Forgiving Him From The Death Camp Analysis

Improved Essays
How does one go about forgiving someone that actively participated in attempting to wipe our entire race of people; annihilating their culture, their religion? This is the exact predicament Simon Wiesenthal faces when a dying Nazi soldier calls a Jew, any Jew to his bedside confesses all his transgressions and sins to him while on his death bed. Smail Balic knows how Simon feels and can understand what he did because he would have done the same. He believes that if Simon would of forgave him and he is not in the right place to do so. If he would of forgave him for what the Nazi soldier did, he would have only forgiven him on Simons behalf not for everyone.

Simon was stuck in a really awkward situation because a random nurse went up to
…show more content…
“In order to understand a person who has carried the burden of so much injustice and suffering, we have to imagine ourselves in his position” (110). Just imagine being in Germany during the Holocaust and becoming an SS soldier, and having to do whatever the higher officers say to do. While you’re at your death bed you just keep imagining all the horrible and bad things you did, and the only think that can ease what you are going through is by trying to apologize to a Jew. When he is apologizing for all those things he did, Simon is sitting there thinking about what to say, then when he’s done Simon just walks out of the hospital …show more content…
“Only God in his infinite mercy can cleanse the sins of the perpetrators of these crimes” (111). The only person that can forgive this Nazi of what he has done is God. What he has done is way over what any person can say about the situation and about forgiving what he has done. “Those who might appear uninvolved in the actual crimes, but who tolerate acts of torture, humiliation, and murder, are certainly also guilty.” (111). No matter what situation you are in, if you witness the crimes and you watch the torturing going on then you too are guilty and should pay the price for not talking back to what’s

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    So as we were sitting with the police officer, that was when we were told we would have to go on the retreat. I tried so hard to get Simon out of trouble, but the officer wouldn’t let him go so he got in just as much trouble as I did. I felt so bad for him, especially because it was all my fault that we got in trouble in the first…

    • 813 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The possibility of forgiveness depends on the people involved and the situation. Some people believe in the common saying “forgive and forget” and live up to it, but others never forgive people for their wrong-doings and definitely don’t forget. In the book Sunflower, the main character, Simon, was not able to forgive the SS officer for his participation in the torturing of the Jews during the Holocaust. This is understandable considering that the Simon was an imprisoned Jew himself. It would have been possible to forgive the dying man, but it was unlikely for the Jew to do so, and he didn’t.…

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Auschwitz Dbq Essay

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Not only was Auschwitz a death camp it is where a majority of the incoming Jews, families, homosexuals, and numerous other groups of people lived. When they arrive their belongings were taken and later shipped back to Germany and their hair was cut off completely bald (Source D). The living conditions of Auschwitz did not at all accommodate to the number of people stored in each room being that 3 people would have to sleep with each other per bunk in the barracks (Source D).There were no urinals just simply a bucket which very frequently overflowed by the morning which did cause a stench (Source D).There also wasn’t any windows in the Barracks which had its pros and cons as well (Source G).Around August 1944 there were 105,168 prisoners were…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Questioning Retribution Wiesel’s account of the Holocaust represents the truly barbaric actions that war-driven nations will enact. The gruesome stories that detail the concentration camps are a haunting demonstration of the evil that exists beyond the imagination of the public. Upon the conclusion of the novel, in conjunction with his preface, the question of future development and change lingers. But is there any retribution for the soldiers who carried out such unspeakable acts?…

    • 382 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some Jews had the reality that the harshest they were going through was God's doing. This means that while their fellow jews were getting tortured and killed they still have faith that God will come and save the day.” God is testing us he wants us to see whether we are capable of overcoming our base instincts. “(Wiesel 45).This quote displays how they felt the bad things Hitler and the Nazis we're doing to them was God…

    • 491 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    A third example of how compassion affects survival is the fact that the Nazis showed no compassion to anyone in the camp. It was because of the Nazis lack of compassion that Jews were being put into death camps and being taken away from their families. Which ultimately led to millions of Jews being killed. In contrast to compassion, there were many examples of the Nazis being cold-hearted. One disturbing example is on page 32 when Elie says “Babies!…

    • 190 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After, Hans is the only one of his squad to survive World War 1. He has some survivors guilt. This guilt makes him do unbelievably nice things for people. “The next morning dawned, there…

    • 374 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This inevitable guilt shows that there is some unspoken moral truth that was realized in order to feel the said guilt. If the Nazis had believed in an overarching set of moral truths, they wouldn’t have thought that their actions were morally right. For more than 40 years after World War II ended, Germany was devastated, occupied, and torn apart. Their society crumbled because the Nazis didn’t recognize or follow the absolute moral truths. Moral relativists wouldn’t be able to tell the Nazis that what they were doing was wrong because they would be entitled to their own opinions or beliefs about morality even though their actions led to the crumbling of an entire country and…

    • 415 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If someone were to bump into you in the hallway, you might be upset, but you come to a point where you forgive them for the incident. You will probably, at the end of the day, forget that someone even bumped into you because it wasn’t important enough to remember. But would you remember if the offense was the murder and torture innocent people? Simon Wiesenthal asks in The Sunflower, “Moreover, when the killing has stopped, how can a people make peace with one another who moments before were their mortal enemies? What are the limits of forgiveness, and is repentance-religious or secular-enough?…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    ALL human rights were violated,the right to not be subjected to arbitrary arrest, detention or exile, the right to not be held in slavery or servitude , the right not to be subjected to torture or inhuman and degrading treatment. Jews were being moved around Europe without their consent. These are the main human rights that were violated by the Nazis. Human Rights of the Holocaust victims were violated because the Nazis tortured them, they held them in slavery and servitude, also they were held in detention. One of the rights the Nazis violated was the right to not “...be subjected to torture or inhuman and degrading treatment (United Nations5)”.…

    • 413 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Trolley Dilemma

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages

    There have been genocides against Christians in history, but despite that the Holocaust was and still is a Jewish struggle and honestly forgiveness to an oppressor shouldn’t be given by someone like me who is not Jewish. Imagining what it would be like to live through a genocide, I don’t think I could run away from the soldier as Wiesenthal in The Sunflower without at least a yes or no answer. I still stand with my decision to give the dying man forgiveness. This is best described in Primo Levi’s response. “You felt that you represented the entire jewish people… you would perhaps today be experiencing a deeper remorse than you feel at not having absolved him” (Levi 192).…

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Application of New Criticism: forgiving my father A short synopsis of the poem “forgiving my father”, written by Lucille Clifton is that it is about a daughters recollection of her life growing up, specifically her father’s inefficiencies. Throughout the poem, the persona shifts through boots of anger, bitterness and contempt as she reflects on the experiences she had growing up. To fully grasp what the poem is about in its totality, one could ascribe to many different types of criticism however; this paper seeks to reveal the meaning of the poem using the tenets of new criticism. New Criticism posits that in order to understand a work, one must focus solely on the work looking at, for example, its figures of speech among other elements…

    • 1775 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    William Golding’s Lord of the Flies writes about the ideas of people’s personalities and the evil within the human heart. Set within an island, a group of young boys set out to survive and be rescued; however, it is later seen how the boys end up being wild and savage when they’re left without adult supervision. Golding depicts Simon as a scapegoat whose exceptional persona on an island of chaos and anarchy makes him a target for the stranded boys’ hatred/evil. Starting early on in the novel, Simon shows a caring, generous personality, which becomes a stigma that he is “unique” in comparison to the other boys. Even though the norm for the biguns on the beach was to ignore or not help the littluns; Simon was different in that, “Simon found…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    "The Prisoners of War,” a relatively short poem by Tom Disch, written in 1972, is riddled with imagery and deeper meaning. Even in the opening line, Disch cuts to the point. “Their language disappeared a year or so after the landscape: so what can they do now but point?” (line 1-3).…

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the many themes of this book is courage. It took Hans a lot of courage to go and help this Jewish man even though he knew he would suffer many consequences not only from the Nazi soldiers but also from his own townsmen. Hans gives the man a piece of bread disregarding the consequences he was going to suffer because of what he was doing. No one else in the entire town went to help that Jewish man because none of them had the courage to do so. Only Hans out of so many was willing to take the risk and help another human being survive for a little longer.…

    • 580 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays