Analysis Of Organ Sales Will Save Lives

Superior Essays
Paper 4
"Organ Sales Will Save Lives" by Joanna MacKay explains the problem that thousands of people are complaining about. This problem is that thousands of people are begging to buy a kidney, but the government doesn't allow people to sell human organs. This outcome causes thousands of people to die each year, creating chaos around the world. Mackay and the other author’s want to convey their message to the government on why this catastrophic problem should be fixed. Since this essay is written on the subject of organ sales and Mackay’s essay was written back in 2004 some information may be dated, however not much has changed to fix this issue.
"Are Ban on Kidney Sales Unjustifiably Paternalistic" by Erik Malmquist corresponds to the main article because they both share that a kidney transplant is the best treatment for the end stage renal disease. The articles both explain the problem on how this disease affects people and
…show more content…
For example, "Patients wait increasingly longer for transplant relying instead of less effective and burdensome dialysis treatments and sometimes dying while waiting"(1). This explains the shortage of kidneys to the outrageous waiting and have no option to get dialysis or patients die because of the long wait. Another article that reckons sides with MacKay essay is "Moral Repugnance, Moral distress, and Organ Sales" by James Stacy Taylor. Who can appreciate MacKay and agree on multiple main points they can work together on their belief about organ sales and proof that they are right about the ban on organ sales. “Because of our scruples against sales, potential beneficiaries of sales, transplantation are probably dying...also true, their benefactors, actual, and potential"(4). This process is explaining the ban of organ sales and a lack of kidneys this causes many to die

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In “Organ Sales Will Save Lives”, Joanna MacKay argues that the sale of humans organs, such as kidneys, should be legalized. She claims, “There are thousands of people dying to buy a kidney and thousands of people dying to sell a kidney.” She provides critical background information on the problem before delving into her main ideas. MacKay claims that donors need and deserve the money, and that buyers are unable to access the necessary organs any other way. Unfortunately, people living in poverty in third world countries would thrive if given the money buyers are willing to provide in exchange for a vital organ.…

    • 268 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sally Satel makes the argument that there is no such thing as indignity when receiving financial gain for the donation of an organ, and she is correct by saying such. Satel believes that in order to increase the amount of transplants that occur worldwide, there much be some sort of incentive to the donors. The types of incentives should not be regulated by the government though, because the life of an individual that needs an organ is not the business of the national government. Satel opens her argument by describing the two different methods that governments want to take to sole the organ donor and transplant crisis that is occurring in the world today. The first solutions she says that governments want to use is making organ trafficking…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Organ Sales Legalized Rhetorical Analysis for "Organ Sales Will Save Lives" It does not make sense for people to die unnecessarily if there is a way to easily save their lives. Author of "Organ Sales Will Save Lives", Joanna Mackay seems to agree. In her essay, she argues that the government should regulate organ sales, rather than ban them. In "Organ Sales Will Save Lives" Mackay uses facts and statistics to reveal shocking numbers to the audience, revealing how lengthy the waitlist for an organ can be. Mackay touches on how many patients have passed away annually due to end-stage renal disease, bringing to light the importance of this issue.…

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most people would claim that authorizing the sale of organs will take advantage of the poorer people in the third world countries, but that’s already happening. The organ seller does usually collect most of the money promised, but it doesn’t make a dent on their financial struggles. The threat of a $50,000 fine and five years in prison (Finkel 26), the up-to-date ban is not successful in averting illegal organ sales and operations. The underprivileged families don’t need more harsh and rigorous punishments, on the contrary they need just the opposite. If organ sales were made lawful, it could be controlled and supervised by the government.…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Sigrid’s article, “Why should donating an organ cost so much?” he makes the argument that the Transplant Act set is doing more harm than good. The finical complications in organ donation is an important issue today because there are so many lives affected. The process of donating organs affects not only the patient’s lives, but those lives of the family and friends. Lingering thoughts of worst case scenarios and rejection are just half of the turmoil that the patients, friends, and families go through; on top of worrying about their finances.…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kidneys for Sale Miriam Schulman is the assistant director of Markkula Center for Applied Ethics (hereinafter referred to as “Center”). In 1988, the Center posted the article titled “Kidneys for Sale’’ on its website, highlighting the ethics and morality issues surrounding the continued sale of human kidneys for personal profit, which also led to emails from destitute people who wanted specifics on how they could sell their kidneys, which compelled The Center’s Issues group to discuss the pro- ideology and the ethical issues concerning the issues of organ sales. Overall, the article discusses three main considerations about the sales of organs: the morality and ethics of such exchanges; the true shortage of human organs available…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Human Organ Sales

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Introduction The need of organ donors only rise higher and higher. In “It Is Morally Acceptable to Buy and Sell Organs for Human Translation”, Mark Cherry offers a solution to this. He provides claims that defend the ethics of human organ trade. Analyzing Cherry’s arguments, I will explain how our organs are not commodities, they cannot be part of a regulated market, and we do not have the authority to put a price on them.…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The article “Organ Sales Will Save Lives” really hit home with me because I myself was born with only one kidney while the majority of the population has both. The articles tells how the legalization of organ sales would benefit all parties involved, I stand with the author on this premise. I believe that if the government would legalize and regulate the sale of organs, less people would need dialysis and there would be far less casualties in result of organ failure. The author explains to the reader that people in need of organs wait for years on end for a organ to become available to them.…

    • 470 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “There are thousands of people dying to buy a kidney and thousands of people dying to sell a kidney.” [Mackay] Mackay instantly grabs on to the readers heart strings with the beginning of her essay. MacKay’s introduction is full of emotionally- charged words and pain. “In third world countries, there are people willing to do anything for money.” [Mackay] “Eager to pay off debts, they line up at hospitals, willing to sell a kidney for about $1,000.…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article, "Organ Sales Will Save Lives, by Joanne MacKay, she appeals to the readers’ emotions by raising awareness that there are thousands of people in the world that die every year due to not enough life-saving organs, specifically kidneys. End Stage Renal Disease is when the kidneys stop working and the patient must endure grueling dialysis treatments and put on the transplant list, where they wait for a very long time for a cadaver kidney donation (MacKay ##). With only these options, some patients look to the black market to purchase a kidney, because it is banned in the United States. MacKay's argument is that "Governments should not ban the sale of human organs; they should regulate it. Lives should not be wasted;…

    • 1367 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Organ Sales Will Save Lives In the essay “Organ Sales Will Save Lives” by Joanna Mackay, kidney failure is the main topic. In the thesis Mackay says “Government should not ban the sale of the human organs, they should regulate it.” It is supported by the evidence it will save lives. 350,000 people in America struggle with this situation each year.…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Utilitarian theory, the action sell a kidney is morally right if the consequences generate the maximum of good for the greatest number. A utilitarian may analyze that selling organ for a financial incentive as an acceptable act, since several people would benefit from it. For example, Ruth Sparrow would be able to pay her medical bills, the recipient would receive a kidney thus eliminating the need for dialysis, and those under the recipient on the transplant waiting list would move up one and no one would be harmed. I strongly agree with the utilitarian approach because the fact is that thousands of people waiting for a suitable donor die each year due to vast shortage of donors, and the number of organs available is not sufficient for the required number. We should respect the decision of Ruth Sparrow who made a rational choice about kidney donation regardless of whether the choice were made with consideration of monetary gain.…

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Organ transplants have become a life-saving therapy for thousands of people, and the demands for organs from patients with organ failure for exceeds the supply. While every day, about 18 persons dies because they are waiting on an organ, I disagree with the sales of human organs being legalized. The sale of human organs should not be legalized because it will benefit the wealthy but pressure the poor to sacrifice their own health, it would be more difficult to obtain an organ if donors can sell them and people may think they can use their body for profit. Yuri, a 29-year-old Egyptian man residing in the outskirts of Cairo, worked an average of 12 hours a day on a bus calling out destinations at bus stops and collecting passengers ' fees.…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, almost 78,000 people are currently waiting for an organ donor, in the U.S. alone. Last year, only a mere amount of 2,553 organ transplant operations were performed, making the chance of someone on the list receiving an organ around 30%. In the prospective future, the amount of organ donors is not expected to rise at a significant rate; however, the rate of those on the waiting list is expected to grow, further reducing the chance of any individual placed on the organ waiting list to receive an organ. This enormous gap between the demand for organs and supply needed to meet the demand brings up the question: Is it ethical to pay people to “donate” their organs? In the case of kidneys and parts of the liver, it is ethical to incentivize…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Selling Organs Essay

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In many countries, the purchase of organs from living donors has become quite common. Most sellers are poor and healthy, while the majority of buyers are rich and sick. Many public figures considered trafficking in human organs are morally repugnant and the idea of selling human body parts for money being unethical. If selling organs became legal, only the ones who could afford it would get it. Unfortunately, poor people who are financially desperate would sell their organs to wealthy people for temporary income.…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays