Analysis: Should College Athletes Be Paid

Superior Essays
Should college athletes be paid? People believe that college athletes should be compensated for their time they give up. Many people believe that college athletes should be paid a small amount of money for the luxuries they desire for many reasons. A few of the reasons athletes should be compensated are that they do not have time to get a job if they wanted to, they are the ones who bring in all the revenue to the colleges, and it would create a sense of financial awareness for others. Universities would not be as popular if it were not for college athletes. These sport programs bring a good supply of financial help to universities. Usually the athletes are the star of the show and have no income to back it up. Without the student athletes, …show more content…
Players should be compensated for putting their lives at risk, and intentionally injuring themselves for their teams. “Is it fair that coach Nick Saban of the University of Alabama recently signed a $55.2 million contract, but Tyrone Prothro, the Crimson Tide wide receiver celebrated for making “The Catch” in 2005, fractured both bones in his lower leg in his next game? Saban is wealthy and Protho is in debt and out of football” (Karaim 14). It is hard to understand how this player should suffer from insufficient funds after playing a big role on the football team. The opposite side has their own opinion about the situation. “Student-athletes are amateurs who choose to participate in intercollegiate athletics as part of their educational experience, thus maintaining a distinction between student-athletes who participate in the collegiate model and professional athletes who might be students as well. Participation in collegiate sports is not a student-athlete’s job. His or her ability to compete is contingent upon continued enrollment and academic eligibility. Because these athletes are not employees, it follows that they should not be unionized.”(Karaim 15). Some believe that the player should have insurance anyway that would help cover the expense of their medical injury. The opposite side believes that since the players are amateurs, they should not be compensated for their time spent …show more content…
They put long hours into not only game days and practices, but also into promoting the school and building the program to recruit other players. There have been many instances in which players have been severely injured in practices or games, which causes them to be out for the season. Once these players are injured they not only can no longer play the sport they love, but they also can not do other activities in their lives. When college players get injured, it also leads to high medical bills. Without college players getting paid, how are they expected to play for their medical bills and other extra expense? College players bring in a great amount of revenue for the universities. Without these important athletes, then the colleges would not receive all the money that comes from all the activities that they are affiliated with. If it were not for all the college athletes then the universities would not receive as much money, or get as near as much recognition and be as well known to others. College athletes and sports draw thousands of fans to their fields, stadiums, and gyms each year. This gives the school ua platform to not only recruit other athletes to join their program, but also to recruit more students to attend their school. If college athletes would receive wages for their sacrifice to their schools, it would be beneficial to the athletes but also to the

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Paying College Athletes

    • 1342 Words
    • 6 Pages

    According to some, getting a full ride to a college isn’t enough. Many think that college athletes should be getting paid because their sport, is their job. Others think that getting a full ride to go to school is enough and college athletes get enough benefits as it is. College athletes may take an educational decline to support their team but these athletes have many tools for success that everyday students are having to pay for. College athletes shouldn’t be paid to play sports because many are already getting scholarships to help out the financial aspect of college, recruiting athletes would be even more based on having a powerhouse, wealthy school than it already is, and these athletes are given an opportunity to become professional athletes,…

    • 1342 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This quote is stating a prime reason why college athletes should not be paid; the athletes are already receiving money for playing a sport. Why do the athletes need a paycheck on top of thousands of dollars in scholarship money? Numerous college athletes are capable of receiving both athletic and academic scholarships. Many college students have a hard time just paying for a college level education, therefore it is simply unfair for the student’s who choose to go to college for education to not receive a high amount of money in scholarships as well if the athletes get paid on top of his or her scholarship (Block). The athletes should not receive any more treatment than going to college for free, if other students aren’t receiving any more money on top of scholarships as well.…

    • 1088 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    College sports is a big part of many peoples live and not just the athletes. but paying these athletes to play when they are already getting a free education along with free living is just outrageous. Yes, the athlete should get more rights to their name, memorabilia, and jersey sales but they are already getting enough from the school. There is no fair way to go about paying these student athletes and that will always be a main controversy to the idea. The athletes do put the people in the stands but the school is giving those athletes the opportunity of a life time and they should be happy with what they are…

    • 1619 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example their days are longer because they have classes and practices. The role of a college athlete is vital for some universities because it provides school spirit and attracts people from around the state to visit that college. College athletes understand their role and some believe that they should be rewarded extra money due to…

    • 1423 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This would bring problems because the women would feel mistreated even though they do not bring in as much money as male sports do. If the college players got paid it would make professional sports not as big of a deal because they are already getting paid. Students would care less about their education because they are already making money playing sports and may think that they don’t need to go to class. A lot of people watch college sports because to these kids it is not about the money, but more for the love of the game. The competition is better because it is…

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    College scholarships can only support a student for so much. Earning a salary would substitute the money they would be earning if they were able to have a job. In the book College Athletes for Hire: The Evolution and Legacy of the NCAA 's Amateur Myth written by Allen L. Sack and Ellen J. Staurowsky says, world-class athlete from lower-class backgrounds are supposed to be able to train and travel but the real question is how are they supposed to find time to work a regular job? They found the solution to make up for time missed due to training would be to financially compensate the athlete allowing them to compete successfully.…

    • 1767 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Many on the opposing side state that since college athletes are the reason the NCAA acquire such a large amount of money, would it not be morally right to pay the athletes? After all, they train like an Olympic for their sport. I believe that this opposing argument is incorrect. Although college athletes generate a large cir-plus in money, I believe that free tuition alone takes care of that. Any student in the world would accept free tuition, while college athletes look at it as a small part of the professional plan.…

    • 1360 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    First off, if one team wants to start paying their players, based on the amount of revenue that teams produces, it would flag the question as to whether or not all athletes for each sport in the college should be paid. Some people who are involved will be against all teams getting paid and others will be for it. If schools decided to only pay certain players, other teams or athletes may quit from this unfair, discriminating act. If they only pay the biggest revenue making teams, commonly football and basketball, are all players going to get paid, even those who sit on the bench? “Commonly, players and their families often overestimate a player’s market worth.…

    • 1366 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    College sports provide a huge source of colleges’ income. The school takes in money from ticket sales, television contracts, and sport-related merchandise etc. The athletes receive their scholarship and little more. While receiving a free college education is something few people would complain about, when the issue is more closely examined it becomes obvious that it is not enough. The colleges are utilized athletes, and recently the problems that this creates have become more famous.…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Free tuition, room and board, fees, any other expenses allowed by the NCAA, and benefits or incentives that student-athletes receive to entice them to play. The controversy whether athletes should be paid for their talents and dedication towards their school have increased in popularity over the past few years. Some people believe college athletes should be paid because they spend many hours per week dedicated towards their sport. However, highly recruited athletes already collect free clothes, electronics, and other perks for signing or visiting a school. If the NCAA decided to pay these athletes, the competitiveness of these sports would fluctuate.…

    • 2398 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays