Analysis Of Dumbing Us Down By John Taylor Gatto

Improved Essays
Common Core: Standardizing Inadequacy
In John Taylor Gatto’s essay “Dumbing Us Down: Weapons Of Mass Instruction,” John argues that the current liberal state of the education system is in need of public reform and recognition. John explains that our current education system is structured to discourage self-discovery by cramming mind-numbing busy work down student’s throats, stifling creativity. John expounds the current education system is creating a quiet lower and middle class that keeps busy and helps capitalism maintains its influence by feeding the low wage labor pool, making big business possible. John warns that we must be vocal of our discontent with the system, and oppose anything that will bolster the systems current state. John’s
…show more content…
In these low-income areas, schools do not have the organizations like a Parent Teacher Association to raise money for basic and technological needs, which puts them at a disadvantage because schools with adequate funding have access to programs and technology that can further and broaden the students capability and understanding. How then, can we expect these students to perform on the same playing field as students with unlimited resources at their fingertips? If one student has access to a graphing calculator at home, and the other does not, the student without a calculator is disadvantaged greatly. Not only is the student who has the calculator capable of working at home he is more than likely encouraged to do so. The flip side of this situation is that a student from the low-income area may be more encouraged to find work and help supplement the family’s income and help provide necessities. Students cannot perform well in an environment where teachers expect them to complete coursework outside of school, but are also expected by their guardians to be employed outside of school. This system, Common Core, would force these students to become overworked and overwhelmed. It is not capable of catering to low-income schools, and would further increase the achievement …show more content…
This situation is known as the achievement gap. The United States government forces state governments to adopt this education system, or the state would lose government funding for education all together. As a result, low-income areas with lacking funds have little to no choice but to adopt this system or lose government funding all together. As previously mentioned, students in low income areas may not prioritize their schooling and fall behind, which might lead them to believe themselves incapable of completing and comprehending their schoolwork, will feel less driven to try to do so. This would widen the achievement gap even further, making Common Core

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Small Class Size Classes

    • 1423 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The benefits have shown to not only aid children, but teachers as well. Material covered is greatly impacted by the size of the class. Children need to be learning as much as they can in the first few years of school, and this is not possible in an overcrowded classroom. The cost may be considerable to reduce class size, but will only positively impact the future of the United States. Ignorance and poor education is not worth saving the money it costs to reduce classroom size.…

    • 1423 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    are jobless. There are many reasons for this; they’re not educated because they were in the same situation at this age because many problems they loss their jobs so they cant pay for there children schools so there child have to work in order to learn. The other problem is students from higher income families have better resource and better education. Students that come from higher income families may have access to more and better resource than students from lower income families. For example students from high-class families probably have more access to good educational tools such as books and supplies.…

    • 1280 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Homeschooled education versus Public education It wouldn’t be an exaggeration to say that public education in the United States is a serious problem that keeps getting worse. It’ no surprise that public school system in a decline and more parents doubt the effectiveness of public schools by switching their children to homeschooling. Advocates of traditional public school system claim that public school is a best place for a child to get knowledge, thrive and better prepare for adult life. Opponents of public schools suggest that every child is unique and try to stay away from government authoritarianism in education. It might be a rationale in both cases, but parents should have rights to educate their children at home because of better academic…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, rather than alter the reality of a weakened system, the author suggests the institution “is obsolete and should be abolished” (Botsein). Hence, as the essay provides a commentary on the broader societal implications that plague the established system, the argument emphasizes the necessity of exposing students to vocational skills to prepare them for the progressing modern culture. Further, in the early nineteenth century, the academic system was implemented by secondary schools to provide a broad liberal education to students despite economic uncertainty. In an essay discussing the disadvantages of a private education, author William Deresiewicz states, “As globalization sharpens economic insecurity, we are increasingly committing ourselves-as students, as parents, as a society-to a vast apparatus of educational advantage” (Deresiewicz). The author proceeds to suggest that rather than strive towards attaining an education from a private institution that “measures [intelligence] and academic achievement [as] measures of value in some moral or metaphysical sense,” students should seek a career; hence, as the nation rapidly progresses towards technological advances, the academics may be altered to provide students exposure to vocations beyond the…

    • 1023 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We think that teachers have a huge impact on the economy, through teaching students. If teachers are not motivated to be good at their profession, what is going to happen to the students? The result of that is students are coming out of school with a lack of education. Teachers that are motivated will not give up on a single student, they will help students understand the course and the material. We think that since teachers with low salaries do not try as much to teach students and it affects the state of the economy.…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    There are many reasons the public education system has started to fail. The largest reason begins with the parents. Encouragement from parents outside of class will make students more likely to want to succeed inside of class.. Secondly,…

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Penmanship Debate

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Schools have slowly weaned off of teaching cursive and grammar in schools leaving it up to parents to fill in any learning gaps that are created from this. Families in higher socioeconomic statuses have access to resources outside of school allowing students to improve their learning and fill in any gaps in their education. However, students whose families are lower in socioeconomic status, lack the materials to improve their education creating a larger achievement gap. Thanks to The Common Core State Standards, the achievement gap is widening, making it more difficult for students to catch up once they are…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Students need to have classes that make them feel excited to learn something, instead of coming to a boring, uninteresting, class. Students can be failing because they don’t have access to some things they need that the schools aren’t able to provide. Now schools are preparing students by turning in essays or even…

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Improving Education

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The revenue for each school district is different because different areas have varying socioeconomic statuses, so that districts with lower property values have significantly lower tax dollars being put into the schools (Reyes & Rodriguez, p. 114). Because of this inequality, schools with less revenue are not able to get the resources that could potentially be used to decrease the learning gap. Also, what goes on at home is something schools cannot prevent. How people parent and the resources parents have to keep their child well, account for much of the reasons a gap was started and continues. We need to hold parents accountable for their children’s…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Parents buying school uniforms would be a waste of their money because it isn’t something you actually want to wear it would be something they would be forcing you to wear which makes you not want to wear it more. You would most likely have to buy new uniforms each year because you could grow from last year or they could change the color or just do something different about it. The school would basically just be making you buy something you would wear for a year or maybe…

    • 1897 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays