Andrea Yates's Conviction Case Study

Improved Essays
Children are a blessing to everyone. The joy of carrying the baby and experiencing the pains of labor is an experience that a mother never forgets. Not every woman can have children. Some have to adopt. All women will not have the experience to have a child whether that decision is by force (abortions at a young age, cancer in ovaries etc.,) or choice (A woman does not want to bear children). Yes there are things that can happen to further complicate a woman from loving her child(ren) unconditionally. But when does that mean to kill your children? What can a child do to you so badly that you resort to killing them? You had a chance to live the best life you could, your child did not. Andrea Yates had five children under the age of 10. One of her children did not even get to see their first birthday. This …show more content…
In January of 2005, Yates's conviction was overturned when the courts learned that Dr. Park Dietz, a prosecution psychiatrist, had made a false statement on the stand Dr. Dietz had claimed that Yates could have gotten the idea to kill her children and feign mental illness from an episode of Law and Order. However, that episode had never aired and there were some things that was exaggerated during the testimony. The appeals court felt that the false testimony could have influenced the jury's perception of the case (Kesling, 2006). Although the psychiatrist that testified for the prosecution made false testimony about the state of mind of Yates, other psychiatrists say that she was completely when she decided to kill her children on that day (Parker, 2006). According to Parker Texas law defines insanity as the inability to know right from wrong. At Yates' trial four years ago, Dietz testified that Yates knew that drowning her children was wrong. Jurors agreed with Dietz's opinion and rejected her insanity defense (Parker,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The level of childlessness has doubled in thirty years and the world could be in danger of under population. Some women are childfree by choice, meaning they choose not to have children for a number of different reasons. Many celebrities are childfree, even Dr. Seuss did not have children, which is ironic due to the great deal of children’s books he has written. While reading the selection Childfree by Choice by Kelly J. Welch, I developed the belief that all women should have the option of whether or not they want to have children. While some people believe all women or married couples should bear children, lack of interest, logical thoughts, and unfortunate circumstances are some reasons they would remain childless.…

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Casey Anthony Trial

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Cindy Anthony reported her granddaughter Caylee missing on July 15, 2008 after 31 days (Casey Anthony Trial, 2011). Casey Anthony was question by detectives and she informed them that the nanny kidnapped her daughter (Alvarez, 2011). Casey stories where very inconsistent throughout the investigation. This is how she became a suspect in the disappearance of her daughter Caylee Anthony. Casey was indicted for first-degree murder in…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Andrea Yates: Mother or Monster Mothers have been thought of as nurturing caregivers. Caregivers who have always done and thought of what is best for their children. Nevertheless, what happens when the nurturing mother becomes the monster? What causes them to undergo such a drastic transformation?…

    • 2451 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Serial Killers Essay

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    • 6 Works Cited

    According to law, a person is “not guilty by reason of insanity” if they do not have the capacity to know right from wrong, therefore;…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    • 6 Works Cited
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I, Judge Awotwi, presided over the mock trial State Prosecution vs. Macbeth, and it is my duty to uphold the rule of law and instruct true justice upon this issue. The defendant entered a plea of insanity due to delusional compulsion before this court on October 24, 2017, after committing beyond a doubt one count of murder and two counts of felony murder. The question is not whether Macbeth committed these crimes, or if he is judged to be found guilty; it is to judge if the defendant “did not have [the] mental capacity to distinguish between right and wrong”, and that is the responsibility of the court (16-3-2). Due to the facts presented in court I have come to a verdict. The defense’s unique argument and main points overwhelmed the predominant…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dr. Resnick's Analysis

    • 254 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Dr. Resnick’s own conclusion was that Yates was severely mentally ill because she reported having delusions and hallucinations. The first explanation of this was that Yates didn’t want her children to burn in hell so she drowned them because she couldn’t bear to do nothing about it. The second explanation was that Yates kept her psychosis to herself because she was under the delusion that Satan could hear what she said and force her own children. The third reason was that Yates believed it would be a greater sin had she not killed her children.…

    • 254 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The lawyer that stood to defend Yates described her as one of insanity as she had no control of her mental self when she committed the crime. “Andrea Yates had undergone intense medication that would have messed her mental self. The several doctors that she had been through gave her strong medication that rendered her body weak” (Denno, 2003). This gave her hallucinations, depressions among other attributes of a mental ill person. In addition to this, she was going through intense pressure from her family; her husband wanted to get another child against the recommendation of her doctor, while her father had passed away.…

    • 1542 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Some reasons one might choose to end a child’s life was based on disability, gender, lack of resources to care for the child, or illegitimacy. In earlier times it was easier to get by with filicidal acts due to inaccurate paperwork. Authorities might overlook these acts due to overcrowding issues and low resources available in unimproved areas (West). In the 20th century with improvements to economic conditions, changes in societal norms, better healthcare and increased services to the disabled many of the reasons for filicide that seemed reasonable in earlier times now…

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If all women who did not want to have offspring put their child up for adoption, this difference would be even bigger. This causes more children to go without families, which could have detrimental effects on a child’s life. These include health risks, homelessness or bad housing, and involvement in the criminal justice system (“The AFCARS Report” 6). It is not morally right to force a person to live under such circumstances. If the woman is forced to go through with the pregnancy, it could cause the child to have a worse life.…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dietz report concluded “Mr. Hinckley 's history is clearly indicative of a person who did not function in a usual reasonable manner. However, there is no evidence that he was so impaired that he could not appreciate the wrongfulness of his conduct or conform his conduct to the requirements of the law” (2008). Ultimately, the determination of guilt or innocence lad on the jury and they came back with a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity for the fifteen…

    • 1387 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The loss of a child is excruciating. Most human beings feel empathy for the family. When a child is murdered, the sense of hope for humanity is lost. So why is murder different than abortion? Is a fetus not a form of living life?…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Case Of Andrea Yates

    • 1780 Words
    • 8 Pages

    In the case of Andrea Yates she did realize what she did was wrong, but could not appreciate the wrongfulness her actions during the time of the crime. Even with the flaws of the tests Andrea still met criteria from both of them to show that she was insane. For example, Andrea claims she was possessed by Satan during the crimes and asked for a razor to shave her head to reveal the mark of the beast 666, which shows that Andrea Yates was clearly not thinking in a reasonable matter and therefore could not be responsible for her actions…

    • 1780 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Bartol and Bartol (2011, p. 244) if an individual pleads not guilty by the circumstance of insanity, then the psychiatric evaluation should be focused on the individual 's mental state at the time of the crime. This basis is very much in line with the recommendation of Dr. Siegel in his letter to the…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    was found not guilty by reasoning of insanity. Still seen as mentally unstable, he was immediately sent to St. Elizabeth’s Hospital in Washington D.C. The nation was outraged by the verdict. Some states were so belligerent that they banned the insanity defense all together. The said-to-be schizophrenic’s parents would open a fund to support the mentally ill and awareness for the mentally ill.…

    • 1609 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Abortion Crime

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Do you know how many people in the world abort their children? Studies show that abortion had increased by eight percent in the past fifteen years. In 2001 the abortion numbers dropped by five percent going from one thousand and twenty one million abortions in one year to one thousand and fifteen million abortions in a year, but not long after that the abortion numbers started increasing. Because the numbers of aborted children went up, more people were dying and getting hurt. The child that gets aborted dies or course but that also leaves the mother to feel pain after she aborts her own baby.…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays