Mellitus 'Libations In Herodotus'

Improved Essays
In Herodotus’ The Histories, after Xerxes pours a libation in a golden cup before crossing the bridge, Herodotus states: “But I cannot judge for certain whether he let these sink…as offerings to the sun…or whether he presented them to the sea in repentance” (7.54.3). Herodotus refuses to offer his definite opinion of Xerxes. By giving these two options, Herodotus leaves it to the audience to judge whether Xerxes offered the libations to the sun or to the sea in repentance. Further, by neither condemning nor praising Xerxes explicitly, Herodotus urges the reader to closely consider whether Xerxes is merely offering the libations to the gods as an act of worship or as a sign of regret for abusing the Hellespont. Moreover, by mentioning the Persian …show more content…
Despite the fact that water is a divinity among the Persians, Xerxes orders his men to verbally and physically abuse the river completely disregarding that custom. Moreover, the Persians believe that no one should even urinate or spit into the river, yet Xerxes, blinded by his rage, thinks it is acceptable to whip and curse the river. Despite his inferiority to the gods as human being, rage rapidly rushes into Xerxes causing him to think that he can penalize the divine river for raising the storm against his men. Furthermore, by claiming that he is the master of the river, he essentially considers himself to be greater than a Persian divinity, which evidently shows the extremity of his rage. Ignoring the superiority that Persians give to water, Xerxes allows himself to oppose the gods, whom he especially should respect as a Persian. Thus, his rage makes him unreasonably defy the highly regarded element of water among the …show more content…
After Pythios asks: “Please, sire…release one of my sons from the army…the eldest one” (VII. 38.3), Xerxes violates this custom because he “ thought Pythios would ask for anything but what he actually requested, so he told him he would grant this favor…Xerxes became enraged… ‘you are my slave and should be following me with your entire household’” (VII. 39.1). Although lying is a sin among the Persians, the king himself violates this custom. Instead of calmly dealing with the situation, Xerxes becomes uncontrollable angry at Pythios’ request because he thinks that Pythios is his slave who should be following Xerxes with his household rather than being concerned for his own family. Moreover, rather than hastily telling his son to leave without Xerxes’ permission, Pythios politely asks Xerxes for this one favor. Yet, with utter carelessness, Xerxes makes a blind promise and then, out of rage that Pythios asked to release his son, he immediately breaks that promise committing the sin of lying. Furthermore, Xerxes’ anger blinds him to such an extent that he calls his guest-friend a slave and shows dishonesty simultaneously. Thus, Xerxes’ rage cause him to disregard the Persian custom of never

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    During 300-400 BCE, Greeks passion for reasoning and logic influenced the development of Western thought. Contribution to historical records, philosophers Herodotus and Thucydides were first to explain history; they would delve into the past to decide the facts and significance of historical events. For instance, Herodotus questioned and analyzed historical evidence to write History of the Persian War; however, not often did he differentiate between facts and legends. Later, Thucydides incorporated facts he could prove and maintain impartiality to write about History of the Peloponnesian Wars. For example, Thucydides issued both weaknesses and strengths for both Sparta and Athens.…

    • 258 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Xenophon now announces that he has captured a number of men, killed several of them and kept two alive to act as ‘guides who know the country’ (Stoneman, 65). This showed that Xenophon was probably getting tired of being misguided and was trying to show it through killing so that the next person who tries to step in or say they know their way around won't be playing. He felt that any man who acted as a guidman for them was a enemy I would assume that Xenophon felt that way due to the past history of guideman misdirecting him in his…

    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Odysseus is seen as a hero and leader by all his comrades who returned from the Trojan War. According to his fellow commanders, like Menelaus, he has strength, courage and restraint. In Ithaca, preceding the war, Odysseus was viewed as a kind merciful king, adored by his people. Though when voyaging home, Odysseus displays his stubbornness in making decisions, overcome by the need to gain glory and prestige above all else.…

    • 1296 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Socrates in Apology In the Apology, Socrates presents an argument for his belief in the Greek gods to invalidate Meletus’ assertion that Socrates is an atheist, which therefore means his teachings corrupt the youth (26b). Socrates’ argument is valid through philosophical logic yet as we will find, his argument is not sound. There are also revisions to Meletus’ claims which will be presented as it will display a stronger argument in favor of Socrates’ atheism.…

    • 1311 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As Herodotus noted, Xerxes ‘had no intention of doing the very thing for which he blamed them, or, by taking reprisals, of freeing the Spartans from the burden of their crime’ (Selincourt…

    • 1462 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a result, the Greek’s take heavy losses and Agamemnon even suggests retreating and surrendering. These examples show that for Greeks, refusal to show xenia meant hardship and the loss of the gods’ favor. Even Agamemnon recognized this when he said: “I see now that [Zeus’] orders/Are for me to return to Argos in disgrace”, a consequence of his reproachable actions. If he would have acted differently and shown xenia, the course of the war would have resulted very…

    • 908 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Without even knowing who Odysseus is, Alcinous had offered Odysseus a way to get home and treated him with hospitality, proving that the Phaeacians follow Xenia. Another example was the Phaeacian elder who saw Odysseus on the ground and exclaimed, “There is no way, Alcinous. How indecent, look, our guest on the ground, in the ashes by the fire! . . . raise him up and seat the stranger now . . .” (7.189-192).…

    • 254 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While Odysseus was struggling to return to his homeland, many of the maids in his palace were not anticipating his arrival back home and became disloyal and harming, but many maids remained loyal and helped men in the process, . With Odysseus gone, Odysseus’’s once-loyal maid Melantho harms Odysseus and the suitors through her disloyalty. When Melantho first caught sight of the old beggar roaming in the palace, she “mocked him shamelessly” even though Penelope has “treated [Melantho] as a child and gave her...cheer for her heart” (18:364-367). Even with the love and care provided by Penelope, Melantho seems to disregard that and act in hospitable ways while in Odysseus palace. As Odysseus remained in the palace, Melantho taunted ¨cock of the walk, did someone beat your brains out...¨ (18:370).…

    • 368 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Yet both men are very human when it comes to their faults and both can be seen and the anti-hero. Odysseus can be seen as such because is the new form of hero, the think before you kill, type of hero. His craftiness and tricks can come off as cheating or as not honorable. The corruption of the ideal of xenos is seen in both men's actions. Odysseus' actions of wronged xenos can be seen is the following quotation from Book Nine of The Odyssey: "I'd brought along a skin of wine that we'd been given as a gift.…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The gods also realize the massive threat Odysseus’ household is under in his absence, and thus resolve to finally direct him towards home to restore order to his household and Ithaca. The only god that objects to this is Poseidon, as he holds a grudge against Odysseus for blinding his Cyclops son, and thus causes many of the hindrances of Odysseus’ journey. However, even he realizes that Odysseus’ return is essential, and compromises with Zeus: “‘I thought Odysseus should in time regain his homeland; I had no mind to rob him of that day- no, no; you promised it, being so inclined; only I thought he should be made to suffer all the way… I should have taken vengeance, as you say, on my own; but I respect, and would avoid, your anger” (XIII.159-85). Despite his own divine will and hatred of Odysseus, Poseidon had never dared to deprive Odysseus of his homecoming, as this would have upset the will of the gods, which asserts that Odysseus must come home to restore his household.…

    • 1619 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This relationship is a derivative of the emphasis of Xenia and morality in the Greek civilization. The laws set forth by the gods in each civilization demonstrate the similarities of the cultures in the way that the gods want to control the community and overall morality of the humans. Although the laws are somewhat different,…

    • 1693 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Odysseus says, “’I wanted to see [the Cyclops] and claim the stranger’s gift… So we lit a fire and made our thank-offering, and helped ourselves to as many cheeses as we wanted to eat; then we sat inside till he should come back with his flocks’” (111). Odysseus is impulsive and does not think before he acts. He is very selfish and only wants to see what glory the Cyclops gives him. He expects everyone to bow down to him, let alone know who he is, contrasting Odysseus when he fights the suitors at the end of the story and receives glory from his city. When Polyphemus, the Cyclops who happens to be Poseidon’s son, returns home, he traps Odysseus and his crew in his cave.…

    • 1566 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    At first glance it may appear that Herodotus’ account of Egypt is a clear-cut description of the country and what he learned there, intended to educate a Greek audience. However, a closer examination reveals that his intentions and motivations may have been different that originally assumed. The opening passage exemplifies the sort of conflicted view of the Egyptians that the author so frequently presents. Though, at times, he emphasizes their otherness, he seems to admire their achievements and credits them with inventing multiple cultural practices that the Greeks then copied. He begins with high praise for the Egypt, calling it a country of wonders, unparalleled in their quantity or majesty (2.35).…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Ithaca, Telemachus blames Odysseus not returning home on Zeus. However, he sees how much the gods help him and how other kings pray and sacrifice. Again, Athena reveals how much she is helping Telemachus soon after he doubts whether the gods are on his side, showing him that if he keeps praying, his wishes will come true. He arrives at Pylos as they are sacrificing to Poseidon; they also sacrifice to Athena before they leave.…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is also important to remember that Ithaca was currently a city without a king and suitors who were attempting to take his spot. In these turbulent times, Eumaeus still fulfills proper xenia he adds, “rudeness to a…

    • 1663 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays