Arguments Against Prenatal Genetic Testing

Good Essays
Prenatal genetic testing is beginning to become more at ease as mentioned by Carolyn Gonter in her 2004 article, The Expressivist Argument, Prenatal Diagnosis, and Selective Abortion: An Appeal to the Social Construction of Disability:
As the ease of prenatal genetic testing increases alongside an increase in the number and variety of conditions testable, so does the general view, both in medical and social communities, that prenatal testing is a logical extension of good prenatal care with the goal of healthy babies. (p. 1)
Some people argue having the screening performed on expecting mothers will be more harmful to the health of the unborn child and the mother, than helpful. Some may also be concerned about the psychological viewpoint and
…show more content…
The NIPT should not be done on expecting mothers who are considered a high risk or already been tested for Down syndrome because it will present a false positive stating that the baby could have Down syndrome. According to Merryn Ekberg (2007) article, “the greatest benefits gained from prenatal genetic testing are the prevention of the birth of the child with chronic genetic disease and offering prospective parents a degree of liberation from reproductive risks.” (p. 67) The most important benefits of the prenatal genetic testing include: giving the mother the opportunity, or option to have an abortion, if there is any degree of being at risk in reproduction; it prevents the mother from giving birth to a child who is special needs and medically fragile; and it prevents emotional distress and financial struggle of giving birth to a child with genetic issues, or health conditions. It also gives the mother the opportunity to prepare or plan for the future of the child’s needs. There are several risks to having the prenatal genetic testing done which can include: the intervention of private lives, reproductive freedom loss, and discrimination of disability, sexual, racial conditions, and wrongful deaths. “With over 8000 single gene defects that affect at least 1% of the adult population, the demand for prenatal genetic testing is rapidly increasing.” (Ekberg, Merryn (2007), p. 68) …show more content…
The decision is based on the mother and the doctor whether or not the child should be genetically tested for any conditions. The decision to have the prenatal genetic testing perform could cause a big controversy on unethical and ethical issues. However, by making the decision to have the prenatal genetic screening done could cause psychological issues such as anxieties, making it very stressful in trying to decide. It can be very shocking or disturbing to some mothers who find out that their child could be born with abnormalities or a disability, and they do not know how to handle the situation. It can also be a hard decision to make in having to terminate a pregnancy because of a health condition of the unborn, or the unborn is not developing right. However, some mothers accept the fact their child could be born with abnormalities or a disability. It will be less stressful if the mother was educated and counseled on the risks preventions and maximize the benefits, to prevent unwanted babies from suffering from abuse or neglect because the intervention of the prenatal genetic screening was not performed, giving the mother options on what she wants to do with her

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Let’s say the mother isn’t trying to get pregnant, but she ends up accidentally messing up her birth control. She doesn’t mean to get pregnant, she won’t be able to survive the pregnancy, and therefore, the fetus has very little chance of survival. This makes it absolutely okay for the mother to get an abortion. Some people may argue that the fetus still has a chance at being born, so getting an abortion doesn’t seem like the only option. They think that if there is a chance of survival for the fetus, there should be measures taken to ensure a life for the fetus.…

    • 1338 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Since a cleft lip does not affect the wellbeing of the mother any government aid should be provided because it is solely a preference decision. Some abortions may be necessary because of specific conditions, but because of a baby not meeting the desired checklist, should not be allowed to receive government aid on an abortion because it is a decision that was made because the parents would not be happy with the child they would have…

    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Plague Of Abortion

    • 1633 Words
    • 7 Pages

    If the mother dies and the the child dies, then there are two lives that no longer exist. Is two deaths better than one? A third reason that people might have an abortion is because they are scared that the baby will have disabilities. If the baby does have disabilities, the mother should still love the baby no matter what they look like or act like. They are the person’s own flesh and blood.…

    • 1633 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Another barrier for genetic screening is that, genetic screening and "designer babies" would lead to requiring experimentation on women as well as on children. Many people argue that genetic screening can help treat diseases for future generations. It is unacceptable to use genetic screening to produce genetically healthy, or even “designer" babies. Moral and ethical barriers exist when beginning to change a humans genes. Many have feared the…

    • 1184 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Abortion Argument Essay

    • 875 Words
    • 4 Pages

    People also think it is acceptable to have an abortion because they do not want to bring an unwanted child into the world due to birth defects. No reason is a good reason for killing an innocent, vulnerable child. In fact, out of all the abortions performed for expecting mothers, less than one-percent of them are to save the life of a woman. Also, to perform an abortion because the child has a birth defect is discriminatory against people with disabilities. Additionally, the baby’s right to be alive is much more important than the mother’s right of deciding whether she wants a child or not.…

    • 875 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    However, as seen, along with this negative side of the prenatal testing, there are many positives for potential mothers. The argument then swings to who decides if a pregnant person should do the testing. Who decides what a pregnant person does with the results of the test? Should genetic counselors be more direct in their recommendations after positive tests, despite the limitation of doing so because of their professional value which prevents them from not being direct? In the end, who truly decides the fate of the fetus/potential child- the potential mother or all who have influenced…

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    If the individual does test positive for a certain genetic disease, this has no indication of the overall quality of life the person will live in the future. The choice for genetic screening may lead to reproductive decisions based on the genetics of the child and allows for parents to select for a better child. The choice to undergo prenatal screening implies that children with a certain genetic defect are less desirable and that the life of the child is somehow worth less and his/her life would not bring happiness. However, it would be unethical to take away the mother’s right to such services and abortion. The parents and the child would suffer, If the mother is not prepared or ready to take care of a child with genetic deformities.…

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Birth control also lowers the risk of unplanned pregnancy and abortions. Many abortions can be prevented if people used their heads. I am not pro abortion or am I for abortion either. I feel that some have reasons for their choice in having one and that their live is theirs. But I do feel as a baby anysize in the womb are babies and we should realize that we are making a life whether in the heat of the moment or not and if we do not intend to care for a child we need to take all measures to insure that we are protected so that "accidents" may not happen.But not only for pregnancy reasons, birth control pill has benefits to a woman 's menstrual cycle and helps lower some types of cancer.…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In fact, they think it is a better option for children and their parents. They can choose an embryo that is not going to be affected by a certain gene and then their child will not have a specific disease, but that does not make up for the fact that one of the embryos just gets thrown away. Also when someone changes the genes to avoid a disease there is always a possibility that the gene pools gets messed up. Overall, there are more cons in the situation than pros and “designer babies” are not worth the risk. Some people are not able to have children for medical reasons so they have to look into In Vitro Fertilization for further help, but “designer babies” are going farther than that.…

    • 1505 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Parents bear the responsibility of making life-shaping decisions in issues such as education and healthcare for their children. The growing skepticism against vaccines and the healthcare industry is worrying because it can potentially cause preventable deaths. In this paper, I will be responding to Sarah Pope’s entry in The Healthy Home Economist where she argued against vaccines. Pope established her family’s medical background to show that her claims are not unfounded. It is ironic that she used this to reel the reader to trust her because her background makes her a legitimate source of information, when in her previous paragraph she urged readers to realize that doctors can make mistakes and are blindly conveying information from the…

    • 1368 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays