Analysis Of Tough Guise 2 And Miss Representation

Improved Essays
There is hope for a better reality of Americans when the few come together as a group, exposing themselves and others, and the documentaries Tough Guise 2 and Miss Representation speak to men and women and how they can change their bad gender image sold to them by the media. Tough Guise 2 observes men bred by the media to be leaders in America’s violent crimes. Miss Representation observes the role the entertainment industry plays in defining gender roles, but takes a closer look at what women can do to fight gender inequality in political spectrums where their positive example is lacking in areas where males predominate, and therefore attempts to do something about gender representation. Without diverse input from men outside the realm of the most famous, both documentaries miss an opportunity to reach an audience of men that could use their power to stand up against the plight of gender misrepresentation in the media.

Consequently, as part of the media monster itself, the filmmakers of both documentaries have a part in selling how Americans think of themselves to them, and they speak to roughly 50% of the problem. The filmmakers of Miss Representation expose the viewers to themselves, but without shaming them to buy into a fake reality. It does have its problems. This documentary provides this message to the females: successful women are depicted as bitches or even pitted against one another in feuds seemingly unrelated to their actual aims. Indeed, the media is a good example for bad representation of gender as some notable news articles in Tough Guise 2 highlight. The film’s narrator, Jackson Katz, cites some newspaper reporting of violent crimes committed by men where the focus of the perpetrators mental state overlooked the more significant factor of their sex. This mention of gender misrepresentation in the news, though a rising concern with interest for men, doesn’t speak for all men reading negative headlines regarding their own sex. Convicted male shooters could best find use in these headlines, perhaps, if needing good example for using the insanity defense as a useful defense against death worthy judgments. To some broad extent this still benefits men. Depicting women as bitchy and power-driven in news articles within the political spectrum of the news, however, not only overlooks a person’s genuine effort to succeed in helping the world, its whitewashes the attempts made and doesn’t give women reading of themselves anything to run with by example to accomplish much of anything. Females are depicted as victims, failing to provide its predominantly male audience about an actual solution to the problem of male gender depiction. Likewise, Tough Guise 2 somehow manages to worsen this media messenger by focusing on one man’s many cited examples of men who appear for reference in their already exemplified Hollywood form.
…show more content…
The author of this documentary fails to provide his select audience with a diverse and gender neutral solution, and though ambitious it is in aim with regard to changing male patterns of behavior, it is overall reductive. Gay and straight men without children to influence or schools to shoot up might have trouble relating to this film and could apply real behavioral change in their life by taking the many observations of several different women for example to follow, who unfortunately are solely female. Indeed, where are the men? Miss Representation addresses startling statistics that hinder the growth of men and women of all creeds, and by doing so serves a broader audience albeit predominately female. The narrative is ingenious, and its technique deserves mention for progressively providing a much needed way to interpret bad or misinformed individuals; it encompasses it message within several different life mantras shared that originated from adversity without redundantly stupefying its genderless audience. The media operates by how well its audience follows its example and everyone goes about their own lives with subtle but significant regard to media messages. Miss Representation lets it run freely across the screen without disturbing its audience with what to think about it and by allowing this to occur lets them read and listen to take women into consideration by how it affects them. Moreover, Miss Representation provides hope to every viewer that women in film are making effective strides at changing the use of statistics in a way

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Marilyn Frye Case Study

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The underrepresentation of women in the media shows the limitation of freedom they are allowed to get, it targets the entire population of females, and there is no direct cause of this oppression. In this case, men are the ones who receive a group-based benefit because it makes them feel “good” or superior. According to Alison Bailey, “privileges are unearned advantages that are conferred systematically due to one’s being identified as a member of a particular social group” (Privilege, Slide #9). Since men have always been viewed as a dominant figure, they are the ones who benefit from the oppression of women in the media. The negative of a microscopic perspective when it comes to oppression and privilege is that a microscopic view tries to directly find the individual causing the harm whereas oppression and privilege are systematic; there is no single direct cause.…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Vision Strong “Miss Representation” is a documentary film by Jennifer Siebel Newsom, who illustrates the way media portrays women and the issues that come along with this portrayal in the face of young girls while trying to expose it. In order for Newsom to get her point across she had to build a strong claim. The documentary sheds light on the portrayal of women and helps build a stronger claim on how this portrayal is wrong by sharing her story, using the stories of young girls who have had issues because of this portrayal, using visuals, and facts from successful women. In the opening of the documentary Newsom begins by saying how she found out she was pregnant with a girl and how the pregnancy made her see clearly.…

    • 957 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the 2011 Miss Representation documentary, directed by Jennifer Siebel Newsom, it discusses the limited, but also degrading portrayals of women that mainstream media and culture produce. Newsom graduated from Stanford University with a Master’s degree in Business Administration and is a CEO, actress, filmmaker, and advocate. As a woman and an actress, she presents her belief that media is a huge contributor in making women feel powerless by providing several examples to deliver her message. Newsom effectively convinces the audience of Miss Representation that media under-represents women through the use of emotional appeals, appealing to credibility, and by including a counterargument but then refuting it.…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Misrepresentation is defined as “the action or offense of giving a false or misleading account of the nature of something”. The documentary, Miss Representation, by Jennifer Siebel Newsom addresses this as definition as it applies to the media and politics for women. The documentary tackles the topic of the media’s representation of women and the consequent socialization into traditional gender roles. Not only are traditional gender messages that are perpetuated by the media pervasive, powerful, and pernicious, but also, women’s delayed progress in politics can be traced back to the media’s representation of women.…

    • 1257 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The second documentary, the Mask You Live In focuses on societal constructs of femininity and masculinity and how these constructs impact men and women in society. It discusses the experiences and issues of mainly men, focusing on the influence society has on men by enforcing certain expectations of what a man should be like. Joe Herman, Michael Kimmel and several others discuss their experiences with societal pressures to behave masculine. Some of the main issues discussed in this documentary are toxic masculinity, violence in young men and boys, the influence of media on masculinity, and the influence male mentors have on boys and men.…

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The inequality that has always existed within the workplace began to be addressed, and women’s liberation throughout all races began to take hold. The largest feats of feminism were displayed in the media and society as women were allowed to compete in sports and other male dominated activities and professions. Then, in the 80’s and 90’s, these liberal ideas were heavily rejected and seen as a negative agenda against the American Dream. Then, by the 1990s, many television conglomerations began to control what was displayed in the media, and focused on conservative perspectives and what extreme displays would garner the most attention, most of which displayed women in sexual, sexist, and derogatory perspectives. Traditional gender messages are heavily enforced, emphasising that men should be the strong breadwinners who need to prove their manliness, while women must remain non- threatening, delicate, and an object of desire.…

    • 1258 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The world as we know it, is being influenced by pop culture and the media, and it is doing more harm than good. In the essay “Still Missing: Women in the Media”, by Megan Tady, she discusses the gender issues and inequality in the media news world. Tady talks about the way men have a greater voice and opinion in the media, and decide “how to represent and portray our population in the media” (Tady, 577).…

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Miss Representation Essay

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Miss Representation, a documentary created by Jennifer Siebel Newsom, explores the under-representation of women in America, and it objects to the media's skewed image of women in leadership roles in social media. It does not break new ground on these issues, but it gives viewers an array of perspectives to think about. The film scrutinizes many of the issues related to the portrayal of women in American society that includes leadership roles and the affect on youth. The film expresses this mistreatment through vivid media footage, quotes, statistics, interviews with a diverse group of people and Newsom’s personal experience growing up as a woman in America.…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A multitude of photos, videos, and graphics were shown that placed women in positions that were mostly sexual, and all inappropriate, showing that media does not take women seriously. Then the topics moves on to women in politics and how that is negatively affected by media. The film then moves on to the topic of women in movies and television, and how the majority of movies made either revolve around men, or are for the pleasure of men. There is incredible denial in the media industry regarding the status of women. B) PRESENTATION MEDIA– Miss Representation was a documentary that was filmed in color.…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The U.S. has a percentage of around 50.8% women and 49.2% men. According to Miss Representation, “only 16% of protagonists in films are female”. With a nearly equal population of women to men, why is this? A close inspection of the media pinpoints why. We don’t know where the trend started, but somewhere down the line the media constructed an obtuse idea that a woman’s body is more important than her intelligence.…

    • 281 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After viewing the documentary of “Miss Representation” I found that the message this documentary was sending its viewers was that the media sells the idea that women are visualized and praised for their beauty, sexuality and youth rather than their intellectualism and leadership skills. “Miss Representation” exposes the ugly truth behind the media and politics towards women. I found this documentary to be persuasive and successful in bringing awareness to both men and women, of what the “normal “everyday women goes through and the pressure they attain because of the media by the following supported claims. This documentary highlights the importance of what is advertised through the media and how it affects us, the many different statistics…

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Women have it harder than men… Women aren’t treated equal… Society is dominated by men”. Has society even thought that maybe men don’t have it as easy as society thinks? Society has focused too much on women's rights movement that they forgot about men. Media has affected gender roles throughout generations.…

    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stereotyping Analysis

    • 313 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In this today world, Stereotypes plays an important role. Stereotyping is defined as a fixed conventional notion or conception of an individual or group of people. It may be basic or complex which people may apply to individuals or groups on the basis of their appearance, belief, behaviour. Stereotypes are found everywhere. It has been observed that our world seems to be improving in various ways that it is impossible to liberate it from stereotypes.…

    • 313 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mean Girls Movie Analysis

    • 509 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In this media presentation, my group decided to watch two different movies that can be categorized for each gender. The first movie was “Mean Girls”, this movie is directed to an audience of young women and represents the typical stereotype women that media have portrayed for a long time. The second movie we watched was “Live Free or Die Hard”, this movie represents all the typical characteristics of the man, that is aggressive, protect the girl, and save the world, all at the same time. In these two movies I learned how similar media and society embrace differences between women and men. “Mean Girls” is a movie meant for a women audience.…

    • 509 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Women equality in the media has increased over time, but it is still not equal to the men's. Women are seen as “Just women” and the media is inferring that women are not capable of the same things that men are. Women are put in a box that labels them in negative ways. In my research paper I will be explaining the inequality for women in the news, sports journalism and also entertainment. News journalism is a demanding field for both women and men, so why is it when you turn on your daily news you're less likely to see a women representation?…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays

Related Topics