Analysis Of We Don T Do Empire By Bernard Porter

Improved Essays
The Article “We Don’t Do Empire” by Bernard Porter discusses the idea of modern imperialism in America and how it compares to Britain’s imperialistic ways. Bernard Porter uses this article to discuss just how similar and different our foreign policies are to those of the British back in the 1800s. Presidents and people have been indenial of such claims, but Porter’s article makes it known that we may not have a reason to deny these claims after all. Though many of these claims can be supported, it is important to note the differences too, for the sake of the argument. While reading this article, I learned many of the “glaring similarities” discussed. One similarity talked about compared how 19th century Britain compared to 21st century America’s

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    1. Imperialism in the 1890s reflected both continuities and changes from earlier American history, as America continued to expand but do change in the ways the expand, as well continued to have similar reason toward imperialism. To begin with, America continued to believe that i was their destiny to expand into areas and promote democracy and civilization. While previously in history this idea was called Manifest Destiny, the Americans now justified their imperialism with the idea of American Exceptionalism which was the idea that it was America’s destiny to spread democracy and civilization. The difference here is that, while previously America conquered through land, and just moved west on their own land, now the Americans started to increase…

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the years of 1895-1920, America had started to move towards the idea of getting involved with foreign places. With the closing of the frontier, America had started to search for a type of ‘new frontier’ that they could conquer. The factor most important in driving American foreign policy in this time was self-interest. While idealism played a role when America felt the need to help foreign countries, it was ultimately self-interest that led America to take actions in foreign policy. Self- interest is shown when Senator Albert J. Beveridge claims in a speech that America was in need for new markets to get new resources from and to sell to for more trade.…

    • 374 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Murrin’s ‘Roof without Wall’ is significant to understand history, because Murrin provides a different context to view the American Revolution period. Murrin argues that the British North American colonies were diverse on a spectrum north to south, from Canada to Caribbean Islands, but also had common connections and actually Anglicized over the 17th century to 18th century. America was Britain’s creation, which only became American when pushed to act by British tyranny. Once British authority was overthrown and the Articles of Confederation were proven unsuccessful, was America forced to create the constitution; The U.S. Constitution served as a stop gap measure for a shared national identity until one could develop.…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    III. Critical Response to Alice H. Amsden’s Thesis At the heart of Escape from Empire, Amsden explains how shifts in American policy between the First and Second American Empire were a detriment to the development of the Third World. More specifically, Amsden’s thesis is that because of American policy rigidity, the Third World could be better suited for development if it cultivates self-determined policy. It is from this dichotomy between progressively driven policies and ideologically driven policies that Amsden theorizes a third American Empire: an ideal regime that promotes equitable policy regardless of economic, geographic or ideological status.…

    • 1526 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The United States has always considered itself a shining city on a hill, a place that makes the rest of the world better. This is the narrative that many Americans have been sold, that whenever the United States intervenes, it is always for the better of not only that country, but the rest of the world. In spite of this narrative, the United States has not always had the best intentions, and many of their interventions have left lives and countries in ruin. Many of the darker parts of American interventionism come to bear in the book Empire’s Workshop by Greg Grandin, which discusses American imperialism in Latin America. Despite the fact that this book assumes a certain level of expertise on United States policy in Latin America, it is still…

    • 1499 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Did James Monroe Challenge the European Powers? December of 1823, James Monroe delivered his annual message to the United States Congress, the prelude to the State of the Union held in the present day. In this speech he set the policy that still resonates today in dealing with foreign powers, the Monroe Doctrine.…

    • 1149 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the eighteenth century, America was fed up with the British empire and thought they deserved their freedom. Although Thomas Paine and Charles Inglis both had good arguments and logical reason, Paine had a patriotic vision on why America would be better off as an independent nation that Charles Inglis did not see. Paine's argument consists of his views reconciliation, preventing war, and even the downside of independance from Britian. To describe the possible alliance between the British and Americans, Paine uses the word “Reconciliation”.…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay 1 The years after the Civil War to the turn of the 20th Century should be seen as American imperialism, because all expansions during the era were either approved, or instigated by the US government. To start I would like to take a look at how the Hawaii expansion was handled, it was first taken over by nearby US Marines that were station nearby before the government had learned of what happened. The Us Marines were ordered to capture the present ruler, Queen Lili’uokalani, by a US fruit company, The United Fruit Company.…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    William Appleman Williams’ essay The Tragedy of American Diplomacy centers around America expansion, and the idealistic and economic motivators which inspired it. Williams frames his narrative with his critique of the idea that expansion was one of the main ways in which America could extend its virtues throughout the world, and create a new era of peace. He decides the true tragedy of American diplomacy is that actions undertaken in the name of humanitarianism, self determination, and peace actually work in opposition to those ideals and instead turn the United States into an oppressive force abroad. While the United States may have desired to help others, they believed the only way they could do so was if they maintained authority over the nations they helped. The reason this occurred, Williams argues, is because expansionism has a large role in American mythos but both policy makers and citizens refuse to reconcile expansion with the idea of becoming an empire.…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Was American success in achieving independence due more to the strategic skill of George Washington or to the operational and strategic mistakes of the British? The primary reason the British lost the American Revolution was due to operational and strategic mistakes. Through the course of this paper I will show direct evidence of how over confidence in faulty logic, failed strategies, and logistical miscalculations allowed the colonists to protract and win the war.…

    • 1894 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The 1800’s was a time of American expansion from the quaint east of the North American continent, in which the majority of citizens resided. Americans began to migrate to the west, creating the country known today as “The United States of America”. They then looked toward distending into the rest of the Western Hemisphere including the islands of the Caribbean and parts of Pacific Asia. Big businessmen, government officials, American military, and the presidents of this era began to invade and take control of these territories and implemented their power, thus creating the term imperialism. The reasons behind this extension was primarily to rebuild a struggling U.S economy and gain control.…

    • 1214 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Cowboys and Indians: The United States and the Lasting Legacy of its History of Conquest Ned Blackhawk is a Western Shoshone professor of history and American studies at Yale University. His works have focused primarily on post-Columbian Native American history. Within his work, Blackhawk has argued that ‘the history of conquest has an important though largely ignored legacy in the modern United States’. This essay will be an analytical evaluation of the validity and implications of that argument from a historical perspective. This central argument of this essay is that the legacy of the United States’ history of conquest can be seen on a political, sociological and culture level in the modern United States.…

    • 1683 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Imperialism was a proper and legitimate policy for the United States to assume at the turn of the century. The U.S. economy prospered due to the spread of imperialism. The United States had one of the top military forces in the world, making it easy to take control over other countries. Manifest Destiny also contributed to the idea of imperialism in the United States. There were many factors in place in the United States that were improved by imperialism and helped imperialism flourish.…

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The U.S we see today looked very different only a mere 200 years ago, it was much smaller,but by westward expansion it grew. Coined the century of expansion, the 1800s were a defining time in U.S history, new technologies were created, the country grew economically and territorially as well, through treaties and annexations, America grew to the size it is today. America’s hard fought westward expansion, can be attributed to two ideals, the belief of manifest destiny, as our “God-given right to conquer North America, and land hunger by avid settlers, however it cannot be attributed to imperialistic notions to assert our global power as a regional hegemon. Manifest Destiny, the belief that it is our “destiny” from God, as many were stringently religious at the time, as Americans to expand across the…

    • 952 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The writer’s intentions in this piece can be perceived as strong and well said through his level of certainty in the knowledge he had of how badly the American people had fallen. The suffered a moral and ethical fall due to them becoming the aggressor, after they had suffered and knew so much pain from their experience being under the rule of Great Britain. As a result of what happened to them they created a system of values that afforded rights to those who needed them and by taking control of other countries in a way that paralleled what they had gone through, it appeared as though they had forgotten what the constitution truly stood for. This behavior goes to show how little things have changed as people have and continue to be human and make the exact same mistakes they have always…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays