Analysis Of Why Robots Will-And-Must Take Our Jobs

Superior Essays
The impact of technology on society is a growing topic for discussion. Often, the issue of whether or not technology is controlling humans arises. Academic scholars, journalists, and writers have presented various views on this issue representing both the support and opposition for technology’s control over humans. In his article “Why Robots Will-and-Must Take Our Jobs,” editor and writer Kevin Kelly strongly defends that humans have control over technology by describing how the primary job of humans is to create more jobs for robots. Journalist Clive Thompson agrees with Kelly in his article “Smarter than You Think: How Technology Is Changing Our Minds for the Better” that humans have control over technology, but he also vouches for the idea …show more content…
He discusses the power of robot’s integration and use in society. Kelly describes how over time robots will capture the “old jobs,” or jobs that humans used to have, and humans “new job” will be to create more jobs for robots to complete (Kelly 305). Kelly uses the A/B/C/D quadrant to show the relationship between humans and machines in the process of robot replacement (305). This quadrant compares new and existing jobs and whether these jobs will be the roles of humans or machines. Kelly’s inclusion of this quadrant in his essay shows the relationship as a circle where ultimately, humans will make decisions about which jobs robots and humans will perform. He emphasizes, “Let the robots take the jobs, and let them help us dream up new work that matters” (312). Kelly is claiming that it is the final decision of humans to decide which jobs robots will perform based on the needs of humans and robots as technology progresses. He also asserts that humans have the ability to take jobs away from robots that yield technology some control over humans. This idea supports his claim of why humans ultimately have the choice in which jobs will be performed and by whom. Kelly’s conclusion that it is the job of humans to create jobs for robots supports the claim that humans are controlling …show more content…
He uses the game of chess to support his argument. After analyzing various chess games, including variations of humans competing against and with machines, Thompson concludes that humans playing alongside computers, i.e. receiving suggestions from computers about which move should be played next, is more beneficial than playing solely as an individual or computer. Including a comparison to chess allows Thompson to portray how the relationship bound by chess, computers, and humans is similar to humans and technology, where working together is more beneficial than individually. In order for humans to successful adapt and integrate themselves into with technology, the human brain must have the ability learn and grow. In his essay, Thompson includes the Theory of Cognition that humans are mentally dominant (Thompson 355). He also incorporates a summary of evidence from multiple studies completed by neuroscientists that have used brain scans to try and understand exactly how the brain is wired and “rewired” (355). However, Thompson mentions that because of a lack of present in-depth knowledge regarding the subject in this advancing field, sufficient analysis based on analytical tests are not available. Despite recent studies, Thompson feels that “Almost everything rewires [the brain]” (357). The brain’s ability to grow

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Better Than Human Essay

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As technology continues to advance with every passing minute, it seems as if the idea of robots taking over human jobs, whether it be physical or intellectual, no longer seems too far off from reality. While it currently seems likely that machines are on a path to take over human jobs, many still feel uncomfortable with this becoming their reality. Kevin Kelly in his persuasive essay, “Better than Human: Why Robots Will-and Must-Take Our Jobs, assumes that his audience is anti-machine job takeover, and attempts to persuade his audience through the use of logos. Kelly heavily relies on logos throughout his essay, it becomes his crutch as there is insufficient amount of strong evidence that prove his claim. Kelly states that a “recurring pattern…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Why we need artifial intelligence in robots? The artificial intelligence make the robot have a specific tasks and goal and its job to do it or to solve it as the artificial intelligence works with this goal as a problem and divided it into sub-problems and then put many assumption until the robot solve this problems and save time and effort to the humans. So artificial intelligence helps the robots to act like a people in thinking, learning, talking and moving and also in making tasks and that mean a robots with brains robots with brains can do many things with no risk for human to be harmed in this job, with better accurate and more time as robots don't sleep. artificial intelligence make the robots do something different and unusual in case of changing in any condition and that mean a difference in the routine of doing a job so ordinary machine can't deal with any change while machine with artificial intelligent could deal with this problem and solve it so robots with artificial intelligence is like a human deal with problems with his brain and this is the difference between the automatic artificial intelligent machine and ordinary one which need an person to work on it and take every…

    • 1600 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With the resurgence of artificial intelligence in the media and news, I have gained an interest in the philosophical aspects of it. I would like to write a research paper about whether or not an artificial intelligence is deserved of human rights. This topic has greatly peaked my interest, mostly because I have seen the issue proposed in numerous movies and games that I enjoy. Also, there is no definitive answer, so my goal would to present information, then give my opinion and allow the reader to make their decision. For my research paper, I intend to explore the possible ethical issues involved in the use of artificial intelligences, similarities and differences between AI and the human mind, and who currently deserves human rights.…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Out in the community, we will see robots following the instruction they have been given by their owner. Meanwhile, some are getting a better life, with the new technology, it will affect others in a different way. Many companies will properly replace their human employees with a robot employee, therefore some will dislike robots for taking their job. The dislike and hatred could escalate problems and maybe even violence. That is why I believe that the future will include police drones flying everywhere, to protect us, and keep control of the society.…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although people say technology has worsen the creativity process, but with further research, Dean Rieck mentions how technology didn’t make creativity disappear but a new form of creativity has been developed. As time passed by, creativity has taken a whole new phase. It shows how technology has changed creativity to something everyone has access too. For instance, computers illustrate how writers pour their creativity into this machine. Before typewriters made life so difficult because one essay had to be revised a few times and if one wanted to cross out a line, the whole essay needed to be retyped.…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Swarm Robotics Essay

    • 2996 Words
    • 12 Pages

    Abstract— Swarm robotics is an advanced robotics field which involves co-operative behaviour implemented on robots. Swarm robots find its applications in a large number of fields like process automation, defence, surgery, surveillance etc.In the centralised swarm robotic approach, we have a master robot and one or more slave robots. For a known environment this approach has a very less response time. The master robot is basically in charge of the slaves and controls their actions through sending suitable commands.Using swarm robotics in this project, we are demonstrating the load movement between two predefined positions by pattern formation. Keywords—Swarm Intelligence(SI), Computational Swarm Intelligence (CSI), Centralized Control Mechanism…

    • 2996 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    While some people embrace AI technology for its sophistication and functionality, others are skeptical of it for different reasons. One example of the usefulness of artificial intelligence is that self-sufficient AI robots can be created and used for military purposes (Russell, Hauert and Altman 415-416). Although there is discussion about whether or not lethal autonomous weapons systems (LAWS) are ethical to use in a wartime setting, there is no doubt that they could be helpful. Instead of putting human lives in danger, robots that have perception, motor control, tactical decision-making, and long-term planning can be put into war and function as a soldier (Russell, Hauert and Altman 415). Manuela Veloso, professor of computer science at Carnegie Mellon University states that she wants people to embrace a robot-human world (Russell, Hauert and Altman 418).…

    • 1743 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Role Of Robots

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Although the insertion of robots is imminent, it should be a concern about the ethical issues to which this insertion implies, such as how long a person should be cared for a robot instead a real person or to what extent a task should be outsourced to a machine. While scientists and engineers are studying how to develop new smart machines, sociologists are truly concern about the bonds that can be created between humans and these robots given that humans can create connections between small pieces of technology as a tamagotchi. The ethical issues that surround the relationship among humanoids and human beings were widespread by Isaac Asimov in the book “I, Robot”, but Asimov’s rules are extremely simple-minded to the environment of modern society (3). The world has been change and every single change in technology as regard robotics affects the way that people live. Starting a new era in which robots are as common as pets requires a code of ethics as regards to the relationship between man and machine.…

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    They believe that robots will think the same as human beings, act the same as human beings, and have emotions just like human beings. Having robots do everything a human being would do in their daily lives. However there are a majority of them who believes other wise. There are some scientist who believe designing a robot to do our daily chores can be unethical and robots will only bring bad impacts to humanity because of their imperfections, but the irony about this is that as robotic artificial intelligence technology advances with further support from major industries, these imperfections will not only get fixed, but be removed all together allowing for a more positive future for both robots and humans. Some scientist believe robots who can help people who have problems with socials contact, but this contact with robots will further separate people from human real relationships.…

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    If such a time is ever reached, we will have to reconsider what role artificial intelligence has in our society. If artificial intelligence is able to surpass our own mental capacity, would it then be time to consider using AI to solve matters of social, ethical, or moral matters? At what point do computers become so powerful that we use them beyond their initial purpose of solving calculations, and move on to using them for answers to the world’s moral and philosophical questions? It may be that we never reach that point in artificial intelligence, but the ethics of listening to AI opinions will surely arise if we…

    • 2072 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays