Examples Of Skewed Framing Of Immigration

Improved Essays
The way in which issues are framed, that is, defining what factors are considered issues at all, is instrumental in determining whether a problem will be truly solved, or if instead a pseudo problem is simply solved instead. A limited frame is what inhibits policy makers from truly being able to address the core issues of many problems today, thus causing uncertainty, ineffective policies, and offense to many. Perhaps one of the most skewed framings is the one of immigration. In “The Framing of Immigration,” by George Lakoff and Sam Ferguson, the two maintain the warrant that all immigrants arrive with intentions of eventually becoming productive members of society. Utilizing strong language and compelling statistics, the pair argue that policy …show more content…
Both Lakoff and Ferguson claim that this convenient framing not only hinders policy makers from finding a true solution, but also hides the true global implications of immigration, shifting the blame to lay entirely upon the migrants. Regardless of how immigration is framed, solutions are inherently limited once the word “immigration” is left within the naming of the frame. This framing immediately limits immigration to being at the fault of “illegal immigrants,” not the fault of the root factors that, in actuality, cause the subsequent problems that are associated with immigration (5, 6). A notable example of a politician framing an issue to be more favorable for himself would be President Bush. Like many of the politicians before him, and those still of today, President Bush took advantage of framing immigration when he discussed his plans for “immigration reform” (2). He created a frame that made the “problem” far easier on himself, in lieu of focusing on the true core issue. The reader might see how it is far easier for a politician to promise the American people …show more content…
While immigrants are blamed for coming to America and “taking” American jobs from the people, Lakoff and Ferguson point out that the employers that illegally employ these immigrants conveniently escape scrutiny, and are not labeled as “illegals” themselves (6). The refugees are vital for the for the economy, and contrary to popular misconception, the jobs that the economic refugees come to America for are not the ones that are heavily sought after, rather they are often menial jobs that Americans take for granted get done (4). Refugees fleeing their homes in an attempt to find the America Dream should not be treated as degenerates, rather they deserve the respect that framing often robs them of.
All people that come to the United States of America in search of the American Dream and desire to be productive members of society, no matter where from, should be treated with respect and open arms. Currently, all framings of immigration fall short of properly containing the dilemma, as it is far more complex than what first meets the eye. The only true solution lies in expanding the scope and understanding of what is truly going on, inter-complexities and all, as the solution does not lie within one frame, but in that of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    George W. Bush, Ben Carson, and many others also share a similar stance on immigration. Yes, it is true that they do jobs Americans will not do, but blaming Americans for this is gratuitous. In fact, “illegals do work that American 's cannot do because Americans must adhere to minimum wage and labor laws” (Coffey). Cheap labor leads to an overall drop in wages, which decreases the popularity of that occupation. They stay away from those jobs not because they want to, but they are forced to.…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although I agree most with Hillary Clinton’s views, I do not fully approve of it. I feel the American people need a fair combination of strict and lenient middle grounds. We need to strengthen our borders, but only deport those that cause harm and are known to be involved with gangs, or drug activities, regardless of race. There are plenty of hard working people from foreign lands that have come to our country, and it would be a monumental burden on our economy to deport those hardworking people who are here for a better life. I personally have known illegal immigrants who put forth more effort and had been more grateful for the opportunities in America than most Native-born Americans who take their opportunities for granted.…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As stated above immigrants are paying a lot of money towards taxes and they’re getting nothing in return.Yet they’re considered the bad people and even if they are not legal they are still helping out some Americans don’t even do that. Therefore, society should not view immigrants as dangerous…

    • 1895 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The only difference is that illegal immigrants don’t receive anything in return to compensate for it. Also there’s a renown practice followed by illegal immigrants to work more than what they’re getting paid and taking less welfare than natives. This is not only good for the U.S as a country but also benefits businesses.…

    • 1484 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    David Bennet, a historian, disagrees with the idea that anxiety of illegal immigrants is motivated by the difficulty of finding jobs that are already taken by illegal immigrants (Ball). Ball writes that diversity is the cause for society’s panic because it threatens security and values. I disagree with Bennet and Ball’s views. I think the idea of diversity is a cover up so people do not look selfish when they say they are worried about their jobs. Because undocumented immigrants are willing to be paid less, Americans struggle to compete for the jobs.…

    • 923 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This could be due to language or education barriers, but immigrant jobs usually compliment native-born jobs rather than take them (1). Illegal immigrants go for jobs that will not get them caught in the system. Many of these include sewing or maintenance work for very little income. Legal immigrants go for construction labor, taxi drivers, and maid jobs (Camarota and Zeigler 1). These are jobs that many Americans, even in need of work, would not wish to do.…

    • 2318 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is good for politicians like Donald Trump to awaken voters with informative and riveting speeches. Furthermore, as stated before, illegal immigrants bring crime into the country, steal money from government programs, and take many jobs from Americans. Therefore, Illegal immigration are detrimental to the United States, and Americans should no longer share some of the same values as the founding fathers, for they did not think of the unintended consequences. If Americans changed their way of thinking, it would help the country heal and progress to a better…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    citizens. In this journal, “Unskilled Workers Lose Out to Immigrant”, focuses on how and why U.S. citizens lose out on jobs and are given to illegal immigrants. It is important to note that U.S employers hire illegal immigrants and pay them at a lower rate, even though this act is illegal. However, some employers look pass this and move forward with hiring illegal immigrants. Hiring illegal immigrants for jobs that many U.S. citizens do not want helps our economy with more work production leading to a better outcome.…

    • 2256 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In short, having undocumented immigrants is unacceptable because of the fact that they [undocumented immigrants] are steering livelihood away from our nation’s citizens. Nonetheless, the United States should not restrict all immigrants, instead have an immigration reform for undocumented immigrants. Whereas there are legal immigrants who are working in America that are contributing to strengthening and building to expand our nation’s economy such as filling the labor…

    • 1464 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This subclaim was chosen because the fear of job and benefit loss is at the center of the immigration debate while America also ignores the economic benefits of undocumented immigrants. The first reason discussed is that undocumented immigration is a cheap labor problem (4). This reason was chosen because cheap labor affects the economy. Evidence used to support this reason include specific companies use of undocumented immigrants for their low wages (4). Furthermore, the authors also use the evidence about supply and demand — specifically how increase supply of workers drive down wages (9).…

    • 1135 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays