For Native Americans, Land Is More Than Just The Ground Sheet Analysis

Improved Essays
Native Americans have long struggled to preserve their culture along with their lands due to foreign intervention. Author Kelli Mosteller wrote “ For Native Americans, Land Is More Than Just The Ground Beneath Their Feet, “ and in the article she argues that keeping Native American land under Native American control would result in the prosperity of their culture. In this essay, I will examine the methods Mosteller used to prove her argument and establish herself as a credible source. I believe Mosteller did an appropriate job of using ethos, logos, and pathos to persuade the audience, which is the general public, into agreeing that Native Americans are capable of flourishing without the presence of non-Natives. Throughout the article, the …show more content…
Mosteller gets personal as she reveals to the audience her relationship with the Citizen Potawatomi Nation tribe. This revelation lets the reader know she has first-hand experience with the issues she speaks of. In addition, she connects more social issues to Native Americans to broaden the pool of sympathizers. Besides poverty, Mosteller mentions, “wars,” “genocide,” “forced removals,” and “separation from ancestral homelands” (Mosteller) Although Native Americans may not be facing all these issues currently, tying their history with the possible reality of other groups of people (including immigrants) is a way of getting the audience to feel how the author hopes to make them …show more content…
The ethical approach and all the resources it included led the article to be a reliable source of information. Additionally, the logistical progression of historical events, which lead to today’s issues, helped to establish the reasoning of Mosteller’s stance with the subject. Finally, the personal connection she had to the topic and the broadened audience target created a sympathetic view from the audience towards Native Americans. Overall, Kelli Mosteller was able to use strong arguments (which were backed up with examples and facts) in order to clearly convince the audience to agree with

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Sand Creek The Morning After In Annette Jaimes, “Sand Creek The Morning After” she first starts by giving a background to the atrocities done to the Southern Cheyenne and Arapaho in late 1864 after stating they were at peace. This group of people, after being having countless lives taken, were driven out of their Colorado. She moves forward two decades where the American Indian community celebrate the renaming of Nichols Hall and honoring those who were slaughtered at Sand Creek.…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Native American response paper This response paper will be on the articles A Tour of Indian Peoples and Indian Lands by David E. Wilkins and Winnebagos, Cherokees, Apaches, and Dakotas by Debra Merskin. The first article discusses what the Indian tribes were and where they resided. There are many common terms to refer to the native people including American Indians, Tribal nations, indigenous nations, first peoples, and Native Americans. Alaskan natives are called by their territories like the Inuits or the Aleuts.…

    • 1151 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Battle over land ownership and the movement of the Native American’s off of their land is part of the American story. As whites moved across America, the Indians were moved to less desirable land. In the two essays that I wrote for this class, Kaw People and Absentee Landowners the interesting connection between both essays is that not only were the Indians moved off the land but settlers and their descendants who wanted the land were priced out of the land in Chase County. Both essays are connected by the simple fact that as land became more valuable only the most powerful or richest could own the land and as a result both the Kaw and people of Chase County have became more dependent on others for support.…

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Lee Maracle Education

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In this article, Lee Maracle discusses how Native people handle situations with enemies, paths to take in life, education and the laws of the land. Maracle begins with discussing her personal life, "I sought the teachings of my grandmother" (36) to enhance the reader's understanding of the complexity of Native people inheriting and learning everything from their elders. This information then gets expanded on when Maracle discusses the importance of decision making and how someone has to use "self-determination... when our own people are making decisions." (37) Maracle then furthers her discussion of life paths with the discussion of education systems and educating on traditions, laws, and values for young children. She discusses the difference…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Native Americans had quickly become “savages,” and “uncivilized.” Europeans had failed to understand the rich cultures, and as time went on, these cultures would be haggard or outright destroyed by disease, conquest, loss of ancestral lands and subjugations. Due to the popular idea among European settlers that Native Americans were “savages,” and “uncivilized,” they embarked on a century long quest to strip the Native Americans from their heritage. The European settlers had been effective in “stamping out the Indian,” creating a disparity among the Native American people and themselves. They were able to retain their culture while destroying the Native American’s.…

    • 1044 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Indigenous peoples have been resisting against the colonial drawn borders in both parts of the world. This resistance is seen physically on reserves as well as in legal battle against the powerful federal, states and corporate nexus in North America. While the tribal governments’ regulations to protect their environment from “fracking” are strict, maintaining “separateness” is mounting challenge to fundamental spatial, cultural, economic and political sovereignty. In the context of environmental protection, sovereignty is fundamental to establish environmental standards as they have been recognized as legitimate and that are enforceable. However, the federal and state institutional structure considers “sovereignty” as a non-Native, which fails to reflect indigenous values; therefore, it is an inappropriate political goal for Native Americans to legally defend their sovereignty at the US Supreme Court, which defined Native peoples as “domestic dependent nations”.…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Native ways of keeping culture alive must be revitalized, as colonization was detrimental but did not destroy everything. Indigenous relationships with the peopled universe emphasize environmental values and a way of being that holds strong to cultural values. Colonizers desperately tried to erase this deeply rooted culture, but it is hard to erase a link so completely tied to the land. Deeply embedded in each native person’s pedagogy is history, collective trauma, the reverberating effects of genocide and colonization, and yet Native peoples are resilient, proving strength time and time again.…

    • 1150 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Discussion 1 The turn of the century in 1900’s, most remaining Native Americans had been forced, to leave their ancestral lands; it was truly a time of cultural assimilation (Assimilation through Education). Some chose to live on the reservations that were created by the U.S. government starting in the 1890s, while others spent their lives hiding from whites whom they feared would kill or capture them. Native Americans world as they new it naturally died out, from progression (Assimilation through Education), they needed to become a part of white society. There Indian language, religion, and art, would become something from the past to be studied or viewed in a museum, but would not be the products of living cultures.…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Native Americans were the first to settle in America and were defined by the English as indigenous people. The English labeled the indigenous people as “savages” and viewed them as an uncivilized culture, while they viewed themselves as a civilized culture. In Robert Warrior’s “Indian,” he argues the idea of the present absence of indigenous culture meaning their culture is what made up American culture and no one realizes it. In the “Narrative of the Captivity and Restoration of Mrs. Mary Rowlandson,” Mary Rowlandson explains her feelings and experience while Native Americans held her captive. In the beginning, her perception of the world was defined as either savage or civilized.…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By studying the history of Native Americans we can understand some of their characteristics, qualities, and perspectives regarding America’s landscape. Many of these still persist today in the original form or mutated ways. The Native American quality of living unsustainably persists today in various forms because it is difficult to notice an unsustainable lifestyle at first as described by John Steinbeck, Barry Lopez, and Scott Momaday in The Log From the Sea of Cortez, The American Geographies, and The Way to Rainy Mountain, respectively. It is easy to look back in time and see that Native Americans lived unsustainable lifestyles.…

    • 919 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lakota Woman Quotes

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages

    When you’re taught in class about the Native Americans, you’re taught the negative side of them, such as they were alcoholics, they were very violent and they didn’t want to leave when we “earned” our land peacefully. That wasn’t the real issue at hand. Lakota Woman, written by Mary Crow Dog, describes Sioux traditions, painful Indian history and the Indian’s constant battle to win equality in America. Mary Crow Dog uses her personal experiences to give an Indian perspective on these issues. By using first hand experiences, Mary helps to give the book credibility.…

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Native Americans have been viewed in a negative light ever since 1492. With Columbus’ first voyage to what he believed was the East Indies people have viewed Native Americans as bloodthirsty savages of an inferior race. These stereotypes have been passed on ever since through mediums such as the still image, novels, films, mascots, and cartoons; I believe that they have been perpetuated by a culture of ignorance in which no one cares to learn the truth. The modern world has made next to no attempt to write these incorrect views and have away with the stereotypes. Early European images of Native Americans tell us more about Europe’s world view, how they see themselves, and hardly anything about true native life.…

    • 1030 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Overall, Stretten’s argument is only effective in making people aware of her feelings but not effective in representing the community. Because of her lack of credibility and overly hostile language towards the audience, Stretten does not persuade the audience to modify their outlook on Native American culture and how the audience “honor” this community.…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This book is not a typical novel; it is a composition of many interconnected short stories that share the same characters. The short stories show different perspectives of life on the Spokane Indian Reservation, and each short story shows the struggle of the characters on the reservation in some way. The setting of this story, the Spokane Indian Reservation, shows us some of the plight that the modern Native American, born and raised on a reservation, faces. A majority of the short stories have a somber setting. For example, in the short story “Because My Father Always Said He Was the Only Indian Who Saw Jimi Hendrix Play ‘The Star-Spangled Banner’ at Woodstock”, Alexie shows Victor’s experience in a hostile household.…

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The contrast between indigenous people and those who voluntarily arrived by ship has been emphasized more than commonalities constructing the “ecological Indian” as a pinnacle or at the least something that “Man…” is not. The hunting practices employed by many indigenous tribes was ritualistic in nature with a right and wrong methodology to utilize (Krech 129), however, colonizers would question these practices with regards to buffalos in comparison to the European “proper” and “sporting” methods of hunting (Krech 130). Additionally, the prioritization of economic security over environmentalist concerns can be understood as very human, but increased pressure and scrutiny from outside of a reservation is placed on indigenous populations because they have been held up to the standard of an “ecological Indian” (Krech 226-227). This is another example of a socially constructed “fundamental truth” because these criticisms do not acknowledge the history that forced the tribal leaders to choose between two detrimental…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays