understand that with one of the restrictions being a prognosis of six months, that prognosis precision sometimes fails. They began to fear that if the prognosis are wrong, that people who would have the chance to live longer will be killed thinking they had little time to live (Griswold). In the Netherlands where euthanasia is legalized the patients eligible for mercy killing “now includes depressed people and…

    • 1594 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The American Medical Association tried to fight back against abortion by trying to criminalize abortion unless it was to save the pregnant woman 's life, but it failed (2035). People believed that if abortion was criminalized it would result in a problem of rise in poverty (2035). It was believed this would happen because to raise a child it is over thousands of dollars a year, and not everyone has the sufficient amount of funds to pay for a extra child in their house. As crazy as it may seem some women believed that it was equal citizenship to be able to perform an abortion, they felt as if it was a power and privilege of living in the United states that they had (2036). I 've always believed that having an abortion is murder, and to think that someone believe that an abortion is…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This sparked a lot of controversy as many thought doctors would abuse this power and try to steer patients towards euthanasia as the primary option. What people fail to realize is doctors are humans too. Their whole career revolves around saving lives even if it is not what the general public would recognize as saving. Most doctors would only use euthanasia sparingly and try to make the patient consider it as a last resort. People also fear the legalization of euthanasia would cause a rapid increase in the suicide rates for…

    • 1693 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Arguments have been made stating that cloning could save lives, but it would jeopardize many more than it would save the scientists from the article “The Cloning Debate. Should All Forms Of Human Cloning Be Banned?” State “Many experts say reproductive cloning is grossly unethical because it jeopardizes the health of would-be child clones. They note that efforts to clone sheep, pigs, goats and other animals yield few live births, and that many live-born mammal clones die within weeks or months because of abnormalities.” If humans were to reproduce through cloning we would have very little success and the children would not live for very long. Why…

    • 1745 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Childhood Vaccination

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages

    However, in the past few decades there has been a growing trend of privileged parents refusing to vaccinate their children because they associate alternate risks with the vaccines themselves. These parents let perceived threats, such as the claim that a link exists between vaccinating and autism or mistrust in government…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays