Argumentative Essay: Should Students Get Paid For Good Grades

Improved Essays
Argumentative Essay
Should Students Get Paid For Good Grades Some students get money for getting good grades but is that really good? Research shows that paying students may be a bad idea. For example, the NEA states that paying students would lead to practical problems in the classroom. Parents would pay for their child’s good grades as motivation, but it is actually affecting their own desire to learn. By giving money to students, parents are working against their intrinsic (innate) motivation. Students would be inflated by pressure from both getting good grades and trying to get money. From not being motivated by their own desire to learn, to learn, to working against their innate motivation, to being inflated with unnecessary pressure,
…show more content…
Psychologist Sam Goldstein claims, “ External motivators may be effective and well intended, but they clearly work against the continued development of a child’s intrinsic motivation.” This stated that by giving outside factors as motivation, people are harming the student’s natural motivation. This would lead to them not having their own desire to learn. Students would start to lose their innate motivation for short, external motivation. Giving students money as motivation has a negative effect and can take something natural from them. Clearly, students should not be paid for good …show more content…
According to Clare Levison, “ I think it can be an effective incentive, as long as you’re using it as a teachable moment to tell them about budgeting and saving.” But undoubtedly this could be challenged because even if students were being paid in the long term, their academic performances are lower than those who are not getting paid. Students who want to lean will be better than those who are only studying to get money. In addition, getting paid may be effective, but it is external and is generally short- term. Students should not be bribed and should study to get an education and not money. For the reasons above, students should not be paid for good

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Some people believe paying students for good grades is a bad idea, I personally believe students will strive to do better when they are paid for their work. Lots of schools are paying their students for getting good grades, and others are giving it a try. Why would a student want to take a harder, more stressful class if they don’t get paid more? More people would try to be in AP classes if they were offered money or more money than just a regular non AP or Honors class. Paying students will help underprivileged…

    • 1116 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Have you ever wanted to get awarded for your work and grades in school? Well that’s what is happening in some schools in the United states. I think this should be happening in more and more schools around the world for some pretty good reasons. First, some parents have very low income and they can not provide for their families and if you are getting paid for the good grades you earned you can use that money to help your family. Another thing is, some kids do not like do their work and with the ability to make money for good grades would influence the kids to do their assignments and get promising grades.…

    • 1062 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Paying for grades also causes pressure on teachers to inflate grades that don't deserve to be a high grade. Paying students is not good idea because the student will lose their love for learning, they won't remember what they have learned, and school becomes more of a business transaction then a place to learn and grow. First of all, students should not be paid for grades because it takes away the child's natural love for learning. Research by Edward Deci and others shows, “ children, by nature, are motivated to learn … Promise of eternal reward, and the child's natural love for learning might be dampened”.This shows that when you give money for good grades,the child will become greedy and not be thankful that they are getting an education at a good school. Once awards are taken away, the student…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The flip side of this situation is that a student from the low-income area may be more encouraged to find work and help supplement the family’s income and help provide necessities. Students cannot perform well in an environment where teachers expect them to complete coursework outside of school, but are also expected by their guardians to be employed outside of school. This system, Common Core, would force these students to become overworked and overwhelmed. It is not capable of catering to low-income schools, and would further increase the achievement…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Effects Of Grade Inflation

    • 1624 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Grade Inflation What is grade inflation? Grade inflation is the tendency to award students with higher academic grades with work then what the students should had actually received, and because of it there has been discussion about grade inflation and what solutions would help educational institution get rid of it or try to lessen the problem. Many people does not realize the effects of grade inflation. So what are the effects of grade inflation? What solutions can help solve grade inflation in educational institutions?…

    • 1624 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    First reason is the misplaced motivation, the ultimate goal in children’s education is to have them learn. By giving them money, their goal will change from learning new things to gaining money and this can even drive them to cheat academically just to get the money. Instinctually, Humans should be striving for knowledge because that is how we advanced so far in society. In the far future, the world will not improve if the only thing people care about is money and not in discovering new ways to progress. Parents should teach children that knowledge is the most important thing they will gain in life, not money.…

    • 1502 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    A student’s understanding of the language really influences their score, the student may have done very well if the test was in their primary language, and a teacher cannot control the student’s understanding of the language, they can help improve their knowledge of the language but even then it takes years to perfect it. Another factor that teachers cannot control is a student’s income background (Teacher Accountability). Some students come from wealthier families than others, affecting the student’s score more than the teachers. Less fortunate students may not have the money for extra educational resources and help as a wealthy student would, affecting their score and knowledge. While a teacher may offer thee knowledge and tutoring, some students need more than what a teacher can offer.…

    • 1382 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The college should not constitutes an obstacle for the students, because they want a lot of money for tuition, living, books, and supplies, so the student has to work a lot to get the money to pay and can’t put more time to their studies, and so they are not as good if they didn’t pay a lot of money to go to school. Colleges should require less money, so that they have better students and don’t become a…

    • 1568 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is okay to be rewarded for your good work, does not always happen but students should be paid for good grade. The benefits outweigh the disadvantages, giving the students a sense of accomplishment for their hard work. If student were to get paid it would increase their motive a get up and do well. Many kids do not like the idea of having to go to school, they do not feel like it would really benefit them so we need to give them some motivation When students get paid it teaches them what good thing can happen when you work hard and do well. Now, we would not pay them for D’s and F’s, getting paid is a reward for good grades.…

    • 1093 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Students should study because they want to, not to be forced to. Its wrong to lure students into studying by using cash as it gives them an idea that money can somewhat “control the world” everything does revolve around money, Which is a sad truth that they don’t understand that money does control the world and them. Although this policy encourages the wrong things. Students may get so caught up in focusing on making more money that they assumed getting good grades is purely for the money and not for learning. As I stated, their parents always expect getting good grades and studying from them.…

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays