James Wilson Just Take Away Their Guns Analysis

Improved Essays
In James Q. Wilson’s Just Take Away Their Guns, Wilson has fairly liberal views on guns, gun owners, and their respective rights, but Wilson also has a radical solution for gun-related crimes. Wilson boasts an increase in frisks as a better way to control the amount of guns on the streets illegally than the already instituted paperwork and background checks required to legally purchase and own a firearm. He also argues that blame and ill will should not be upon legal firearm owners and that it is not feasible to confiscate legal guns in an effort to reduce the circulation of illegal guns. While I do believe that “our goal should not be the disarming of law-abiding citizens,” and that there should be an extent of gun control in the United States, …show more content…
The US has a poor handle on the mental health of its citizens with little to no regulation in the handling of psychotic or otherwise mentally unstable citizens; in addition to little regulation, there is a lack of institutions to house those with psychological problems. At a hospital, there will be at least one behavioral health ward, but if there aren’t others in the surrounding area, then all deemed to be mentally unstable will be sent to the hospital causing massive overcrowding, increased discharging of overly aggressive and/or dangerous patients. While the patient will receive some different methods of treatment such as medicine or counselling, not all patients will be completely reformed or ready to function in society, but they will be released anyway. Increased awareness and research focusing on mental health would not only reduce the number of people affected by a mental disease, but also their access to a firearm and likelihood of one being used in a violent …show more content…
He states that “People who… defended themselves with a weapon were less likely to lose property in a robbery or be injured in an assault than those who did not defend themselves,” and that “would-be burglars are threatened by gun-wielding victims about as many times a year as they are arrested and that the chances of a burglar being shot are about the same as his chances of going to jail” (Wilson 127). If all US citizens knew these statistics and were better educated about firearms, then they wouldn’t just feel safer, they would BE safer. A population or community that is known to possess and efficiently operate a firearm would have a direct impact on violent gun crimes; no criminal wants to die, so a populous that knows how to use a gun will not be bothered. The way in which people are educated on firearms should be entirely up to the government, but they should be taught correctly and without

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    In the article “Is it time to pass tough gun control laws” the author Don Kusler believes that we should have stricter gun laws to better ensure our safety. “The Second Amendment grants U.S. citizens the right to bear arms, but it was written in a very different time: there was no police protection, and there were no automatic weapons available” The rights to own firearms should not necessarily be taken away, but should definitely be restricted, there are automatic weapons besides guns that are available to keep people safe therefore people who are worried about protection can use those instead of guns. According to the article the idea that all people with firearms in their possesion know how to use them in self defense is impractical. Very…

    • 236 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Henry Wilson Argument

    • 388 Words
    • 2 Pages

    1.) Describe the issue then state the author’s opinion about it. Wilson opinion on the issue of gun control is that he believes that a person should be frisked and searched if they look like a suspicious character. He wants the police to take away the illegal hand guns or weapons. The reason being guns cause more violent outbreaks and more injures.…

    • 388 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Davidson begins his article with the recent events of a mass shooting to hook in his audience. Then he goes on to lay out some interesting statistics regarding the annual number of shootings and how much of the American population is in favor of gun control. After this, he moves onto an interview of the director of Center for Research in Crime and Justice at New York University School, James Jacobs of Law who is also a professor of constitutional law where he brings up most of the main arguments for gun control and explains why these concepts would not work. They begin with some common misconceptions about things such as the “remarkable decrease in violent crime and gun crime in the U.S. since the early 1990s”, and that “most gun-related deaths…

    • 388 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The frisking argument provided by the author tends to focus almost exclusively on its legality, but fails to provide an instance where similar policies have successfully been applied to resolve the issue at hand or to decrease the number of illegal guns that existed in a certain region. Also, Wilson fails to provide reasons why he supports the idea of frisking and why it will work. Indicating how the alternative works is not sufficient enough to convince the audience to embrace the option in decreasing gun violence. Thus, the argument of frisking proposed by the author seems week and ineffective in controlling illegal guns or decreasing gun…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He writes “It’s not because Americans are an inherently violent people, it’s because guns are so easily available here.” Most of the crimes happening involving guns are…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    After the school shooting in Florida, Trump sparks the decision of building or reopening mental institutions. The experts do not argue that having these institutions could have stopped the killings in Florida like Trump thinks, but they can make a difference in the mental health community. The mental health community is currently experiencing some hardship due to closed hospitals and not enough funding to the community mental health clinics. People with mental health disorders are not getting the proper care and treatment they need and are ending up in prisons. In these prisons, they are still not getting what they need plus so many inmates have disorders.…

    • 243 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Society has been split into two over whether or not guns should be banned, but there needs to be a solution where both parties can be happy. Anti-gun advocates present reasoning why guns should be banned. McMahan’s main two arguments of why guns should be banned: one, guns in the community creates a more dangerous environment; and two, the police have less of a power to protect citizens when society has guns (Shafer-Landau, The Ethical Life (EL) 390). McMahan explains that communities are not going to be free of crimes with more people carrying around guns, because criminals will be more prepared, efficient, and quicker to grab and shoot their target (Shafer-Landau, EL 392-392). People with guns will be safer than people without guns, because they do not have a gun to protect themselves.…

    • 1631 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On October 1, 2015 a gunman, at Umpqua Community College in Roseburg, Oregon, opened fire in a classroom taking innocent lives of many as well as his own. In response, President Barrack Obama politicizes the issue of gun violence and asks the general public to help in the reformation of gun laws. In an online article by Rebecca Harrington, she summarizes and responds to an episode of “Last Week Tonight” in which John Oliver discusses the issue of gun violence. Politicians have dodged the issue and targeted the mentally ill, but are unable to correctly address current issues with mental health care. Harrington’s article focuses on the argument that “mentally ill people are the wrong scapegoat” and that “the mental healthcare system is broken”.…

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gun Suicides Essay

    • 1548 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Because of this, if people with mental illness did not have guns, the 58 suicides by gun that happen in America everyday could be prevented (Lopez). This also explains why it is not a coincidence that of developed countries, the United States ranks as a clear first in suicide rate and gun suicide rate (Masters). It is clear that keeping guns out of the hands of people who suffer from mental illness is important and necessary, but not something that the United States is successfully accomplishing at the moment. The reason for this is that many people oppose restricting the 2nd amendment right of all people, even including the mentally…

    • 1548 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Russ Shafer-Landau provides us with an article by Jeff McMahan in order to give us an analytical argument on gun control. Jeff McMahan, in his article Why Gun Control Isn’t Enough, discusses why he believes guns should not simply be controlled in the United States, rather they should be banned. McMahan makes the case that gun ownership, in its entirety, is dangerous and illogical. Through several examples and through his own reasoning, McMahan hopes to convince the reader that the only way forward on the topic of ‘guns’ in the United States is to completely ban civilians from owning traditional firearms, from the ground up. Through my counter-argument, I intend to show that while McMahan’s argument is versed well on intent, it is mostly normative,…

    • 1297 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His belief was correct. Requiring owners to have a justifiable reason for owning a gun and creating the gun-buyback program reduced firearm suicide by 65% (Sterbenz 4). The deaths involving guns in Australia were significantly reduced. It is also possible for America to achieve the same success, but there are different obstacles that need to be…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    America’s approach when the mentally ill commit violent crimes is locking them up without hesitating if it is the right thing to do. The mentally ill are constantly thrown in to jails or prisons because there is nowhere else to put them in, which automatically causes things to get worse. Mentally ill offenders are being mistreated, instead of getting treatment. They need help in order to get better, and having them hostage is not a way of doing it. That is why they should be sent to a mental health care facility, rather than a prison.…

    • 991 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the essay, “Just Take Away Their Guns”, James Q. Wilson a Management and Policy professor at UCLA, argues that legally owned guns are not the problem, in fact the real problem lies with society ignoring the usage of illegal guns. The purpose of this essay is to convey to society that gun crimes can be stopped before a shot is fired, that it does not entitle a huge stack of forms at the local gun store. Wilson effectively argues that legally owned guns are necessary for citizens to protect themselves, reasonable police frisks should be in place to stop illegal gun use before the crime is committed and ultimately guns agitate the situation making crimes worse. The authors credibility and logical appeal are overall effective, in spite of the lack of emotional appeal or connection to the audience. Despite the absence of Pathos, the author conveys an adequate amount of logic, which carries the paper to an effective and persuasive conclusion.…

    • 1103 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Argumentative “You can have all the gun control laws in the country, but if you don’t enforce them, people are gonna find a way to protect themselves. We need to recognize that bad people are doing bad things with these weapons. It’s not the law-abiding citizens, it’s not the person who uses it as a hobby” (Steele). There are around 100,000 victims of gun violence each year (“Brady Campaign...”). Action needs to be taken so Americans don’t feel unprotected going into a public environment.…

    • 1362 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mental health is one of the biggest problems facing the world today. Lives have been lost through improper treatment of unstable individuals time and time again through mass shootings and other tragedies. Guns are often blamed as the culprit for these attacks but I disagree. While stronger gun control could help lessen the effects of mass shootings, it's not solving the common problem these shootings have in common with each other, the shooter is almost always a mentally unstable person. Banning the weapon a person uses won't make as much of a difference because if the person is unwell, they will just use other means to accomplish their goals.…

    • 348 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays