Analysis Of Marcia Gaudet 's Carville : Remembering Leprosy Essay example

1517 Words null Page
In Marcia Gaudet’s Carville: Remembering Leprosy in America, the idea is presented that “counterstories seek to alter the dominant group’s assumptions as well as the oppressed person’s perception of herself,” serving as “narrative acts of insubordination” (Nelson qtd in Gaudet, emphases in original). Counterstories have been used throughout history to share and pass the experiences of multiple folklorist groups, to ignite insight into individual’s plights and to ensure justice will be seen/brought at some point to the oppressed groups. Counterstories affect the dominant group by reducing their social and political power and they also provide an alternate identity to oppressed individuals who are seeking retribution for their mistreatment from society.
Gaudet interchanges counterstory with the term counternarrative to provide it with a more realistic setting for the stories that are shared by the individuals in her book. She explains that the counterstories/narratives from Carville serve two “ideologies” (58), “They are playing against both an ideology of morality based in the bible and the ideology of a legal system that said they could not live in society…” (58-59). Carville’s counterstories of the life that was experienced inside and outside of the hospital reveal how the dominant group’s (society) perception of Leprosy and the individuals who had to live with the disease, had to overcome the stigma associated with the disease, or be socially crippled as well as…

Related Documents