Deleuze's Influence On Music Analysis

Great Essays
Scholarly reception in music looks at developing dialog and discussion among scholars who are engaged in philosophical and practical analyses of musical experiences. Unlike other philosophical discourses, the difficulty of speaking about music is the difficulty of speaking about a nonrepresentational art form. Music has been discussed in terms of the hard sciences, such as pitch, rhythm, and form, but music has been at best, ignored with respect to philosophical thought. Deleuze is one philosopher who has tackled music straight on. An analysis of the scholarly reception of Deleuze 's influence on music reveals the problem with using language to speak about non narrative topics such as music. I am writing on the scholarly reception of Deleuze …show more content…
Hulse and Nesbitt (2010) see two problems with this statement. Deleuze 's thoughts on music were not consistent with his overall philosophical approach. They also feel that there is a need to move beyond Deleuze as he has only scratched the surface of speaking about a non-narrative form. Hulse and Nesbitt (2010) point out that one major problem in the field of music studies is that it is seen separate from other scholarly thoughts. Hulse (2015) critiques Edward Campbell 's idea of how Deleuze is applied to different subjects and in particular, music.1 Hulse posits the question “Does musical production, once armed with the technologies of Deleuze and Guattari, 'change” after Deleuze, or is it our understanding of music that is changed or ought to change?” (Hulse, 2015.) Hulse (2015 states that some people think that there is music that is more Deleuzian than other types and that this is not a defensible position. Rather, Hulse (2015) argues that all music is Deleuzian. Hulse (2015) asserts that Campbell 's ideas of Deleuze and music privileges Western-European music over other types. Campbell (2015) responds to Hulse 's review of Campbell 's article “ 'All Music is 'Deleuzian ' by asserting that he does not share Hulse 's view that the “Deleuze 's relationship with musical modernism is fundamentally …show more content…
I have tried to articulate about musical compositions and how the thought that goes into the actual creating of music unfolds from a primordial abyss to becoming-music. How do we articulate that? It is difficulty, indeed. In my assessment of the authors I have researched, I find that many of them struggle with discussing music in terms of a narrative. For example, Hasty (2010) and Bogue (2003) both start with speaking about musical compositions that are analyzed in Deleuzian terms, but they usually succumb to the problems that are inherent in a nonrepresentational art forms, as they fall back to a discourse on notational techniques, inspiration for musical ideas, or a generalization of the musical genre. This is seen as Bogue (2003) starts out speaking about becoming-music, but soon the discussion is reduced to Messian 's ideas of notational devices. I know that there can be many interpretations on a myriad of subjects, such as music and class, but after reading Grose 's (2012) article, the promise of speaking about becoming- music falls into the common discussion of describing nature in musical terms. It is encouraging that Deleuze takes the position of the artist rather than the position of the audience as much discussion has been devoted to what the listener

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    While lyrical music may more directly display a message, instrumental pieces can leave many in bewilderment. Copland acknowledges that most amature listeners seek concrete meanings, however, a full understanding of a piece is nearly impossible to discover. Copland suggests the listeners should be satisfied with a high-level understanding of a piece but open to further explanation. While the story of a song may remain a mystery, we should keep an open mind to digging deeper into the obvious signals a song elicits. If a song is dark or sad, what type of darkness or sadness is being highlighted.…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Categorizing music correctly today is very troublesome. Labeling a song with the correct genre is difficult because of the mixture of various genres in a particular song. An in-depth analysis is required to accurately label a song with the right genre. Can we analyze and categorize modern music correctly? Using ideas of the past genres produces possible genres that could fit the song.…

    • 1093 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The existing structure of the music as such the duration of the note, step, balance, and tone color are emphasized in this part of the essay. This fundamental study of the structure is a must to form a having a solid foundation in the musical segment and to realize the diagnosis of it. This technical and more theoretical plane is inconsistent to the philosophical sensuous plane. consequently, it is another good technique of Copland to set down one right after another to cover the entire listening process. from this statement, I think that there is an unpleasant emotion caused by the losing the expressive plane, if this situation triggers.…

    • 502 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One point she makes about those skeptical of any relationship existing (music existing just for music’s sake) is that either they truly believe this or do not having the sufficient tools to describe it. She quickly dismisses the first with the statement of music’s meaning coming from “human beings who live in a human world,” music being a part of the human world. More interestingly, the second part, she attributes to what Wittgenstein states as logic’s unspeakable or indescribable relationship to the world, which translates to Attali’s statement as music being an “instrument for understanding” and the world “for hearing.” She ends with stating that this metaphysical issues leaves those who wish to tackle the problem more dealing with the issue than a solution, and the ultimate request to just stop and…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sample Literature Review

    • 1017 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Baglione expands by saying that the author should also address the strengths and weakness of each school of thought. Upon review of the research paper, I do not believe that the author adequately does this in the literature review. The author does a good job of explaining the components of traditional decision-making theory and the scholars who proposed the theory. The author then goes further to explain the weakness of traditional decision-making theory by saying that one cannot prediction human behavior, or what he terms “actor rationality”. Nevertheless, where I feel that the literature review is lacking is the application of decision-making theory to the Yom Kippur War.…

    • 1017 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The common way to structuring 3rd movement is Minute-Trio form as I mentioned before. As Kerman mentions in the article which called “How we got into analysis, and how to get out”, people can apply criticism to analysis but it could be problematic when we apply to everything. In other words, if people only stand in the certain side with the critical thought, they only can be in one side. In terms of this, people can think about the using of pizzicato in the Trio section. It might be not a great idea to analysis only based on the typical sequence or traditional structure of music.…

    • 2248 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The alienation a focus on linguistics presents for texts that are rooted in aesthetic applications of language is one of de Man’s primary arguments for why the post-1960s theories are more radical and garnered more resistance. These linguistic considerations include grammar, semantics, context, readability, and tropological phrases. It is through his exploration of language that de Man reaches the conclusion that “the resistance to theory is in fact a resistance to reading” (de Man 343). In this context, de Man more specifically means reading the text in terms of theory and for the scientific forms of linguistics, which in turn demonstrates the resistance of theory to application. De Man demonstrates this difficulty in an example of Keats’ poem “The Fall of…

    • 1091 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Simply having music training has lead to different effects on brain activity and task performance when compared to those without music training. Therefore, this study aims to examine the effects of in-game music on performance outcomes while completing a tapping task. It has long been established that listening to music…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    3 Critical Analysis The writing style of the book might be hard to understand as the author have separated the historical background and his own point of view into two part, so that it might be not tight enough that let reader become confused. Also, the theme popular music have been separated by different kinds of music, but actually, different kinds of music actually somehow have relation to each others, and in this case, different type of songs become an individual thing that haven’t got relationship to each others. If the author can consider this problem, the theme will become more tight and the audience may not be confused to the theme. In the aspect of Popular Music and Politics, I really agree that Popular Music is not the only thing that we can only see as entertaining. A German sociologist T.W.…

    • 959 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dual Polymodality

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Composers and scholars have not agreed on what each term exactly means, and its scope. Perhaps as a result of its wide acceptance, the term polytonality lacks accuracy as a descriptive category. Béla Bartók’s explanation of both this terms, is one of the most radically different to the rest of composers and scholars. For him, the difference relies in the amount of tonal centers. While polytonality must have two or more tonal centers with identical or different scales, polymodality needs only one tonic and different modes, as he observes To point out the essential difference between atonality, polytonality, and polymodality in a final word on this subject, we may say that atonal music offers no fundamental tone at all, polytonality offers or is supposed to offer several of them, polymodality offers a single one.…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays