Analysis Of The Ecstatic Edge Of Politics By Donald Trump

Great Essays
Understanding the Trump Supporter
In January 2016, Donald J. Trump said, "I could stand in the middle of 5th Avenue and shoot somebody and I wouldn't lose voters." He was probably right. Everyone was in complete surprise when a man who degrades women, mocks disabled reporters, and calls Mexicans rapists won the November election. Many are still wondering, why Trump? Everyone would like to think that there is not that much evil in the world. Maybe we are missing something.
Former professor of sociology at the University of California Berkeley and author, Arlie Russell Hochschild, in her essay “The Ecstatic Edge of Politics: Sociology and Donald Trump,” analyzes several different perspectives regarding the mentality of the Trump supporter.
…show more content…
For taken as a whole, this entire network is nothing less than a privatized political party whose budget now dwarfs that of the republican party.
A common idea might be that right-wing donors may have contributed to Donald Trump’s win. Hochschild goes on to explain that one of the Koch brothers made a statement saying that he might vote for Hillary Clinton. This does not serve as enough proof to refute this take on the support for Trump. However, it does make room for other possible interpretations. Hochschild then moves on to the gain of Trump support through values, religion and morality. According to Jonathan Haidt, conservatives sometimes do not vote based on economic interests but rather vote based on “moral interests”. However, Hochschild refutes this by stating that polls have shown that most of the white Protestant Republicans support Donald Trump. She says, “Trump won far more votes than the deeply religious Ted Cruz, an evangelical pastor’s son.”
Continuing with the same strategy, Hochschild moves on to George Lakoff's idea that politics is seen as a metaphor of the family type one grows up in, and maybe Trump supporters fall into this sub-conscious ideology. She
…show more content…
She says, “Donald Trump fits the classic description of a charismatic leader, as Weber defined it.” Trump’s followers will forgive many of his flaws simply because he recognizes their deep story. How did Trump gain this status as the messenger of the deep story? In Hochschild's words, “Trump has intuitively fitted himself into a secular version of the Rapture.” The Rapture refers the belief the world will come to an end at any time and believers will go to heaven with God leaving everyone else on the earth to face chaos and living hell. This idea of “saved and damned, with no one left in between...eerily echoes the growing split between America’s rich and poor…” Hochschild states that Donald Trump made himself the “supreme judge who determines who goes to heaven and hell.” This is something many charismatic leaders do. As Weber stated, “the charismatic leader gains and maintains authority solely by proving strength in life.” In a sense, Trump is offering his followers a heaven if they trust him as their

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Thank you for your comments on my analysis. Here are my thoughts. Using an ethos appeal, Ken Herman uses his status as a prevalent journalist for a major daily newspaper in Austin, the capital city of Texas to garner credibility for his “opinion” of the December 2016, Austin City Council election and to perpetuate the “Austin American-Statesman’s” preferred political ideologies in society. After reading Herman’s article, it is obvious the “American-Statesman’s” political ideology leans left. Although Herman makes these liberal views known throughout his article, he carefully constructs his opinion article with the selling of the newspaper in mind.…

    • 222 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Every person possesses opinions or beliefs which shape and mold his or her political ideology. In today’s American society, political ideologies have split into a rift unlike any other in 21st Century America. While most Americans still identify as politically moderate, the divide between the far left and center and the far right and center continue to expand. The groups at each end of the spectrum have developed into radical factions, much to the dismay of the Americans in the middle of the spectrum. In the past few decades alone, a group based on the ideas of white nationalism has emerged on the far right side of the political spectrum: the alt-right.…

    • 895 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thus, it is my obligation to carefully assess their political agenda and personal statements prior to election time, welder, L., & guitarist, b. (2011). It is important to remember a worldview is comprehensive. Therefore, it touches on every area of my liveliness. Ultimately, I must remain faithful to practice and develop my Biblical worldview in order to mature in my relationship with…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article, Absorbing the Impossible, Maureen Dowd, a feminist and a slight liberal lean, suggests that Donald Trump won the President-elect because of the hidden Trump supporters and the misunderstood lack of Clinton supporters throughout the nation. Dowd develops her ideas further by addressing how Trump won for a combination of reasons including but not limited to: the annoyance of current Democratic government (“too much regulation, too much government”) strong dislike of opposing candidate (“one of the most flawed candidates in history”), and the possibility of another ‘Clinton’ in the White House (“unable to condone the Clintons’ miasma of financial and ethical cheesiness”). Using these examples, Dowd illuminates how Trump was able…

    • 342 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Précis of “A Quieted Donald Trump Quickly Turns On ‘Lyin’ Ted’” In the article “A Quieted Donald Trump Quickly Turns On ‘Lyin’ Ted’” author Maggie Haberman skillfully combines visuals with direct objectives and an unbiased selective view. First Haberman paints a visual of the seemingly quiet Super Tuesday with a summary of the previous political drama starters. By doing so, a reader can recall the past scenarios and form a mental basis of comparison before continuing with the article. After a few sentences Haberman allows direct quotes to further tell the story.…

    • 333 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout the entirety of this book we are following Hochchild as she tries to understand the point of view of the conservative mindset. The book was narrated in way that focused on the perspective of the Tea Party. Hochschild intended on using the Tea Party as the control variable of the far right. She went on to tie a knot between the Tea Party and the past upcoming of presidency of Donald Trump. To understand the conservative mindset, she utilized focus groups for research and often relied on her sociological research methods to divulge new information.…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Florida megachurch pastor Paula White has earned criticism after she said U.S. President Donald Trump is “authentically raised up by God” and even compared his election to the biblical story of Queen Esther. In an appearance on the PTL Network’s “The Jim Bakker Show” broadcast on Aug. 22, Pastor White likened Trump’s rise to the presidency to Queen Esther’s coronation as a respected queen even though she was an unlikely candidate for the position. She spoke in the wake of the president’s speech about the plan to increase U.S. military presence in Afghanistan, Religion News Service relays. “They say about our president, 'Well, he is not presidential.'…

    • 370 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This idea of the separation of religion from presidential leadership became a big debate in the 2008 Presidential elections when Mitt Romney joined the race. Some citizens believed that this bold Mormon would overly implement his religious beliefs and flip the nation upside down. This arousal of fear in people’s hearts caused Romney to act. In Mitt Romney’s “Faith in America,” he courageously utilizes unifying diction, voice merging, and familial metaphors in order to connect with his audience. He employs these devices to dispel his audience’s fear and re-emphasize his stance that while he will not pander or throw away his religion, Romney will always put the Constitution of the United States of America first.…

    • 1473 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As he worked through the ranks of government by being elected governor up to being elected president, Bush’s use of religious rhetoric increased over the years and became a staple of his speeches to the American public. In the speech addressing the attack on 9/11, the first mention of religion came when Bush praised Republicans and Democrats for coming together to sing “God Bless America.” While members from both political parties came together to volunteer within their communities and offer words of encouragement, Bush specifically pointed out the unity between two opposing groups singing a song that asks for God to watch over the US. When responding to the question of what Americans should do in response to this attack, Bush asks Americans to uphold American values and continue going on with their days without showing fear “in the face of a continuing threat.” But the last request he made was to “please continue praying for the victims of terror and their families” because “prayer has comforted us in sorrow.”…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The recent election of Donald Trump as president of the United States has evoked strong reactions from people worldwide, leaving Americans and non-Americans alike baffled as to how the former businessman and reality TV star – who has become known for being prejudiced against several demographics, as well as his plan to build a wall between the US and Mexico, among other things – managed to become the leader of one of the most powerful countries in the world. David Wong’s article, How Half of America Lost Its F**king Mind, provides an interesting perspective on why so many Americans might have voted for Trump. He writes that rural areas in the United States are for the most part ignored by both the media and the government while the focus remains…

    • 2039 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this day and age, our nation has a “red versus blue” mentality despite the public’s opinions and attitudes displaying the many shades and tints in between. Traditionally, Americans have strictly defined their stance on a given issue or policy by which particular political party he or she identifies with. Today, Americans are more apt to define themselves as exclusive groups who share similar detailed views each a stemming from the ultimate Democratic and Republican parties. The new and improved typology has a range of groups that represent the diverse middle in between two polarized wings. After taking the typology quiz to see where I personally stand on this spectrum, I was unsurprised to find I identify with the group known as “Next Generation Left.”…

    • 272 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    With the 1976 election of Jimmy Carter the nation saw the election of a professed “born-again” Christian but did not realize it would serve as a catalyst for the social conservative religious right movement and ultimately force Carter to be a one-term president. Carter born into a southern Baptist denomination embraces a “secular quest for justice” during his presidency. Freedman describes Carter as a unique, “combination of modernity with conservatism” which ultimately allows him to, “win over both religious and secular voters” in…

    • 1460 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Senator Cruz’s faith separates him from most other Republican and Democratic competitors. As a result, Cruz created a prayer team amongst him and his followers. He said, “Our nation is in desperate need of God’s favor: these are dangerous days for America, but these are also days of great hope” ( National Prayer Team).As surprising as it may sound, this form of self promotion may be one of the most important aspects of his whole campaign. It reaches out to the greatest practiced religion in the United States and makes Ted Cruz relatable.…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Donald Trump went from being a billionaire businessman to the 45th President of the United States of America. He is unlike any leader the US has seen before and he has the whole world on its toes waiting to see what he does or says next. He is not the normal, clique politician that does things by the book. He is creating policies that are shocking and disrupting to other countries, with the well being of the US in mind and he is reaching out and forming relationships and connections with countries that had not been popular in the past. He is changing the way politics are normally view and making them his own, thus earning him the title of the most influential person in world politics…

    • 1447 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Daniel 11:23 says the Antichrist will gain power with a “small people”. Trump has become the Republican nominee mainly through the support of simple uneducated folk, many of whom never voted previously. Trump was elected the nominee with 5% of the adult population in…

    • 2216 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays