Argument On Child Soldiers

Superior Essays
For years the use of children in both conflicts between states and civil wars has been evident. Children are forced by commanders through false promises, drugs and things which you can’t even imagine, to kill innocent civilians, other children and even their own families. Universally, the use of child soldiers has been frowned upon as both unacceptable and abhorrent. Despite this, in the last ten years over two million children have been killed, over one million orphaned, over six million have been left seriously injured or permanently disabled and over 10 million have been diagnosed with psychological trauma. However, the question still remains whether or not child soldiers should be held accountable for their crimes. In other words are child soldiers the victims or the perpetrators?

The debate regarding child soldiers has prolonged for years and as of yet there appears to be no definite answer. Both sides of the argument bring up strong points, but it is about time an answer is brought up.

On one side of the argument, many believe that child soldiers are not morally responsible for the actions they perform. More often than not children have no say in whether they enlist or not and once recruited the children become brainwashed through the use of drugs and alcohol. The drugs
…show more content…
For instance, many believe that child soldiers are mere replicas of child criminals; child criminals are prosecuted. Over the course of the past decades child soldiers have been responsible for some of the most brutal acts in wartime, such as rape, mutilation and mass killings of innocent civilians. Most domestic laws state that the age of criminal responsibility is much lower than 18 (child soldiers are generally considered children under the age of 18). If a child can be convicted for murder under these domestic laws there should be no exception for child soldier’s just because their crimes occurred in

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Doesn’t it seem a little ridiculous that some children are forced to become soldiers and then are punished for the crimes they committed in war? Well, in today's world, unfortunately, there are many child soldiers fighting all over the world. The topic child soldiers has become a bigger and bigger controversy across the world today because of weather or not child soldiers deserve amnesty. The reason why it has become so controversial is because many people question if it is truly the child's fault that he or she committed the war crimes. Some people think that the child is not responsible for there crimes because they are being forced to do them and think the child soldiers do deserve amnesty.…

    • 1839 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The children will forever be responsible for these brutal crimes that they committed. Next, according to “Child soldiers should be prosecuted”, “If a child can be convicted for murder under national law they should also be held responsible for international crimes. There should be no exception simply because the crimes occurred in wartime.” They are considered a child criminal so they should be punished. They are no different from child criminals that were not at war, so they should be punished the same way as the other kids not in a war that committed these crimes.…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is also a geostrategic and development issue. Child soldiers are usually depicted as victims. That’s accurate: Exploited, torn from their families, deprived of their education, and forced into battle, child soldiers are truly casualties of war.” (gates)They are then taken as a broken down child and ordered to do kill and them not knowing what they are doing, they…

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Child Soldiers can be rehabilitated to live in society, but it is hard work for the victim and for the nurses and others helping. The real question is, should they be prosecuted as criminals or victims? Ishmael Beah was a child soldier in Sierra Leone during the 1990’s to fight in there civil war. After being rescued he was rehabilitated and is now a husband, author, and lives in New York. He says that he still gets nightmares about what he did.…

    • 859 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Images last week from an ISIS video appearing to show a child executing a hostage were horrific. The very idea of the "cubs of the caliphate," as the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria dubs them, is stomach-churning.”) This statement and photos show that the children in the video are no more than 14 years old thus they would not have had enough experience in the world to make the right decision. (captaindarwin ) While some did this do to lack of experience while others did this because they were brainwashed by drugs and then threatened to kill or be killed.…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Can anyone possibly imagine a child in war causing havoc while carrying loaded weapons? Many child soldiers are being stolen from their families and being forced to fight and then being punished for their crimes committed in the wars. Unfortunately, there are tons of children forced to fight in the wars today. The topic child soldiers has become a huge controversy across the world today because of whether or not child soldiers deserve amnesty. The reason why it has become so controversial is because many people question if it is truly the child's fault that he or she committed the war crimes.…

    • 1523 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some kids choose to join them because of the allusion of better living conditions, but most are forced into it. These kids are taken and shaped like clay into killing machines. From these facts alone, child soldiers are clearly the victims. They are not only damaged physically, but mentally as well. Even when they are taken into safe havens, they are still harassed by guards that do not sympathise with these kids.…

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I believe that child soldiers are victims forced to be perpetrators. I say this because they are taken into war against their will, but then they commit many horrendous acts of killing and slaughter, which fills the perpetrator definition of someone who commits a crime. Some child soldiers are taken by government off of camps and forced into war, and if they try to leave they are shot down. In this situation, the soldiers are forced into combat and should be granted amnesty, but I believe that overall, child soldiers should only be granted amnesty if the prosecutors are certain the decision to go to war for these young soldiers was not their own. On one hand, child soldiers are victims and deserve amnesty.…

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Children come into this world in hopes of being the future of this world, but they never imagine themselves as stone cold killers. The dilemma of child soldiers has spread to hundreds of countries around the world and has no intention of slowing. Now, an estimated 300,000 children fight wars under the forceful hand of local militias that care none for the people they effect. They suffer the cruelest of things during their time as a child soldiers, the effects are frightening including all sorts of trauma that they may never recover from. Now these child soldiers have grown up and are looking for redemption in the new world but first are being prosecuted for their crimes as warlords.…

    • 1735 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One controversial issue over the past couple of years has been the topic of child soldiers. On one side, people argue that child soldiers should be prosecuted. On the other hand, others contend that they should be given amnesty. My own view is that child soldiers should be given forgiveness for what they have done because they were forced into killing, they were manipulated, and they only had one choice once they entered the army: Kill or be killed. When villages are attacked and families are taken away for children, they don’t know any better and they believe that the commanders are the adults that they should trust.…

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I have developed this opinion after conducting research on this topic. I have discovered that child soldiers are often forced into fighting through false promises. They are also forced into fighting through drugs and alcohol. The drugs, often cocaine mixed with gun powder, brainwash the children to the point where they would rather not escape from the horror unravelling around them. I personally believe anyone who has to submit to such horrors and atrocities should not be prosecuted for the crimes they committed.…

    • 822 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Child Soldiers Is Wrong

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages

    When thinking of children, most see a young, innocent human, incapable of dark tendencies without being provoked. Others don’t see the mind, age, or body, but the murder or illegal act committed in another country as a child soldier. However, evidence from the I.C.C. (International Criminal Court), lives of these child soldiers, and the repercussions of not granting these children amnesty all show that child soldiers should be given a pardon for their convictions. Out of the I.C.C.’s 128 articles on crimes throughout the world, only a handful can be used to give evidence for child soldiers.…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    No matter the situation child soldiers need to pay for their actions. Some kids will kill because they are forced but others are volunteering and wanting to get their hands on a gun and be able to use it to kill. The Child Soldier on Trial at Guantanamo article reads, “... he would recall how he had killed a U.S. soldier and that would make him happy. The implication, of course, was that Khadr was, in the words of one interrogator, ’cold and callous’”(Prasow 3/5). That little insert suggests that not all child soldiers regret the choices of becoming a killer and some actually enjoy the killing and shooting people.…

    • 564 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are a lot of children that have been taken away from their families and were put to commit crimes that are very dangerous children. In the article of child soldiers prosecution it states, “ children are often forced into fighting and having little choice over whether they enlist.” This means that children have no choice about being in the military. In the article it states, “ The recruiters of child soldiers also use drugs and alcohol to make children more compliant and enable them to commit crimes they wouldn’t not ordinarily commit.” This means that I guess children take drugs and alcohol to commit crimes that you probably wouldn’t expect them…

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although people might disagree with this reason of child soldiers dying, but child soldiers should not be killed or prosecuted. Over 100,000 child soldiers die every year. That’s a tremendous figure considering that there are only around 350,000 child soldiers in the world (child soldiers 1). That’s 28% of children soldiers in the world and 35% in the world. They all carry adult weapons, fight, and come face to face with death (Garris, James and Medcalf 1), .…

    • 563 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays