Nclb Vs Snow White Essay

Improved Essays
The story of Snow White, a lovely girl who ate the poison apple that was given by the absurd queen. She was put to a deep sleep, but with the care of the dwarfs, the princess survived until the prince came to the rescue. This story is happening in our society, but it is a morbid version. Our princess, education, has been poisoned by the deadly poison apple, No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB). Unlike Snow White, we do not have dwarfs to take care of education, and to this day, our prince, our savior has not yet appeared; she is just left there. NCLB, the poison apple, is what is currently keeping Princess education asleep and impeding its prosperity. In the beginning, NCLB looked like a delicious and healthy apple that seemed very beneficial to …show more content…
Charter schools are run by private organizations or corporations and they are run by the government so they do not have to follow NCLB. The quote goes, “Cyber-charters, which offered online instructions to students at home, were receiving full payment for each student and amassing multimillion-dollar reserves” (Ravitch 134); Charter schools is an investment, a way for big corporations to make money; they get millions of dollars for funding yet they can only be a cyber school. The quote states, “Most KIPP schools consistently outperform traditional public schools in the same neighborhood. But KIPP schools often have a high attrition rate” (Ravitch 136).Unlike public schools, they do not have to accept students that they do not seen fit while public schools are required to accept all. By not following the NCLB, charter schools would definitely pass the adequate yearly progress because they only accept students that are above average and with large amounts of funding, there is almost no way for charter schools to fail. Charter schools are being well funded while public schools are suffering under the NCLB. Seeing how “successful” charter schools are, why should parents send their kids to “bad” public schools. According to the novel, Death and Life of the Great American School System, …show more content…
At first many did agree to this act because it sounds so perfect. What could be the harm of that one little test each year? well, it is detrimentally bad because now all schools are being ranked based on test scores and not knowledge. When students are given the chance to leave their school because it is “below average”, they might not want to leave the school because the school that they can transfer to is too far from where they lives and transportation is a problem; they might not think there is any problem with the school, it is the school system that is wrong. The article, ‘F’ for ‘No Child Left Behind’ act declares, “Not going to happen. One hundred percent perfection among the millions of American schoolchildren -- What were President Bush and congressional lawmakers thinking when they signed off on that Utopian goal” Everyone is different, everyone learns differently, having everyone reach 100 percent proficiency is a fairy tale. NCLB ideas were good for education but the predicted results were very imaginary; it is impossible for everyone to achieve proficiency because we are all

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Almost every American in the working class, or middle class, thinks that we, as todays students, will not be bale to reach the American dream because of the society we live in. Government programs like the No Child Left Behind (NCLB) act punishes schools for having lower test scores than the rest of the schools in the nation. This is not even close to right because the schools are forced to take these tests by the government themselves, and the get punished for something that they did not want to do. The government does things such as firing, closings, etc. just because the school does not the resources to have an average education compared to the rest of America (Strauss).…

    • 1288 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Common Core Tragedy

    • 1360 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Students are tested on one single performance and the proctors don’t look at the child’s overall growth; it’s just a bunch of statistics that say that every single kid needs to be at the exact same level of knowledge at the end of the school year. These statistics do not take account of disabilities, anxiety, behavioral problems, etc. If a student does not do well on the standardized test, his/her confidence drops because they did not score as well as their peers. Common core is not a good form of education for children because of all the negative mental effects it…

    • 1360 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “You get an F! You get an F! Everyone gets an F!” Most students would be lying if they say they have never been threatened by their teachers giving them an F as a grade or have never received an F on an assignment, paper, test, etc. I will be the first to say I have received my fair share of F’s, most if not all of them earned because I deserved them. They were because of not preparing well enough for a given test, not turning an assignment in on time, or simply not turning one in period.…

    • 1161 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a result, students consistently fail the EOC’s because of the lack of preparation and lack of thought from the teachers. In order for most students to get passing grades I have known teachers to always curve the grade so they would not get embarrassed and look like they were not teaching anything. In my opinion teachers should be able to make their own end of course exams because they know what they have taught and how they taught…

    • 1084 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This statistic shows that whether or not students like school because every child know that their school have a limit on how many days you can miss without counting accused absences. This shows children either wants to be held back in school, or just do not care enough to go. Another school related issue is the students believe it is easier to get a GED. Students felt as if getting a regular education with better attention from teachers is a horrible choice. The easier choice is skipping school and at a later date to go get their GED.…

    • 1787 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nclb Act Persuasive Essay

    • 1473 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The House of Representatives has recognized that the NCLB policy is unfair toward disadvantaged students; therefore, they are currently debating on amending the act. Mr. Bonamici said that, “this amendment will help reduce the testing burden and recognizes that a one-size-fits-all policy to address testing won’t work” (Cameron). Unfortunately, students attending these failing schools are conditioned to take these annual state tests. The students know that there will be a huge test at the end of the school year because teachers let them know in advance. This leads to students who are not retaining the content to become discouraged, and seek help.…

    • 1473 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    America is the only country in the world that offers all children the right to a free high quality education system. The United States teaches all children, despite learning disabilities, economic status, or those who do not speak english. In most other countries parents are forced to sacrifice everything to send children to private schools, so they can get high quality education, whereas in the United States, such a large sacrifice is not needed from parents. ("Why America Is Home to the World’s Best Education System. ", www.beinglatino.us) For decades American students have been warned about the decrease in American greatness, a fall from the power of being a world power, in science or invention.…

    • 1731 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    American Education Crisis

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages

    “No nation has ever achieved 100 percent proficiency for all its students” (Ravitch 3) and “Black and Hispanic children have lower test scores than white and Asian children” (Ravitch 3) meaning that no student is perfectu due to race, color, ethnicity and any kind of background settings, therefore approach of education should be delivered to students equally. In the MAST program, as you walk in you would see students with different background settings but that doesn’t mean a student is dumb, it could be put in a better way as they might be underperforming due to certain circumstances but having mentors around to help such students was a great to not only help them with what they were struggling with but also to be there for them so that they have someone to talk to about anything they might be going…

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Public schools should not have a dress code because it does not decrease attendance, affect academic results, or cause a major distraction. I’m sure most people agree that students need a good attendance in order to do good in school. The question is how can dress code change that attitude of a student towards going to class or not? If a student is going to miss school they will their…

    • 1049 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Armstrong, these tests don’t even provide the proper feedback students need in order to improve their performance. Results are reported back to schools months after the test is taken, and there’s no instruction on how to improve the scores. Standardized testing also diminishes the value of creativity and diversity in schools. The initial tests were taken by a “norm” group who fit into this cookie cutter idea of what an American student should be. Their results were calibrated into how the machine determines a grade, which meant every test was graded according to these perfect student ideals.…

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays