Zimbardo's Prison Experiment Essay

Improved Essays
What happens when good people are put in an evil place? What about when innocent individuals are systematically punished and humiliated? Is human identity rooted in one 's situation? A 1971 endeavor, now known as Zimbardo 's Prison Experiment, attempted to explore these questions and others.

Deep beneath the Psycology Center of Stanford University, a tiny prison was created. Eighteen boys were meticulusly selected from a large group of volenteers. It is important to note that before the experiment commenced, there was no discernable difference between these eighteen boys. They were all mentally stable. By way of random selection, they were split in half and assigned to play the roles of either guards or prisoners.

The experiment was designed
…show more content…
Clearly, the treatment that these boys (particularly the prisoners) were subjected to was inhumane. The fact is, however, that this experiment was meant to emulate real prisons as closely as possible. That means that real people are being subjected to similar inhumanity on a daily basis. Now, these people have committed crimes, some worse than others, but they are still people. This experiment was neccessary to bring to light the barbarity of prison conditions . It showed that this barbarity could have disturbing and inintended consequences. It also revealed much about human identity and nature. This information could not have been obtained any other way, and it can be used to improve and protect the human condition.

How far are we willing to go to pursue the greater good? Everyone knows that this question carries dark implications. As we look ahead, however, it is an important question to consider. The boys who participated in Zimbardo 's Prison Experiment did not suffer any lasting affects. Had the experiment not been discontinued, however, who knows what might have occurred. When conducting psycological experiments, it is important to protect the subjects from lasting harm. If we loose sight of that goal, we loose more of our humanity than research findings could ever provide us

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The experiment brought forth the idea that good people can create harm in negative environments, such as correctional institutions. The experiment tends to assume subcultures will arise, however it is unreasonable to claim extreme subcultures will arise in all cases.…

    • 985 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Institutional Review Boards review proposed experiments to ensure that the welfare of the participants are protected and the APA codes of ethics mandates psychologists to secure informed consent from research participants (Kassin, Fein, & Markus, 2013). In this study, the prisoners and guards were not informed or kept accountable for their responsibilities in the study. Due to the harm, lack of consequences for inhumane behavior, and the eventual long term effects on all the participants, this experiment, and others like it, would never be allowed to be repeated. Conclusion The Stanford Prison Experiment conveyed oppression as well as the abuse of power, but also offered a glimpse of how members of low-status groups develop a shared identity. The participants involved scored greater on examines that measure aggressiveness, authoritarianism, and narcissism, than on those that measure empathy and altruism.…

    • 905 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    They started implying their own rules, Zimbardo had told them as they will be watching the prisoners he will be watching them. Zimbardo being the superintended of the prison, he should have did something when he saw the guards physically hurt the prisoners, but he didn’t he wanted to see how the prisoners would handle the situation. The prisoners stared rebelling, but the guards quickly stepped in and physically hurt them. That was the first step in seeing the guards abuse their powers day by day.” I fell into that role, and in that role, I observed guards brutalizing prisoners – in some cases sadistically… And I did not stop it” (Sparkman 2). Because Zimbardo didn’t stop the guards the first time.…

    • 1297 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I question how such terrible acts could come from human beings, the human beings we American people have so much pride and trust in. People say, those are our enemies, they deserve no mercy, but should they not deserve basic human respect? If you think you can stomach it search it up, and see the horrors that occurred there. According to Claudia Wallis, et al., from Time Magazine, “Zimbardo and other psychologists who have studied torture and sadism by prison guards and soldiers believe that most abuse can be traced to group dynamics and circumstances rather than to individual personalities.” (42). In other words, the terrible acts that people commit mostly come from group environments and not an individual 's behavior.…

    • 2175 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Stanford prison experiment was done by Philip Zimbardo to see how good people respond when they are placed in a bad environment. He made a prison in the basement of the psychology department…

    • 562 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Zimbardo Evaluation

    • 1774 Words
    • 8 Pages

    His study was deemed highly unethical as suffering by the participants was experienced to such a high degree. This could have caused psychological harm to the individuals participating. As a result of such behaviour, governments have now decided to have a detailed look into the ethics of research to ensure no harm is given to participants of any study. Zimbardo claims that today we are now unable to gain new knowledge that could enhance society due to the ethical restrictions. (Maslach, 1996) This provided an impact on the psychological field as ethics boards thus decided that if a participant is involved in a study then no harm should occur to them.…

    • 1774 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Standford Prison Experiment The topic of the study the article is addressing the study of the prisoners and the guards in a simulated prison. The main purpose of this study is give an explanation of the deplorable conditions of the panel system in that there are the dehumanizing effects of the prisoners and at the same time the guards. Additionally, another purpose of the study is to address what contribute to causes of despicable conditions, violence, brutality, degradation and at the same time, dehumanization within any prison across the world. According to the author, the main hypothesis of the study remains to be the dispositional hypothesis. The hypothesis is embraced due to the existence of the status quo of the prison as well as the…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In order to study this effect, the researchers set up a mock prison in the basement of the Stanford University, where 24 participants would later be placed there as either guards or prisoners. The participants were college-age men who initially…

    • 1866 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Zimbardo wanted to find out if the cruelty reported against the guards in American prisons was because of the barbarous personalities of the prison guards or if it was due to the environment of a prison. He wanted to find out how people would heed to the character of a guard and a prisoner in a fake environment that resembled prison life. Prisoner and guards usually possess personalities that doesn’t mix together. Prisoners lacks respect for the law while the guards are browbeat and aggressive. To observe the roles played in prison situations, Zimbardo turned a basement of the Stanford University psychology building into a fake prison.…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Prison served the purpose of removing the deviant sects of society and enforcing surveillance on the group in hopes they would self-regulate. Foucault’s main concern was the possibility that prison mentality would spread to wider society – surveillance and segregation would become the norm. Contrastingly, Durkheim held a move favourable view of the prison system. By punishing deviant acts and utilising the harsh sanction of prison, Durkheim believed that values and an appropriate moral standard would be reinforced on society. Essentially, Durkheim believed that prison helped shape society in dictating between right and wrong.…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays