Analysis Of Dumbing Us Down By John Taylor Gatto

Improved Essays
Common Core: Standardizing Inadequacy
In John Taylor Gatto’s essay “Dumbing Us Down: Weapons Of Mass Instruction,” John argues that the current liberal state of the education system is in need of public reform and recognition. John explains that our current education system is structured to discourage self-discovery by cramming mind-numbing busy work down student’s throats, stifling creativity. John expounds the current education system is creating a quiet lower and middle class that keeps busy and helps capitalism maintains its influence by feeding the low wage labor pool, making big business possible. John warns that we must be vocal of our discontent with the system, and oppose anything that will bolster the systems current state. John’s
…show more content…
In these low-income areas, schools do not have the organizations like a Parent Teacher Association to raise money for basic and technological needs, which puts them at a disadvantage because schools with adequate funding have access to programs and technology that can further and broaden the students capability and understanding. How then, can we expect these students to perform on the same playing field as students with unlimited resources at their fingertips? If one student has access to a graphing calculator at home, and the other does not, the student without a calculator is disadvantaged greatly. Not only is the student who has the calculator capable of working at home he is more than likely encouraged to do so. The flip side of this situation is that a student from the low-income area may be more encouraged to find work and help supplement the family’s income and help provide necessities. Students cannot perform well in an environment where teachers expect them to complete coursework outside of school, but are also expected by their guardians to be employed outside of school. This system, Common Core, would force these students to become overworked and overwhelmed. It is not capable of catering to low-income schools, and would further increase the achievement …show more content…
This situation is known as the achievement gap. The United States government forces state governments to adopt this education system, or the state would lose government funding for education all together. As a result, low-income areas with lacking funds have little to no choice but to adopt this system or lose government funding all together. As previously mentioned, students in low income areas may not prioritize their schooling and fall behind, which might lead them to believe themselves incapable of completing and comprehending their schoolwork, will feel less driven to try to do so. This would widen the achievement gap even further, making Common Core

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In James Loewen’s excerpt “The Land of Opportunity “the author discusses middle-class students not knowing anything about how class structure works or how it is changed over time (Loewen 201). In “Do Schools Kill Creativity,” Sir Kenneth Robinson discusses how we are all born with natural capacities for creativity and the systems of mass education tend to suppress them (). That the present education system we now implement is not the failsafe system we think it is. Both narratives tried to explain the failings of the education system, by not going in depth on any given subject, and showing America in the best light. Both Loewen and Robinson decry the broad view of American’s education system failing students that are being taught today.…

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his 1998 article, “The Liberal Arts in an Age of Info-Glut”, Todd Gitlin advocates for an increase in liberal arts education to give students the opportunity to learn more about humanity and understand society better. Gitlin uses rhetorical questions and repetition to emphasize the points in his argument and uses contrast to highlight the differences of the common concerns of humans. By describing how liberal arts should be taught, he informs the younger generation about what they are missing out on in regards to humanity. Through these strategies Gitlin reveals how liberal arts will help his audience become more educated. Using repetition, Gitlin emphasizes the need for more exposure to the liberal arts throughout his essay.…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the conventional American ideology, all people have an equal opportunity to pursue and invest in their personal aspirations. To some, success in these endeavors is only perceivable through a learned and educated mind; others, however, argue that college is no longer worth its expense, whereas work has an immediate reward and payoff. Sanford J. Ungar and Robert Reich explore both of these subjective values in their essays “The New Liberal Arts” and “College is a Ludicrous Waste of Money.” Ungar discusses why a liberal arts education should be pursued; doing so by introducing common misconceptions about liberal arts and, using argumentative persuasion, proves their insignificance. On the other hand, Reich argues against the conventional belief…

    • 1424 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Education in schools has long been a heated topic, especially in regards to what its purpose is. On one hand, some, such as the ACSD Committee, argue that education’s purpose is “to provide for the fullest possible development of each learner for living morally, creatively, and productively in a democratic society.” However, others identify a far more critical purpose of education, such as that of Jean Anyon. Anyon theorizes in her article “Social Class and the Hidden Curriculum of Work,” that the function of our educational systems is to uphold the structure of today’s society that keeps the working class majority oppressed and its top 1% superior to the working class through the way the curriculum is taught. As someone who has been in school…

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    First, Let Teenagers Have a Fair Shot at Adolescence Across the hypercritical and interconnected global society that exists today, a multitude of notions and opinions constantly stream from every source imaginable; however, Leon Botstein’s analysis of education in America stands out among the most profound. Bluntly writing in a piece entitled Let Teenagers Try Adulthood, Botstein proposes, “the American high school is obsolete and should be abolished” (153). This provocative nature of Botstein’s writing leads to polarized views of the education system that could ultimately result in alienation of individuals or groups with more moderate views. That is not to say Botstein lacks valid points.…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Growing up this quote by Malcom X sets the tone for my attitude towards education. “Education is the passport to the future, for tomorrow belongs to those who prepare for it today.” In today’s world, a higher education is the cornerstone of life. Regarding the debate of a liberal education over the years, I concur with Shorris and his points in “On the Uses of a Liberal Education as a Weapon in the Hands of the Restless Poor” and want to qualify with Edmundson’s points in “On the Uses of a Liberal Education as Lite Entertainment for Bored College Students”. Edmundson used to think that a liberal education was beneficial for everyone and was originally for self-betterment.…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ruth Rosa Ms. Dolson ENWR 105 5 October 2014 From a Consumer to a Student Mark Edmundson, author of On The Use of Liberal Education, easily criticizes the culture of education. Education is really important to many students. One goes to college to receive a degree on what they studied so that they can have a decent job. Edmundson’s article explains how universities, students and teachers focus less on education and concentrate more on a consumerist society. Edmundson focuses on the change of education; how colleges and students don’t focus on education.…

    • 1544 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Neal McCluskey the associate director of the Cato Institute’s Center for Educational Freedom author of Common Core Treats Students Like Soulless Widgets “They learn different things at different rates, and have myriad talents and goals. Yet Common Core, by its very nature, moves all kids largely in lock-step, processing them like soulless widgets.” They need to be taught life skills that they will need after the graduate from high school such as check writing, signing in cursive, and simple adding and subtracting. All things lost or eliminated with these core…

    • 1822 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In America, an education is no longer considered to be an option but in fact, a necessity. Many are raised to believe in order to ensure a successful future, education is a key component. In fact, there are others who believe that the educations systems we have in place today, actually does more bad than good. There have been many movements that had an idea to insure that students are properly educated and all receive the same form of education but, the institution of these movements may have caused more damage and simply relied on the forcing of educators to produce a group of workers who are unable to consciously think for themselves. Although there is no way of making sure that the potential of a student is fully developed, possible solutions…

    • 1720 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    International Legal Lessons on Closing the Achievement Gap” , the Common Core State Standards are explained as an enhancement in the U.S. education system, which overtime, will provide growth and stability in the nations economy. Frye then goes into details regarding America’s educational rank among other nations and how America is settling for mediocre learning in the classrooms. Next, Frye investigates the pros and cons of the Common Core Standards and defends allegations against the CCSS. Second, Frye analyzes other nation’s education systems and compares them to the United States.…

    • 1652 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Schools in the United States use standardized tests to evaluate the students' in elementary, middle and high school. These tests are also used for entrance into college or even to find out if a student needs to take a particular class over in college. To enter into college, a student usually will take the SAT or the ACT Exams and usually there is a fee for taking these exams. In Indiana, the students' take the ISTEP + Exam.…

    • 1780 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Poverty In Public Schools

    • 485 Words
    • 2 Pages

    If the school and the teacher does not have the right materials to teach the subject to the student then it become difficult when testing comes. Thus, poverty-stricken public schools do not tend to do well when it comes to testing, since they have limited resources. Students in school do not have the resources to be able to receive an education where they can do well on standardize testing. In public schools that are-stricken with poverty, they do not have enough textbooks for students to take home. Which means that students cannot have their own textbook to study from and write in notes to help them.…

    • 485 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Yet literacy rates before then, before compulsory public schooling, are estimated to be around 90% to 98%. Men such as Abraham Lincoln, Samuel Langhorne Clemens (Mark Twain), and Frederick Douglass were able to educate themselves and move on to contribute greatly to society without the benefit of public education in any form, as did most Americans in that era(Sowell, Inside 18-24,27). In fact, in many countries today, countries such as Switzerland, where it is estimated that only 23% of its citizens attend public high school, have the highest income per capita in the world and more scholarly individuals in comparison to other countries. This is generally attributed to the lack of public education (Murray Real 33,34). The same show similar literacy rates to that of early America, where little was available in the way of public…

    • 3345 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Education is essential in modern day society in view of the fact it gives an individual enlightenment and knowledge. It helps people find truth of their general surroundings alongside with the concepts of morality. In “Learning To Read” by Malcolm X, he discusses a narrative of his path to self-education through the remembrance of moments in his life while being incarcerated. His motivation arises from wanting to interact with Mr. Elijah Muhammad; the leader of Islam. Through self- education, he discovers the tensions in race relations and the unfair treatments that African Americans endure in the hands of the mainstream American society.…

    • 1115 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lower-income neighborhoods struggle with maintaining adequate facilities, up to date books and technology. Because taxable wealth such as, property or income, is lower in high poverty districts, poor districts will always raise fewer education dollars than wealthier ones. (Baker, Brian). To compensate for inequality, states’ schools funding formulas try to distribute more money to low-income districts but this is not always the case. (Frolich).…

    • 742 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays