Analysis Of Properly Direct Hatred

Improved Essays
This excerpt from Thomas Doherty’s “Properly Direct Hatred” explains the urgent nature of America’s need for unity through the media during World War II, through particularly cinema. In this passage he explains that domestic issues of race, class, and ethnicity were eclipsed by the need to unify the heterogeneous population of the American ‘melting pot’ in order to fight in the war, not only militaristically and industrially, through the draft and increased production required by war, but also ideologically, because America’s power as a heterogeneous nation, directly countered Nazi ideologies of the Master Race eugenics. In his essay as a whole, Doherty outlines the way in which Hollywood collaborated with the Office of War Information to direct …show more content…
The film industry’s history of WWII representation described by Doherty and the textual influence of the circumstances of WWII are evident in Casablanca (1942) which implicitly navigates the tough terrain which the Office of War Information sought to outline by concentrating WWII conflict into personal stories, as well as, representing the war as a battle of ideologies and refusing to give the enemy a face, while ultimately suggesting that the personal is subordinate to the war and political efforts. One particular scene is especially emblematic of the OWI’s strategy in representing WWII as a war of faceless ideologies, rather than of people or groups of people, while keeping the conflict largely personal. In this scene, a group of German soldiers, with no particular leader, begins singing the German national anthem in Rick’s café, abiding by the OWI’s suggestion that the representations of hatred in WWII films not be directed toward any individuals. However, the larger narrative of the film shows that the issues are personal for Rick and Laslo, because Rick has witnessed their corruption and villainy of the soldiers, inherent in their ideology, not themselves personally, …show more content…
Cinerama, and its similar technologies, prove that cinematic technologies do not emerge on their own, but rather require circumstances that incite their development or adoption, in this case, the competition that arose with television and other leisure activities. Cinerama also exemplifies the ephemeral nature of film technology because, despite the fact that Cinerama and the competitive technologies, like CinemaScope, that it provoked became the standard during the 1950s and early 1960s, they were quickly reinvented and became outdated. Cinerama and other widescreen technologies were also part of a broader industrial shift in film production from studios making many cheaper films to instead making fewer more expensive films, to accommodate to increasing production values required in making competitive films due to the costs of filming in color and the widescreen format, and with stereo sound, based on greater potential profits in the newly restricted and highly competitive industry. The widescreen revolution of the 1950s also was part of a shift to demographically segmented audiences that required that films be produced to

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    The NAACP’s monthly publication The Crisis, from April through September 1944, illustrates the wide purview of opinion present in the organization with regards to its view of the Second World War. The picture of the war that The Crisis paints is one quite different than the traditional story of racial unification and brotherhood put forth in the discussion of World War Two for African-Americans so often in basic history courses. The Black soldier in the mind of the magazine is a person that is not only undoubtedly patriotic and a source of pride for his community, but a person just as vulnerable and victim to racism as the Blacks back home. The magazine makes no attempt to cheapen the war effort, in fact it is as patriotic as one would expect…

    • 2625 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The industrialized character of the First World War reflects its indisputable position as the first major modern war; however the antiquated ideals and methods of both its political and military leadership had more in common with the techniques of Napoléon some eighty years prior than those of the Second World War merely twenty years later. Joining prestigious company along such anti-war works as All Quite on the Western Front, The Enemy Below, and Grand Illusion, Stanley Kubrick's adaption of the 1935 novel Paths of Glory reflected this divergence well. While the film maintains a tight focus upon its central theme of “the enemy within rather than without,” Paths of Glory does touch on several other pertinent aspects of the Great War including the devastation of industrialized warfare, life in the trenches, and the futile stale mate that dominated the Western Front for most of the war. A short monolog opens the movie describing the brutal nature of the Western…

    • 1188 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Looking at the difference between both the fictional and the nonfictional sides of the story, one can see the evident alterations from nonfiction to fiction. Although War Horse the movie is similar to its real life equivalent, the movie was sugar coated and dramatized for the audience’s entertainment. The movie failed to depict the real life events, violence, and horrors that haunt WW1 veterans today. The glaring differences between these two stories outshine the similarities. General Jack Seely’s brave heroics on the battlefield gave light to one of the most well known tales of WW1.…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Casablanca (1942), which is about to get to its seventy third anniversary has all that the elements that made the film an enduring international classic — a great cast in a riveting love story; an exotic, glamorous setting; melodramatic and heroic sacrifices; sharp, strong dialogue; and the triumph of idealism over cynicism in a “world gone mad” — are still capturing our imagination. It is one of those rare films from Hollywood’s Golden Age that has managed to transcend its era to entertain generations of moviegoers for nearly three-quarters of a century. It is a movie that is very well acted according to the time it was shooted. However, if we look beyond the nostalgia and the sentimental theme of lost love and redemption, we see that Casablanca actually presents a complex and intricate political and social commentary on the early days of World War II. It is the product of the time were producers were making “a movie a week,” Casablanca surpasses its humble origins as “just another Warner Brothers’ picture” by exploiting wartime…

    • 1082 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The United State’s practiced its long-standing policy to stay out foreign disputes and affairs until World War II. Wendall Willkie’s One World reflects the shift in American support from “isolationism” to “internationalism” as well as their new role as a global leader during the early 1940’s. The book, like internationalists, opposed intolerance and oppression and, in turn, valued cooperation among and within the nations. It highlights contradictory American efforts of becoming a democratic world power, while remaining an internally racially intolerant nation. Willkie also recalls earlier tragedies catalyzed by notions of racial supremacy.…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1911, Windsor McCay created his first cartoon, based on his comic strip Little Nemo. The silent animated short film with a running time of 10 minutes is one of the earliest ever made and its expressive character animation distinguished the film from the experiments of earlier animators. Little Nemo, 1911. https://alchetron.com/Little-Nemo-(1911-film)-45390-W The response to the film was enthusiastic.…

    • 390 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Ironman2 Propaganda

    • 1945 Words
    • 8 Pages

    A movie date with DOD and Ironman2 We laugh when we see films like “the Battle of the Midway” created by John Ford because it SO in your face and almost obvious that it’s a film propagating the war effort that it leaves you almost yelling at the screen “HOW CAN PEOPLE BELIEVE THIS!” but in the last 80 something years since the second world war we have seen unbelieve advances in filming technologies that blockbusters have become these 3 hour experiences that leave us in silent awe while walking home from the theatre. Because of these astounding movie creations there leaves a massive gap for creators, investors and government agencies to perfectly embed messages and ideologies for very participating viewers to pick up on. In the opening scene of Iron2 we are brought to some undisclosed location in Moscow, Russia.…

    • 1945 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the era of World War II, propaganda controlled nearly everything from the morale of the troops to the support of the people. It led to many great victories and successes; however, it also ushered in support for mass genocides and racism. It was so effective that people in this day and age still question how it could have held so much sway. In these next few paragraphs, I will use information from The Propaganda Battle, a documentary, to explain the qualities of propaganda and how it led to genocide.…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Without hearing what it was about, Janka, my other Hungarian classmate and I decided to go to the Museum of Tolerance in Los Angeles as extra credit for our Race and Racism class. I learned in school what the Holocaust was, and imagined it to be a terrible genocide, but nothing awakens emotions and paints as realistic a picture as a first-hand recount of the events. The reality of the torture of the Holocaust and the heartrending speech of a survivor left us with overwhelming feelings of sadness, anger, and physical discomfort. Upon arrival to the museum we were ushered into a lecture hall to hear the speech of a survivor of the Holocaust. When Elizabeth Mann said her first sentence I recognized she was Hungarian from her accent, which immediately…

    • 1191 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    A Melodramatic Varnish in Ali: Fear Eats the Soul Germany emerging through the 1970s was imbued in polemic discourse concerned with the issues surrounding German identity politics. The issues around American influences within Germany’s social and political spheres proved more convoluted igniting these discourses that would be thoroughly engaged with and explored by the New German Cinema movement. This engagement proved the enigmatic approach encompassing American influences, one that Germüden (1994:55) defines twofold as “an attraction towards a culture that had been decisive in furnishing and shaping childhood images, tastes, and desires and a rejection of American politics and the colonizing effect of its popular culture.”…

    • 2152 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The United States entered World War 1 in 1917 and President Woodrow Wilson sponsored a propaganda campaign against German influence. In an effort to show unity and pride of America, President Wilson stated “You cannot dedicate yourself to America unless you become in every respect… Americans. You cannot become Americans if you think of yourselves in groups. America does not think in groups” (“Facts”). Although President Wilson claimed that “America does not think in groups”, U.S. officials and society at this time consistently denied basic civil and political rights to Americans based on their race, sex, and ethnicity – in other words, their association in a group.…

    • 854 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    4 Due to World War II, film production shut down due to the general military mobilization of many countries, and film industry was seriously weakened by it. However, it wasn’t promising for the American film industry. Hollywood film production rebounded and reached its profitable peak of efficiency during the years 1943 to 1946. By its support, the war effort was successful by the overall quality of its films, by the well-regulated delivery of diversion, information, and propaganda to receptive civilian and military audiences, by the enormous revenues and profits for all concerned.…

    • 190 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    70s Film History

    • 1360 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The film making industry has changed since the start of the cinema in the early in the 1890s, from the creation of the first motion picture cameras, to the grand computer-generated imagery we have today. But, it is a fact that without certain films from the past we wouldn’t have the films we have today.…

    • 1360 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    If I had to choose one film that represents Hollywood’s involvement in the Second World War, it would have to be Michael Curtiz’s 1942 film “Casablanca” . Examining just this film demonstrates the reasons to study the war films, especially with those produced during the war. From this type of film, we get the producers, directors writers and actors viewpoint reflected in the story that they are producing. The film is, from the producers’ time view, about current events thereby the film will often show the external constraints being forced upon it, some locally and some globally. I will argue that although just a fictional story, it transcends that, with at times a character becoming a stand-in for entire countries.…

    • 2469 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Meaning Of Casablanca

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Question 1 Implicit meaning “lies below the surface of explicit meaning, is closest to our everyday sense of the word meaning” (Barsam 318). Question 1 Ideological meaning “communicates beliefs- whether belonging to the filmmakers, to one or more characters in the movie, or the time and place in which the movie was made” (Barsam 319) The movie Casablanca (Michael Curtiz 1942), was written before the attack on pearl harbor.…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays