Are Controversial Arguments In Current Debates About Animal Agriculture?

Decent Essays
Many controversial issues exist in debates about scientific topics. Debates over environmental issues have become increasingly popular. More specifically, debates over climate change and animal agriculture have taken the stage at the forefront of controversy. A keyword implicitly stated throughout Peter H. Gleick’s “Climate Change and the Integrity of Science” and C. C. Croney, M. Apley, J. L. Capper, J. A. Mench, and S. Priest’s "BIOETHICS SYMPOSIUM: The Ethical Food Movement: What Does It Mean for the Role of Science and Scientists in Current Debates about Animal Agriculture?" is perception. Although the word perception is not directly stated throughout these two articles, perception can be inferred through how people understand the controversy presented by each article.

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    The agricultural/food industry has been in many argument about how animals and crops are being raised and killed to feed the american people. Michael Pollan uses his selection “An Animal’s Place” to defend his right to eat as he pleases. While, Blake Hurst uses his article “The Omnivore’s Delusion” to shield post-modern farming techniques from a mass of uneducated critics. Now, read as these two duke it out against their opponents to see if they can live as they want. Michael Pollan, a writer/activist, fights for his right to animals as he sees fit.…

    • 1352 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Genetically modified food is a controversial subject some see it as the future of agriculture others see it as dangerous. Michael Pollan author of “Playing God in the Garden” addresses that in his essay in one paragraph, in particular, he claims that “Uncertainty is the theme that unifies much of the criticism leveled against biotech agriculture by scientist and environmentalists.” Pollan believes that people are opposed to biotech agriculture because so much about it remains unknown. He chose to support his claim with different examples and by using the STARR criteria I can evaluate how effectively he supported his claim. The S means sufficiency the evidence that the author offered to support this claims is enough; he only uses one extended…

    • 450 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When it comes to Global warming, being a vegetarian should be turned to as a first resort rather than going more toward the Prius, a car that has been made to cut vehicle emissions in half in an attempt to fight against global warming. Kathy Freston’s article “Vegetarian is the new Prius” caught my eye immediately when choosing an essay for the very fact that, I want Toyota Prius, and also because I’ve tried going vegetarian. Although I see nothing wrong with being a vegetarian, the lifestyle just didn’t work for me. I do to a certain extent agree with her argument because ever since I took ecology in high school, the environment has been very important to me, and I do what I can to help preserve it. Freston wrote that President Herbert Hoover promised a chicken in every pot and a car in every garage”.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article that I chose to read is called “Ethical Discourse on the Use of Genetically Modified Crops: A Review of Academic Publications in the Fields of Ecology and Environmental Ethics.” The authors, Daniel Gregorowius, Petra Lindemann-Matthies, and Markus Huppenbauer, discuss the ethical issues present in a multitude of academic articles in regards to the use of genetically modified crops. The authors of this article are all staff members at different universities and specialize in the field of science, specifically in biology and ecology, and what those have to do with ethics. Therefore, these authors are very credible and also reliable since they are experts in the previously mentioned fields.…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Article: “Discussing Animal Rights and Animal Research in the Classroom” by Harold A. Herzog (96)I.Research Question The research question posited by Herzog (1990) is based on the ethical treatment of animals in terms of experimental psychology. Herzog (1990) states this question based on animal rights advocates that want to stop animal experimentation in clinical settings: “This article briefly reviews two major philosophical positions held by animal activists in their arguments against the scientific use of animals” (p.90). The subject of the ethical treatment of animals will be utilized to create a forum for healthy debate between students in a classroom setting. II.Introduction Herzog’s (1990) study seeks to understand the different…

    • 746 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Animal Rights Did you know that some animals on earth are being more and more abused because of animal cruelty? Around 900-2000 animals are abused every year. In 2007 1880 animals were being abused. 64.5% (1212) Involved dogs.…

    • 444 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Heading: The Blind Judgement Location: Chapter 3 (Decisions, Decisions: Elucidate All the Pros and Cons of a Decision) Summary: Society is often found to be quick to select a certain product over another, as they ambiguously evaluate the positives and negative of their decision. (Seethaler, 2009, 43) Through jumping towards conclusions, individuals, specifically researchers, are easily able to come to incorrect conclusions, inevitably leading innocent citizens to attend to irrational words. (Seethaler, 2009, 44) For instance, with the experiment performed on monarch butterflies where these insects were fed different versions of “milkweed leaves with pollen from corn”, it was found that merely 56% of these creatures survived when they were…

    • 281 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lappé argues that people do not realize that some of the things humans are putting into the air are causing global warming. She argues that agriculture is a big part of how humans contribute to global warming without realizing it. “Agriculture is responsible for most of the human-made methane and nitrous oxide in the atmosphere, which contribute 13.5 percent of total greenhouse gas emissions, primarily from animal waste mismanagement, fertilizer overuse, the natural effects of ruminant digestion, and to a small degree rice production.” (755) Unlike Steingraber and Lappé, authors Mark Tercek and Jonathan Adams tell how they were the people who didn’t pay attention to global warming, not until they had children. “My evolution into a conservationist began as I worked as an investment banker for Goldman Sachs—and, more tellingly, when I became a parent.…

    • 2039 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Toulmin Method

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Writing a written argument is an act which many people recommend you master. The Toulmin method facilitates the way one analyzes an argument. Stephen Toulmin gives us the basics to this method which allows many people to respond to the argument given and also leads one to improve the argument made. Toulmin’s method invites one to examine the claim, reasons, qualifiers, evidence, warrant backing, rebuttals for any counter-arguments, and exceptions of an argument to decide the effectiveness of an argument. In the article titled “The Locavore Myth: Why buying from nearby farmers won’t save the planet,” James McWilliams argues that although the Locavore movement has brought attention to industrialized food, the movement does not prevent damage…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Although some topics may be considered controversial, they need to be talked about. This is true with the subject of animal testing. In an article published in the New York Times, "Second Thoughts of an Animal Researcher", author John P. Gluck informs the reader why a scientist, who formerly conducted experiments on monkeys, would change his views to be against the practice of animal experimentation. He does this by using personal experiences. In another article, "Animal Research is Wasteful and Misleading", authors Neal D. Barnard and Stephen R. Kaufman use scientific data and evidence to make a logical case against animal testing.…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Snowball and Napoleon continue their debates, the greatest of which occurs over building a windmill on a knoll. Snowball argues in favor of the windmill, which he is certain will eventually become a labor-saving device; Napoleon argues against it, saying that building the windmill will take time and effort away from the more important task of producing food. The two also disagree on whether they should have a armory of guns or send out more pigeons to neighboring farms to spread news of the rebellion. On the Sunday that the plan for the windmill is to be put to a vote, Napoleon calls out nine ferocious dogs, who chase Snowball off the farm. Napoleon then announces that all debates will stop and makes a number of other new rules for the farm.…

    • 251 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We live on a beautiful and life giving planet that we don’t want to see being destroyed but still it seems that we carry out extreme and illogical activities that counter that presumption. Humans by nature are selfish and although that is something we cannot change anytime soon, there needs to be some sort of education for people to understand their actions that they play on the environment. We only have one planet and we should take care of it. The incredible devastation that animal agriculture is causing to our planet is alarming and not enough is being done about it. The E.P.A. recommends that individuals reduce their dependence of energy come from fossil fuels but new studies are now showing that the fact is that our incredibly immense practice of…

    • 1329 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Animal Rights Should animals have rights? If so, should these rights be comparable to those given to humans? Animal Rights are rights believed to be owed to animals in order for them to live full lives, free from suffering. Animals are currently being used, and in some cases abused, in medical research, clothing industries, hunting for sport, food, and population control, and countless other services to humans. As is the case with all ethical issues, there are two defined perspectives and supporters of the current and future treatment given and due to animals.…

    • 1264 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Animal Testing Nowadays scientist create many new things that make our life easier or even better than before . This can include creations of: hair gain shampoo, delicious chocolate or impactful medicine, and this has to be tested for perfection. The people of this country want perfection and this includes people and animals as well. This includes testing their products on animals who are perfect for experimental study such as monkeys or rats. In reality, experimenting on animals will make our world a better place.…

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Name: Woo Yew Seng Student ID: 0323989 Title: Should animals be used for research? (Argumentative essay) What is animal research?…

    • 1062 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays