Thomas More And A Modest Proposal Analysis

Superior Essays
Thomas More’s Utopia and Jonathan Swift’s A Modest Proposal both captured my attention this semester with how they both were very political in addressing real life problems of their respective time periods. Thomas More was a writer of the 16th century while Jonathan Swift was a writer of the 18th century. The writing styles of both authors also plays an enormous part in how their points came across in each writing. More’s Utopia was writing in a humorous sort of style and Swift’s A Modest Proposal was written to be satirical. This essay will be about the comparison of how both authors address current issues in their lives during each time period and also how they both used very different techniques to get their points across about the problems. …show more content…
In Utopia, issues of poverty and scarcity, capitalism, and the issue of the rich buying up everything like it was a game of monopoly seemed to be present. In A Modest Proposal, poverty and scarcity was also a major issue because at the time Ireland was very poor and being over thrown by England which had little or no poverty issues. Both authors set forth social and political ideas with their writings to suggest, address, or amend the problems and issues going on. Utopia was written as a sort of “alternative “ to a better life because in this place that this traveler has come from, these problems of poverty, scarcity, and capitalism doesn 't not exist. A Modest Proposal was written to exaggerate solutions to Ireland’s ongoing problems of poverty and scarcity. At the time, many people had do able solutions that could possibly help Ireland in some ways but they were all derailed so Swift decided that since no one would listen to the practical proposals maybe he should suggest unpractical ones to grab their attention. The proposal shows how bad and backwards the social class and general state Ireland was in. Both More and Swift suggests in their writings that the wealthy people do things to get wealthier while exploiting the poor and not even trying to help at all. Utopia: “ To make this hideous poverty worse, it exists side by side with wanton luxury”(More 1.20 ). A Modest Proposal: “ That the remaining hundred thousand may at a year old be offered in sale to the persons of quality and fortune through the kingdom”(Swift 232). More and Swift both use sources to make it seem as if what they are trying to convey is credible. More uses Raphael to tell the story of Utopia because he is a traveler, "sailed not as a seaman, but as a traveler, or rather a philosopher”(More 1.14). Swift includes a statement from the proposers old acquaintance, “ I have

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    He wanted to give a picture of the civilization he believed would help the world and its current problems. He wants to create a society that humans would be proud of. Such examples of the perfect society that More created are found often throughout his book. More describes the Utopians, “All things are so regulated that men very seldom build upon a new piece of ground” (More 37). More describes men like this because the life they live is a very simple life and if their house needs repair they do not build another right next to it that make the most out of what they have and fix it.…

    • 2088 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thomas More is known for his 1516 book Utopia and for his untimely death in 1535, after refusing to acknowledge King Henry VIII as head of the Church of England. He was canonized by the Catholic Church as a saint in 1935. In 1520, reformer Martin three works setting out his doctrine of salvation, which, according to Luther, could be attained through grace alone; the series rejected certain Catholic practices and attacked others. In 1521, King Henry VIII responded to Luther with the assistance of More, in his Defence of the Seven Sacraments. By this time, More had become treasurer of England's exchequer, but he also served as "Henry's intellectual courtier," secretary and confidant, and, in 1523, he was elected speaker of the House of Commons.…

    • 654 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I agree with Thomas More’s decision. Thomas More was doing what he believed was right, and stood up to those who thought otherwise. Thomas More was asked to take the oath which means he is agreeing that the marriage was annulled by the king. Thomas More didn’t agree with this because he didn’t think that Parliament had the jurisdiction over the church.…

    • 379 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thomas More's Growth

    • 132 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Thomas fell in love with his wife and they together raised a family, here he taught his children at a very early age, and his career began to flourish. Thomas More married Jane Colt, together they had three sons and one daughter. After Jane’s death he married Alice Middleton. More than created a model of an educational community for his children as well as his servants. To help his daughters learn Latin he would speak to them in Latin and only Latin.…

    • 132 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Swift's A Modest Proposal

    • 621 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Swift Analysis In Swift’s “A Modest Proposal” the author exemplifies and focuses on the problem during this time period of the Irish dealing with overpopulation, famine, and extensive poverty. While also attacking Britain on its lack of empathy towards the situation, as well as the unwillingness to create a plausible solution to fix these problems. Swift achieves his position to condemn the British government for not helping the Irish , through the creation of a outlandish, monstrous solution by use of satire and structuring the writing in such a way that the reader is caught off guard by Swift’s proposal and then pushed toward negative views of England for not substituting any better solutions.…

    • 621 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Utopia it emphasized a lot on no private property and good being in places where people can ask for what they need. This is relatable to communism due to the fact that there is no private property but since Utopia has elections for their leaders the government style is not completely relatable to communism. The people of Utopia believed that having equal shares of riches would prevent people from getting greedy. Utopia was written a long time ago, yet the ideas, practices and beliefs mentioned in the book could be found in today’s society. This leads readers to ask the question of how much has society advanced in terms of law, politics and…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The paper will delve into the work of Jonathan Swift and will explore at length a major theme found in that work. In addition to explaining the major theme of the work, I will also explain how the theme impacts the work and relates to enlightenment thinking. Jonathan Swift published the essay in the year 1729. This was in the middle of the enlightenment period. During the enlightenment period, literature saw the rise of the novel as a genre and dry wit, sarcasm and satire became popular forms of political, social and religious criticism.…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Thomas More was born in London in 1477 or 1488. Both his parents came from an upwardly mobile merchant 's class. His father, John, became a judge and chose the legal profession for his son. Very little is known of Thomas 's mother, Agnes, who died sometime before 1507. More began his education at St Anthony 's, a leading London school.…

    • 1062 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    LaChone Taylor Dr. Sircy Eng 358 November 21, 2014 Word Count: In This Together Thomas More’sUtopia is a More’s initial description of Utopia is that of a man-made island, enclosed by a large harbor. The harbor is used for import and travel, but makes external contact with the island virtually impossible. This description of Utopia is intended to categorically separate the island from any actual countries.…

    • 1575 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thomas More’s Utopia depicts that in a perfect society all personal information will be publicly available. The narrator claims that private property does not exist and that “every man may freely enter into any house whatsoever” (More 5). Typically, a house is a place where people can carry out their personal activities and before others can enter, they have to ask for permission. However, in Utopia, any person even a stranger can easily barge into someone else’s house when they feel like it, invading their privacy. Since the members of this society do not mind such actions, it makes it difficult for personal privacy to exist especially in homes.…

    • 210 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Satire: A Sarcastic Response to Human Follies Satire is a scathing and trenchant literary tool, one used by writers to point out the faults of human vice in order for change and amelioration. Satiric works were popular during the second phase of the Age of Reason because of new scientific discoveries that challenged the traditional commanding force of religion. Popular Eighteenth Century writers aimed to “mend the world as far as they are able,” (III. 467) with the help of satire. Satirists used two criteria to measure the effectiveness of their work: the use of exaggeration in identifying flaws in human nature and humor in engaging the audience's interest. Influential figures, Jonathan Swift, and Alexander…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thomas More Utopia Essay

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Utopia is a reflection of this context, providing a critique of political, social and religious problems he saw in his society through a radical presentation of a completely new society. These problems…

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Utopia The ideal society present by Thomas More is a Utopian society that responds to the current to the current issues of 15th century life. More demonstrates this ideal society by defining it into four categories: universal work, elimination of possessions, controlled pleasures, and families as a representation of a larger society. His main argument follows the ideals of elimination of private property.…

    • 223 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    More’s Utopia Book I: Private Property Issues and Resolutions In the well written Utopian book called Utopia by Thomas More, book one of two focuses on the intricate conversation between the narrator, Thomas More, his good friend Peter Giles, as well as the extremely knowledgeable Raphael Hythloday. The three have a heated conversation about Hythloday’s long journey to the Utopians. Within this conversation, may issues and attempted resolutions are brought up.…

    • 910 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Explore the struggle between the individual and society in 'Gulliver 's Travels ' and 'Pastoralia ' 'Principally, ' wrote Jonathan Swift in a 1725 letter, 'I hate and detest that animal called man... upon this great foundation of misanthropy the whole building of my Travels is erected '. Such cynicism is hardly surprising from a writer such as Swift, whose whole corpus is marked by its acerbic and critical tone. As Gravil put it, Swift 's genius was a 'radical scepticism ', one that often-times put him at odds with his fellows, who were utterly entrenched in the intellectual optimism of the Enlightenment. What perhaps may be more unexpectedly gleaned from Swift 's correspondence is his focus on how the 'Travels ' relate to the human condition as a whole,…

    • 1090 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays