H. J Mccloskey Analysis

Great Essays
In H.J McCloskey’s article, he made clear to his readers that the major dispute to theism is the presences of evil in the world. This essay will provide a response to many of the arguments McCloskey made and hopefully offer some clarifications and point out some issues with other objections to the topics of evolution, indisputable, issues of morality, and the subject matter that questions the existence of God, which he also has expressed in his article (McCloskey). The arguments were meant to be used together to provide some insight on the subject matter.
The first argument that is presented in the article is the Cosmological argument. This argument attempts to infer the existence of God from the existence of the universe. In McCroskey statement
…show more content…
This argument does provide some small amount of perception to the knowledge of God but does not mention any attributes about God. This argument also gives some small amount of the knowledge of God but does not mention any attributes.
McCloskey has expressed some objection to the Teleological argument. He states one can reject the argument of design because of the premises that there is no evidence of design and purpose. He points to evolution theory and claims that there seem to be nothing. Basically, no evidence to prove thus compelled to believe there is no such thing as indisputable examples of proof. The Teleological argument argues that the universe displays nessences. It gives insight on the characteristics of the universe. According to Dr. Drew Forman in his video discussion stated Nessence is that which has complexity, order, and purpose in its ability to be.
…show more content…
Atheism values and arguments are inconstant statements and are a dehumanizing view. Filled with inconstant conclusion, and equivocations. McCloskey view of morality is a cultural view. This view is very different around the world and these views change therefore they are not constant and could change frequently based on personal experiences and beliefs. In an article written by William Lane Craig titled, ‘The Absurdity of Life without God’, he presented numerous arguments of Atheist Significance, Moral Motivation, the Atheistic meaning of Morality and Atheistic Purpose. His argument was, if there is no God then we have no reason what so ever to be moral then we are free to act without being held accountable. What would be in place to establish a definition for morality that is solid, concrete and unchangeable? God is the creator and giving humans the gift of free will has established the definition of morality and set bounders for his creation to operate within. Look at the atheistic meaning of the existence of God. Life without God has no value. Thus, what is the value of Death or Love? Human life would be the same as an animal. Everything we do in life would be meaningless. Why have a funeral honoring a person who has passed

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    It was Thomas Merton, a Catholic English writer who once said “To say that I am made in the image of God is to say that love is the reason for my existence, for God is love. Love is my true identity. Selflessness is my true self. Love is my true character. Love is my name” (Merton).…

    • 1204 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Response to McCloskey’s Article Shamyra Thompson Liberty University Introduction In the short article On Being an Atheist, H.J. McCloskey discusses several arguments pertaining to the whether or no there is a God and what one believes to be evil. McCloskey also refers to the arguments as “proof” as well as implied several times that they can’t define or establish the existence of God. In the light of Foreman’s comments in regards to the question of God’s existence, I felt that he addressed the question by discussing the commonly asked question “Is there a God or if a God exist”. He also discussed what exactly is evil.…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1968 a philosopher named H.J. McCloskey wrote an article titled “On Being an Atheist,” which attacked the main arguments held by theists. The main arguments that he refers to as “proofs” are the cosmological argument, the teleological argument, and the ontological argument. McCloskey’s article debunks these arguments as being false and without proof. He states that theists should dismiss the idea of God entirely. He claims in his opening statements that he will show reasons why theists should be miserable just because they are theists (1).…

    • 742 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Teleological Argument for the Existence of God, also known as “Arguments from Design”, states that a designer must exist because the universe and living things exhibit marks of design in their order, consistency, unity, and pattern, and that designer is God. One of the analogies used for this argument is William Paley’s Watch Maker Argument. He gives the scenario: if you were to find a watch in an open field you would automatically assume that it was designed and did not just randomly form out of thin air. Based off this argument, if you agree that the universe and its inhabitants are designed in some way for a purpose, then there must be a designer responsible, which would be God. Believers in the Teleological Argument also argue that scientists and evolutionists are unable to explain how complex organisms such as the eye originated.…

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the reading McCloakey talks about proofs. He believes that three proofs move ordinary theist their theism. The first proof that he speaks about is cosmological, which is the chain that every created thing is being caused right now. There is a slight argument over the creation, who is God, having a cause in the beginning. It is believed that if the proofs fail from an observational perspective; then the proof is proven false.…

    • 1532 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If the theist was to truly believe that God was not wholly good, then he is opening doors to a sadistic God. Also, the theist could reject that God is not omnipotent. But the problem still remains of the theist not truly accepting that God is not all-powerful, and he cannot eliminate evil. The theist’s adequate solutions are not enough to get out of the problem of evil because he cannot fully accept the rejection of one proposition. Therefore, it is assumed that if the theist when discussing the problem of evil rejects the proposition, the proposition is then assumed elsewhere in the…

    • 1014 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When you hear the word evil what thoughts pop-in your head? Do you believe an evil can exist if there’s still a higher power or God? In this essay, I will be discussing Williams Rowe’s argument for atheism based on the Well-Known argument “The Problem of evil and Some Varieties of Atheism”. The problem of evil questions the existence of a God based on the evil in the world. In this paper, I will discuss his reasoning for atheism, I will explain in depth what he means by each premise.…

    • 535 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He says if God didn’t exist we would all be perfect. We wouldn’t have any doubts or desires. You can’t doubt the existence of God since the idea of god has infinite objective reality and is more likely to be true. The idea of God could have come from your parents, and they got it from your grandparents. It’s a never ending cycle that could only conclude the idea of God originating from God.…

    • 1191 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the article On Being an Atheist H.J. McCloskey attempts to explain to us the “grounds upon which theists base their belief in God, of the inadequacy of these grounds and why Atheists believe that there is no God.” (p. 62) Throughout the article, McCloskey attempts to use these three proofs, the cosmological proof, the teleological proof, and the argument from design, to explain why theists are incorrect to believe in God. Although McCloskey has made a very strong case, he was not able to fully prove his points because many arguments or defeaters, exist against his proofs and for the fact that all his proofs are not able to be judged individually but are to be used together in theism. In doing so McCloskey has failed to provide his point…

    • 1716 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This paper states one of many answers to the presence of evil and questioning God’s omnipotence presented by Mackie in his article “Evil and Omnipotence”. Mackie has his own “Inconsistent TRIAD” formula that states: 1. God is omnipotent 2. God is omnibenevolent 3. Evil exists.…

    • 981 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The existence of God, a topic discussed in both William Rowe’s and Robin Collins’ papers, but for two very different reasons. The argument of good vs. evil and the existence of an omnipresent, benevolent being such as God is a topic that many find very difficult to find answers for, and will continue to plague mankind for the rest of our existence. After reading the published works of Mr. Collins and Mr. Rowe, one may find it easier to formulate their own opinion. In the publication by Mr. Collins, he addresses the topic of atheism and theism in respect to physics.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Atheists have morals without a god. Atheists have obligations to follow morals. According to Louise M. Antony in the article “Good Minus God,” “Atheism is the view that the only kind of “obligation” there could possibly be is the kind that is disciplined by promise of reward or threat of punishment.” Atheists follow beliefs that are very similar to those of theists because many of the human laws follow theistic beliefs. Atheists have the incentive to follow these laws because if they don’t, they have the fear of being punished for it.…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Where the beginning of Morality came from has been a huge debate among people for hundreds of years now. Morality can also be called the goodness in people or the desire to be good. Theists believe morality comes from God. Atheists believe that morality comes from our own conscience or reason. In this essay we are going to focus on proving that morality could not have come from God in view of the following reasons, 1: You can be good without God, 2: The Bible is not a clear guide for direction on morality, 3: There are many things that religious people do not agree with, and 4: The problem of evil.…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Does God Exist Essay

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the vast study of philosophy, a particular question has baffled even the most intelligent minds. This question is, “Does God exist?” Philosophers have considered the answer to this question for centuries, each coming up with their own argument and reasons behind their thinking. A platform of debate often used is Antony Flew’s parable of the two explorers, who find a garden so beautiful, that one of the explorers is positive that there must be a gardener tending to it, even if he can’t be detected in any way. The other explorer is not so easily convinced that a gardener exists at all.…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the article by H.J. McCloskey, named “On Being an Atheist”, he attempts to deny the existence of a supreme being, namely God, by offering many criticisms of theism and the beliefs and arguments of theist. In the beginning of his article, he speaks on the arguments as “proofs” and tries to make an objection as to why these arguments cannot be considered concrete in the case for God. These proofs that he speaks of are the Cosmological argument, which argues for a creator, the Teleological argument or the argument from design, which argues that the universe shows signs of intelligent design and divine purpose.…

    • 1772 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays