Utilitarianism: A Case Study

Improved Essays
1. I do not think that any animal deserves to be held in captivity and paraded around for human pleasure. Also, I do not think that commercial fisherman should be able to use unsafe fishing practices that harm other sea creatures in the process. There are better and more humane ways to catch fish than dragging nets across the ocean where many different species are caught, injured, and killed. Unfortunately, the fishing industry like many others is consumer driven and in order to supply a cheap product, the fisherman must use the most efficient methods to catch fish which do not benefit other species of fish in the ocean. I am going to apply my argument to the theory of Utilitarianism. “For utilitarianism, the use of nonhuman animals can be acceptable only if the happiness their exploitation causes is greater than the harm it causes” (“Utilitarianism”). I cannot see how a person’s happiness can outweigh the harm that is done to dolphins or any other animal. These …show more content…
I do not think that there should be special considerations for animals that have a higher intellect or special characteristics, because all animals should be treated equally. From an elephant to an ant, I think all species should be looked at as special. Every species on this planet serves a purpose whether they are low or high on the food chain. I think humans can sometimes identify better with animals that exhibit human characteristics. For instance, elephants are very family oriented and chimpanzees display many human characteristics. It is easier for humans to relate to these intellectual animals compared to an ant or a cricket. Just because an ant or a cricket does not possess our level of intellect or conscious does not mean that they are less worthy or less important. We must remember that the human species in not the all mighty species like we all like to think. Animals have ruled this planet far before humans did and I think they should be shown the same respect that we humans show each

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    "The best way to observe a fish is to become a fish" stated by Jacques Yves Cousteau, Oceanographer. No one really understands what animals in the ocean and animals in captivity feel, therefore these two opposing viewpoints try to find which is better for the animal. One opposing viewpoint is keeping marine mammals captive in theme parks promotes conservation. The other viewpoint believes keeping marine mammals captive in theme parks is cruel. Both viewpoints are strong, but keeping marine mammals captive in theme parks is cruel is the strongest viewpoint.…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Practice with a freshwater tropical aquarium is important before upgrading to the more advanced water tank for your fish pet.Brackish Aquariums The last type of aquarium in your bucket list should be the brackish aquarium because brackish water tank systems can be tricky to maintain. Fish pet owners who use this type of water tank are very rare. A mixture of freshwater and saltwater is needed to produce the right type of brackish water. It’s considered to be on the middle level and at the same time, it shouldn’t be as strong as saltwater that’s used for marine aquariums. The fish that can live in a brackish aquarium are very few and in some pet stores, brackish fish are not handled properly before being sold to customers.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    A significant factor that was not present prior to the collapse was communication. If fishermen were to communicate effectively with each other, the collapse could have been avoided. For example, if the governor or higher authority of the region were to set a quota or limit on how much fish the fishermen can catch, the volume of fish in the fishery would not diminish as fast. In general, what this means is that fishermen should not aim to fulfil their wants by fishing as much as they want, they should communicate with each other to come up with a system as to how much fish they can catch, this way they can preserve the amount of fish in the waters for the long run. According to the article on greenpeace.org, Canada increased its fishing limits.…

    • 1713 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tuna Fish Case Study

    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Marine Conservation Institute has observed that bottom trawling is more wasteful then beneficial due to the machines dragging 905 by catch, which later gets tossed back overboard. Economically, this decision is sound in banning the practice. Policy Option 3: Regulate fishing seasons by catch per pound. The most sustainable option that considers both parties of consumer and environment is this. There does not have to be a ban on fishing to stop the overfishing crises – but instead implement a set limit on catch.…

    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The treatment of marine animals in the Vancouver Aquarium is a depraved action because it unethically treats animals as resources for human purposes. For example, marine animals such as dolphins and belugas are utilized for entertainment and experimental studies (“Beluga Research”). This remains a significant problem because keeping marine animals in confinement for human purposes is a violation of animal rights to live freely from human utilization, regardless the type of treatment that the marine animals are receiving. Generally, these detrimental types of treatment against marine animals are used as means to attain human ends such as entertainment and innovative treatments or discoveries resulting from research experiments (“Beluga Research”).…

    • 1476 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Littering Argument Essay

    • 1257 Words
    • 6 Pages

    It is then caught and cut up for consumption. According to the Surf Foundation, the plastic consumed by the fish carries organic pollutants such as DDT, PCBS, mercury and other toxins (“What goes into the ocean”). Without awareness of the fish’s whereabouts, consumption of this fish may lead to crucial health problems. Not just the fish, but the person who ate it and the environment around the fish is now in danger. Some assumptions that the ad makes about the audience is that they are close by the coastlines and liter quite often.…

    • 1257 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The film Blackfish tries to convince the audience that organizations like Seaworld hold wild animals back from having a good life. Personally I do not agree with the film, Seaworld is a very successful…

    • 727 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In captivity that’s right, the smartest animal is used for our amusement. You may think that the orcas get taken care of, and are properly fed, but they are not. Also when you read all this stuff on orcas killing humans no one knows the backstory. But if you keep reading you will finally know why the smartest animals are going after humans and people. My first reason why orcas should not be in captivity is that of the space issue.…

    • 1544 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Is it because they don't speak like us there for we don't listen to how they feel? Animals can't talk for themselves, all they can do experience the emotion. For example, apes, they are a very smart species. Scientist have found ways to communicate with an animal through sign language--a language we can understand. Scientists have proven that apes are the closest animal species we have to humans.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Animals should have similar rights as people, and we need to learn to share our planet with them. Just because we have more power over most of them, doesn’t give us the right to abuse or torture them, because we wouldn’t on our own kind. Animal testing is pointless, it doesn’t not give correct and reliable results, and it does not benefit either people or animals hugely. Joaquin Phoenix once said, “It takes nothing away from a human to be kind to an animal.” We will not see any negative effects on humans if we start treating animals with the respect and freedom they deserve. It is a factor that is bringing our planet down, and we need to stand up for it, and we could save millions of lives a…

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays