Clark Pope Doing School Analysis

Improved Essays
Denise Clark Pope, a distinguished writer, conducted a study on the modern student and the behaviors they feel will help them succeed. She published her findings in a book titled Doing School. In Doing School, she follows five students at Faircrest High School. Pope analyzes their behaviors and why they do them. Firstly, Pope discusses the “Predicament of Doing School.” She describes “Doing School” as how students manipulate their teachers and the system in order to get ahead. Pope categorizes these behaviors into four different habits that students rely on to get ahead of their classmates; The four behaviors were, establishing allies and treaties, multi - tasking, cheating, and being a “squeaky wheel”. Establishing allies and treaties …show more content…
Being in the top ten percent of your class), so in order to succeed, students become what Pope calls “Classroom Chameleons”. Students would change their behaviors from class to class, doing what they knew their teachers would prefer them to do. Pope says that because students act this way, their different teachers have different viewpoints of their students. Pope concludes that for this reason, there are many misunderstandings between students and teachers, and students and other students. For example, one teacher could view a student as lazy or annoying, while another teacher could see the same student as intelligent and hardworking. Being a Classroom Chameleon can prevent the teacher from getting to know the “whole” student, claims Pope. Students become Classroom Chameleons in order to help them succeed, but this habit could be doing more harm than …show more content…
She talks about young children, saying they want to be rich and drive a Lexus, so they need to get all A’s. Pope goes on to point out the parallels in the American school system and the American capitalist system. The goal in both is to be the best, even if it means compromising your beliefs. Students knew the expectations set for them by both their parents and the economic system. Pope states that students feel the pressure to be the best at a young age, and that their parents will pay a considerable amount to ensure that that will

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Some teachers prefer class to be silent and appreciate when students work on their own, while other teachers like to see students making comments and having discussions about the material. Likewise, when students discovered which teachers prefered which type of students they changed to fit into that teachers perfect student. Pope states, “The students may use the disguises to hide their weakness or to show off their strengths, but in either case, the teacher is privy to only a partial view, often resulting in a lack of useful knowledge about the students, or worse, misconstructions about the youth.” An example of this claim is Teresa, one of the students Pope studied, she excelled in her business classes, and when she was nominated for Outstanding Business Award, her Spanish teacher was perplexed. He said that she often failed tests and didn’t turn in assignments. Without knowing all the sides to each student it can…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Students Assessment Many students have conflicts with their teachers, and some love their teachers. There should be a way for students to grade their teachers in the way that they are graded. Teachers grade students based on their academic performance, as well as how they act in the class. Some teachers care about student’s education and while others don’t respect students nor their job. Some people think kids are young and don’t know what they’re doing but they do know what’s best for them when it comes to their education.Every teacher is different in their own way using different methods to teach children, students grading teachers will help them better their job and get closer to students who need a more understanding in the classroom.…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The importance of a Individualized Lesson Plan (ILP) or an Individualized Education Plan (IEP) is to help every child in the be successful in the classroom. Individualized Education Plans are often used in the classroom to cater to students with behavioral issues, learning disabilities, problems focusing inside the classroom and other issues. What if teachers could use the same ILP/IEP format to meet every students learning ability regardless of student? The Common Core lesson Plans that are used in the classroom now are just that, "Common". Many students are failing at being successful in school because teachers are teaching 20-3o twenty to thirty students in a classroom, with 20-30 different personalities and different backgrounds, "The Common"…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Resulting in the fact that students shouldn't rate their teachers. These teachers work hard to educate their students. It isn't the teacher’s fault that the student is unprepared for class, and lacks the motivation to study. "The bad news is that students often conflate good instruction with pleasant ambience and low expectations. As a result they also reward instructors who grade easily, require less work, are glib and chatty, wear nice clothes, and are physically attractive… Plus students will penalize demanding professors or professors who have given them a bad grade, regardless of the quality of instruction that a professor…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Doing School,” the book was written by Denise Pope. Denise Pope was one of the co-founders of the website Challenge Success, which is an organisation in which parents wanting to foster a child or teen can learn tips and tricks on how to. She is also specializes in curriculum studies, service learning, student engagement, school reform, and qualitative research methods. Denise Pope is extremely interested in the student voices in school and their perspective. This is one of the reasons why she wrote the book “Doing School.” In the book, she observed that at Faircrest’s five students had certain ways of “doing school.” When she asked them, they explained that they would establish allies and treaties, multi-task, and even cheat.…

    • 553 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the article “Doing School,” by Denise Clark Pope, “co-founder of Challenge success, a research and intervention project that aims to reduce unhealthy pressure on youth and champions a broader vision of youth success,” asserts that “students feel the need to manipulate the system and devise crafty strategies to get ahead”. Also “students feel compelled to betray friends and deceive teachers.” Finally, “students feel the need to compromise integrity for future success,”(Pope 150). She came up with these claims through researching Faircrest High School. Four students helped in this research project, but soon came up with problems after having the stress of school on their shoulders. Denise explains in her article that how and why these students are ending up with these problems.…

    • 879 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Andrew Mullins argues that “single-sex schooling allows teachers to tailor their teaching style to the boys and facilitates a more rounded educational experience. In a co-ed school, boys can opt out of curriculum areas where they would be outperformed.” That means the instructor will feel uncomfortable in the class or in the school if he or she has to use different teaching styles for different genders, and the girls will be scared from the boys in the school. Another reason boys and girls should be separated in the classroom is that this will reduce spread the disease and make teenage pregnancy more likely. For example, when the boys and girls study together, both of them communicate with each other, so probably that will let the diseases spread in the school. In addition, when boys and girls do communicate in the class, they will communicate outside the class.…

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The group’s grade assesses the group’s output, but does not showcase feedback for each team member on his or her own skills. Not only does this unfairly score students, but it also does not help the individual improve his or her own weaknesses because he or she has not received accurate criticism; the individual student also will not be able to shine or experience his or her own mistakes. When a teacher notices a student struggling in a specific area of study, she may cater to that student to provide materials or extra help to assure they will succeed; however, with group work, the student’s struggle is shadowed by the overall group’s work ethic. Not all students are well suited to work in an environment in which they must rely on others to complete his or her work. In 2007, 67% of the public voted that public schools should be responsible for dealing with behavioral, social, and emotional needs of students (Alters).…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Competition is usually a very big motivator in a persons life. If a child is homeschooled they might lack the motivation that comes with interacting with peers (Bell, Debra). W.A. Pannapacker in the article, "Homeschooling Provides the Best Education" says, "School sometimes teaches otherwise happy and intelligent children to become sullen and secretive and contemptuous of learning." I disagree with this completely because schools helps students get involved and interact with one another, whether it is in class or outside of class.…

    • 1590 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    This in turn created biased and unfair opinions about the students, and more often teachers graded them poorly based on these false beliefs. Students will not get a fair chance to show the teachers their real potentials in learning. Symbolic integrationists focus on face-to-face interaction. In examining what occurs in the classroom, studies have found that student performance tends to conform to teacher expectations, whether they are high or low. Sociologist Ray Rist indicated that each child’s journey through school was determined by the eight day of kindergarten (Henslin, 2010, Chapter, p.511).…

    • 1504 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays