Susan Engel's Then And Now: Creating A Self Through The Past

Superior Essays
Susan Engel shares a variety of psychological ideas in an excerpt from her book, “Then and Now: Creating a Self Through the Past.” These ideas include “the extended self,” “screen memories,” and “template memories,” which are concepts that can be helpful in analyzing personal development. As example of the process of analysis is offered by Barry Lopez, who reflects his extended self and memories in his memoir, “A Passage of the Hands.” Various stories of his hands are used to register the experiences that shaped him. Another example is offered by Alan Strang, the main character in Peter Shaffer’s play “Equus.” Alan ends up in a mental hospital because of a heinous act. Alan’s psychologist, Dysart, carefully looks into Alan’s memories to account …show more content…
Engel explains aspects human development through her concepts of the extended self, screen memories, and template memories. These concepts can help understand the development of personal identity. Engel is a professor at Williams College and wrote “Then and Now: Creating a Self Through the Past” to educate students how identities of people are developed through accessing and contemplating memories. From here explain engel more. Say how stories define who we are. This results in the extended self. The passage starts off with the extended self; this is defined as an “awareness of consciousness,” which is an understanding of continuity of self over time (Engel 196). Refer to example of birthday party… In other words, a sense of identity is developed through memories and the extended self helps the person recognize and articulate that identity. In his memoir, Lopez freely recalls past experiences that shaped his persona, thus demonstrating his extended self. Alan from Shaffer’s play was unable to form an extended because his memories are too painful. To strengthen her argument, Engel introduces template memories and screen memories. Though they are very similar, template …show more content…
“A Passage of the Hands,” was written in 1997 with a goal of giving a sensory experience of his life. The memoir shows the development of his identity through life experiences. and coincides with Engel’s concepts of the extended self and template memories. Lopez forms an extended self by recalling events from an early age. He says “it is from these first years,” where he can vividly remember “a great range of texture” (Lopez 28). He then recalls a myriad of textures experienced from a young age which range from the sharpness of a saw, to the softness of a dog’s head. This ties back to Engel’s concept of the extended self because Lopez is able to recollect early memories that contribute to his personality. Throughout the years, Lopez develops a sense of identity through his early memories. In addition to Lopez having an extended self, he goes into great detail of memories with his hands; these memories are template memories which follow a similar pattern. Throughout his memoir, Lopez recalls a variety of stories with his hands. Though the stories are different, they evoke similar feelings which are brought back in great detail. The myriad of memories “bring forth affection” to Lopez’s hands as he recalls differentiating the feeling “between husks of the casaba and the honeydew melon,” and the “wire bristle of a hog’s back” (Lopez 34). These vivid experiences result in a pattern of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Throughout the article, Cooper reveals defining moments in Robert Creeley’s life which, aids analyzing and understanding his works more effectively. Creeley’s rebellious behavior towards traditionally defined values is evident through his life and his works, as he abandons his Harvard degree just a few months shy from earning it, in order to acquire an unusual experience. Moreover, he even decides to join an experimental school to violate the conventional status quo in poetry which was long-established by the likes of T.S Eliot and Robert Frost. Through examining Creeley’s style, self-portrait is examined differently as throughout the poem the protagonist is exemplified as an angry broken man, however, given Creeley’s psychology the poem’s meaning transforms to becoming a poem about attempts of escaping a certain archetype but is tied attached by certain physical or emotional qualities.…

    • 242 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Patricia Hampl’s “Memory and Imagination” provides a coherent insight about what a memoir consist of. Hampl begins to explain that a memoir is “a matter of transcription,” meaning that one has the power to present what details they choose to share. As a memoirist, you soon begin to question whether your memory is a reliable source or if your mind filled those empty gaps with desirous details. However, those memories that we simply remember must have been part of a life-changing moment that was not apparent to us at that moment. Although one intended goal could be accuracy, writing a memoir could help one discover what they know compare to the assumption of what happened.…

    • 529 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    A 36-year-old Dominican man with a chief symptom of back pain comes to see me for the first time. As his new internist, I tell him, I have to learn as much as I can about his health. Could he tell me whatever he thinks I should know about his situation? And thenIdomybestnottosayaword,nottowritein his chart, but to absorb all that he emits about his life and his health. I listen not only for the content of his narrative, but for its form — its temporal course, its images, its associated subplots, its silences, where he chooses to begin in telling of himself, how he sequences symptoms with other life events.…

    • 156 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At some time in life, a person will experience death of a relative or lose something that was very important to he or she. After that traumatic event, will that person confront his or her pain, or will that person bury it deep within them? Both ways are possible, however, only one is effective in the long term. According to Tim O'Brien, the most effective way to heal after a traumatic experience is to share stories. In Tim’s book, The things they carried, he used the motifs of loneliness, life, and the mood of nostalgia to illustrate the importance of sharing stories during a healing process.…

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jack Wolff Identity Essay

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The summer of 1955 is an unordinary summer for Jack Wolff. Trapped in the transitioning body of an eleven-year-old boy, Jack is drowning in the emotional trauma of a violent home life, illegal activities, and a lack of emotional support known as his childhood. This is a major period of change for any young boy, and dealing with the extensive distress does not allow him to mature in the conventional manner. Due to his abnormal progression, a common theme arises within the first part Jack’s life: a lack of identity and a lack self-worth fuels the constant need for power.…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When I walk past someone that is physically and mentally different than myself, I assume and judge; but my assumption is not always right because I haven’t been in their shoes to where I can completely fathom their situation. People tend to evaluate others harshly when they don’t know them personally. In “The Cathedral” by Raymond Carver, the husband has a hard time understanding the relationship between the wife and the blind man, Robert. Throughout the story, Carver shows us that assumptions interfere with the overall impression of a person and that audible communication increases understanding by using literary devices and elements of character. Carver gives the husband a straight but, aggravated tone which characterizes him as pessimistic…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Many individuals find themselves socially and mentally isolated from others due to their ideals and state of mind that contradict society’s beliefs, which leave them unable to relate or communicate with others. Du Bois’s short story, “Of the Coming of John”, tells a fictional tale of a colored black man living during a time when the Jim Crow system of oppression was prominent. This naive man, John Jones, leaves his southern home in Altamaha to pursue an education up north, but quickly notices the cultural divide and opportunity differences caused by the systemic oppression and segregation of the country. After absorbing that information and realizing that potential, he returns back home, but finds himself detached and unable to connect with…

    • 1391 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Donald M. Murray’s memoir, “The Stranger in the Photo Is Me,” ascertains the idea that life changes as we change. He explicitly enforces this idea by inundating his audience with his impactful usage of both antithesis and juxtapositions to express his belief of innocence versus experience. Murray narrows the idea of innocence versus experience by ultimately speaking on his positive self versus what has happened in the intervening years, and how once he became older, he became much more aware of what has happened. As Murray goes deeper into his argument, his use of antithesis and juxtapositions become clear during his shift from alluding to memories in his younger age to transforming into someone he never thought he would become, and ultimately referring to himself as a “stranger.”…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1) What is autobiographical memory? What does it mean to say that it includes both episodic and semantic components? Autobiographical memories are memories from life experiences that are collected throughout time. It is consisted of both episodic which are specific events that had occurred within people’s lives and semantic memories are the actual facts related to the specific events.…

    • 522 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Many parents will at one point, comment on the personality of their child. This happens even more frequently as the family has more children. This is because you can start to see clearer divides between each child that paints a clearer picture of their own distinct personality. These initial characteristics never seem to go away. For instance, someone who is outspoken and loud as a child will most likely grow up to be the same way.…

    • 1890 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I was born and raised in Brownsville, Texas; my environment shaped me to become someone responsible, an over achiever, and a determined young man. The people who had the biggest impact on me is the woman who gave me life, my father, and my community. My mother was already there for me even before I stared walking, she was there to comfort me when I fell on my knees. She was my first teacher, the one who taught me morals and set up my standards; whenever we had a family party and all of our thirty members were together, she will make me introduce and address myself to every single one and if ever forgot to say hi to someone she will just give me a look to make realize my mistake, and I will immediately go on to that person and say sorry for…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thus, theories of personal identity attempt to answer the question of personal identity by giving examples…

    • 1193 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Good afternoon teachers and students, this speech will be about the key ideas of human experience in the play King Lear by William Shakespeare. Human experiences can be influenced by past decisions and traits, which aid in establishing characteristics and new profound perceptions of their surroundings. William Shakespeare’s play King Lear involves the ageing protagonist who had decided to resign his throne to his three daughters in exchange for a fulfilling speech. Throughout the play, the king stumbles upon numerous human experiences, that include: Pride, Betrayal and Epiphany.…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Frankenstein, Mary Shelley talks about a monster, who transforms from an innocent individual to an evil person at the end. The entire story revolves around the monster and his creator, who abandons the monster at the time of monster’s creation. Furthermore, the society rejects the monster and this rejection changes the harmless being to a harmful creature. Thus, Shelly comments on the idea of human nature being learned and not innate through her tale of the monster. I strongly believe Mary Shelley’s portrayal of the monster in the story depicts human transformation based on their experience in the society.…

    • 1468 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This speaker explains his memory, and allows us to sense his connection with his father by his point of view it is being told in. To enhance this…

    • 2056 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays