Analysis Of George L. Dillon's Styles Of Reading

Improved Essays
Identifying a single approach to decode the differencing of events and final happening in William Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily” proves to be useful in explanation however; a limitation of just one approach can be obstruct. In “Styles of Reading” by George L. Dillon we are presented with observation that readers critique and interpret publications based on perception of real life events and of people. In George L. Dillon critical essay “Styles of Reading”, he points out how focusing on event chains in a story is important to understand all aspects behind a stories comprehension. It was an interesting study in how people read, and how the way in which we read affects literary criticism. Dillon included multiple people’s responses to “A Rose for …show more content…
For example in A Rose for Emily, by William Faulkner when Rose asks for arsenic it is hard to approach it in just one style. Although using the Anthropologist style to analyze this situation may seem important, it is not the only style that can be used. The Anthropologist style may be used when thinking how Emily got the Arsenic without giving a reason for it because she is a woman. Another style like the Digger for Secrets can also be used when thinking why she might need the Arsenic or why is she not giving a reason in wanting the Arsenic. This proves that readers can use multiple styles in approaching criticism. There is no possible way a reader when reading “A Rose for Emily” can just look at a single piece of text and just focus on only one specific style of writing. Dillon says, “Holland’s study strongly suggests that there are styles of reading stories, characteristic ways that readers interrogate texts, and that the approaches in the criticism are indeed rooted in the critics own styles of reading and appeal to like-minded readers” (Dillion 610). Dillon shows that the interpretation of the text depends on the readers past. For example, in the short story “A Rose for Emily” by William Faulkner, the narrator reveals to us that Emily has been lying beside the dead body of Homer Baron. The Cam style suggests that this has happened because Homer was not the marrying kind, but it can also be interpreted as if Emily couldn’t have him, that she wouldn’t let anyone have him, leaning towards the Digger for Secrets. This shows that it can be interpreted in multiple ways despite the reader

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Collins wants the reader to use more than one of their senses to understand the poem. Many times when reading, the reader tries to “torture” it to find the meaning, but Collins suggests readers should simply be patient and observant. Collins’s use of literary devices really helped introduce a new and different approach to reading poetry. In the poem “Introduction to Poetry” by Billy Collins, Collins is trying to show readers that poetry is…

    • 843 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tell Tale Identity Essay

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages

    One of the main questions that we are faced as readers when reading this text is whether the narrator is insane or not? Upon first reading we note that yes his speech and actions are strange but when we then look further into the text and the way Poe portrays this narration then we begin to see the finer cracks appear in the narrators persona. Self-narration is a literary device often employed by Poe when writing his short stories, allowing him creative freedom whilst also being able to write from a perspective that can directly relate to the audience if readers. Throughout the text the narrator is constantly trying to convince both themselves and the reader of their sanity and the justification of their own actions against the old man. Throughout the novel the narrator is constantly reminding us that they are not insane however due to the nature of Poe’s writing and authorship we can straight away tell that this is not the case “You fancy me mad.…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Literature can teach how to read critically. Reading literature we learn about plot, and symbolism, and conflict. In short readings you miss out on many literary elements found in extensive reading (DeCoursey). Studies have been conducted to see how the brain reacts to literature. Literary devices, such as metaphors and similes, are commonly used in works of literature, and you will be surprised by how our brains interpret these devices.…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, Harold Schweizer questions the readers’ intents when he states “suffering can become the occasion of an endless act of comprehension”. Reading literature does not equal comprehension or understanding. Readers must first understand how their life shapes their perspective and then they must let other perceptions dominate their thoughts in order to understand the writer’s perspective. Barbara Tuchman explains that books are the foundation of life’s disciplines because “books are humanity in print”. We read books to understand other people’s culture, struggle, and perspective, but only if we desire to understand.…

    • 1523 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In C.S. Lewis’s An Experiment in Criticism, Lewis attempts to distinguish how good and bad readers interpret books. 'Let us try to discover how far it might be plausible to define a good book as a book which is read in one way, and a bad book as a book which is read in another” (1). Although Lewis’s essay is primarily dominated by “the many and the few,” the paramount message of the book pertains to the ego; moreover, how the literary experience heals the wound without undermining individuality. An Experiment in Criticism provides excellent insight of what it means to critique something.…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Through the disruption of cynicism, barbarism, and nihilism present in O’Connor’s short story, we’re cognizant that literature truly matters. Its very essence strives to enlighten others of the possibilities of generosity, sympathy, and morality. Mrs. Turpin’s revelation at the end of the story allows readers an insight into these possibilities. When coursework is assigned, the objective is more so to find meaning behind a story than to just read it. Tim Gillespie’s article encourages this, publicizing that literature is more than just words on a…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stephen King Reflection

    • 1385 Words
    • 6 Pages

    King explains that the details of writing that are the least examined, are the determining details that show if a writer is strong and/or has a good story. King says that as a before writing rule, a way for a writer to decipher between good and bad writing is you need to “..read and write a lot” (145). From examining other works, the writer will be able to critique him/herself more effectively. King gives a during-writing tip about a proper writing environment saying “...you need the room, you need the door, and you need the determination to shut the door” (157). After explaining the importance of a functioning workspace, King delves into technical details of writing including symbolism, tips subsequently to the completion of your first draft, plot and theme, dialogue, and stylistic imitation.…

    • 1385 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Authors use fiction and poetry as a platform to address certain political or cultural aspects such as class or gender roles. After these new ideas are brought up in their minds, they protest and do everything possible to change their customs. They do this so they do not find themselves living in manipulative ways. Modernity depends on individuals to question and stand up to traditional norms. In the end, narrative fiction and poetry work as a means of communicating with people.…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tone is shown throughout stories to give insight to the author’s feelings by using specific vocabulary especially in The Possibility of Evil. This story contains so much evidence for tone it is almost hard not to comprehend what the author wants the reader to feel. The story’s name has the word evil in it and even before you start to read you might have a feeling of forebodence due to this startling title. Also, the reader is introduced in the first sentence to “Miss Adela Strangeworth...” (p. 1, line 1). Her name (STRANGEworth) may infer that something isn’t going to be unusual in this book.…

    • 1413 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Macbeth Tragic Hero Analysis

    • 4696 Words
    • 19 Pages

    (When he sees the dagger: ‘Is this a dagger which I see before me…’) When Banquo asks: ‘Who’s there?’ Macbeth replies: ‘A friend.’ That is a good example of dramatic irony, because the audience may suspect what Macbeth does later on to Banquo, and that Macbeth really isn’t a good friend. There is more evidence that Macbeth is feeling unsettled. He lies to Banquo: BANQUO I dreamt last night of the three weird sisters… MACBETH I think not of them. If Macbeth was genuine there would be no need to lie. Also when Macbeth says: ‘..being unprepared...’ That could be a reflection of how he is feeling about the whole plot to murder Duncan.…

    • 4696 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Improved Essays