Analysis Of Benjamin R. Barber's Excerpt From 'America Skis School'

Superior Essays
Many adults today are exhilarated when their child graduates from high school and gets accepted into college. Former reporter and critic, William A. Henry III, has a very different outlook on colleges. William A. Henry III argues that within the concept of egalitarianism, we as The United States of America, have lowered the standards and have accepted too many “mediocres” into college. From Henry’s knowledge not everyone is ready for college. William Henry believes that if we cut the amount of students that get into college in half then it would be even harder for students to be accepted to college, decreasing the amount of colleges throughout the world. Benjamin R. Barber is the author of “Excerpt from ‘America Skips School,’” in which he …show more content…
Henry’s proposition, it only seems right to let the most savvy people go to college and no social political reasoning. After reading Benjamin R. Barber “Excerpt from ‘America Skips School’” you see the social political context that states that the education has to fit the society. When looking at Barber’s views you can see that if you were to cut the amount of students being accepted into college you are undoubtedly hurting the future of the American democracy. In the beginning of Benjamin R. Barber’s argument he exposes the hypocrisy of the older generation directed towards the younger generation. According to Barber the generation that Henry belongs to is full of an abundant amount of hypocrisy. The older generation that seems to criticize the younger generation are simply hypocrites because they are failing to realize that the children are just mimicking the things that they see the older generation do. In the middle of Barber’s article he gives a quiz to a group of forty-seven year olds and a group of seventeen year olds. His primary group was the forty-seven year olds, he was trying to prove the older generation really does know today’s pop culture as much as the younger generation does. According to Benjamin R. Barber, “our kids spend 900 hours a year in school and from 1,200 to 1,800 hours a year in front of the television set (336).” With this statistical fact it shows that children learn so much from the television. While Barber reveals …show more content…
There are many people that will blame the students. According to Benjamin Barber, “others turn on the kids themselves, so that at the same moment as we are transferring our responsibilities to the shoulders of the next generation, we are blaming them for our own generation’s most conspicuous failures (335).” Barber does not say that he thinks everyone should go to college but he does believe that everyone that aspires to further their education after high school should have the opportunity to attend college. Although many students only go to college to make more money they actually still learn important skills like critical thinking. The younger generation feeds off of the older generation. When the younger children see that the older generation does not actually care that much about education then they think that they are obligated to believe that education is not very important; even though education is among one of the most important things to have. According to Barber, “we have been nominally democratic for so long that we presume it is our natural condition rather that the product of persistent effort and tenacious responsibility (340).” Barber also states that, “we have decoupled rights from civic responsibilities and severed citizenship from education on the false assumption that citizens just happen (340).” While Henry

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Society has established the idea that everyone can be compared equally based on the higher education obtained. Parents send their children to college with the belief that the outcome will result in a mass amount of money. Unfortunately, according to Bird, college is “the dumbest investment” a student can make “if money is the only goal” (336). Indeed, if money is the only motivation, striving to obtain a higher education is not the best decision for a high school graduate. Bird states that going to college does not guarantee that the college graduate will get a high paying job.…

    • 1194 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If the federal government subsidized everyone’s college education, we (college students) would lose our scholarships that we worked hard for. The federal government would also end up losing. For the main reason that almost everyone is going to want to attend college; just for the heck of it. These people will only be taking up space, time and money from the federal government. The final reason, as to why college should not be free is A free college tuition sounds nice at first, but when you look into it and gather information it doesn’t sound all that nice.…

    • 373 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Given the best of all possible worlds, I would make a few changes. I would place emphasis on increasing the amount of funding that goes into programs like Pell Grants, that purely and simply award funds to students who really cannot afford full tuition”(Vest). The college tuition is a big problem because some students can not afford college. The college tuition is increasing slowly, but their are people who are supporting for more financial help from the Federal government, yet people claim to say that the Federal Government and the Congressional leaders are the ones to blame for the increase of the college cost and tuition making it very difficult for families to send their kids to college. There are a lot of financial help but only so much…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “If higher education at public schools becomes free, it might appear to devalue a college diploma. It might also lead to students cutting more classes or not trying because they don’t have to “get their money’s worth” when they aren’t paying for anything. The current price of college drives students to complete their schooling as quickly as possible so as to reduce debt. Without that financial drive, we might see more laziness and lackadaisical behavior from our students” (College Raptor). College would just be like high school everyone would go through it to be able to at least get a job.…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many students feel like some of the classes they must take will not get them jobs that will help them pay back their student loans. No matter how much Sanders might think he is going to help by offering free tuition, some students will take that and get to college and not do their work. As far as community college, many of my students told me that if it were free it would attract slackers who would not be serious about their education and cause problems in the classroom (Giordano). Sanders would have Hillary Clinton look over all his positions. Also, Sanders revived socialism from history because of anger towards Wall Street.…

    • 897 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Students are paying more to go to school and are ending up learning less after graduation. With all the college prices rising, less and less people are able to attend college. “In recent years, students have been paying more to attend college and earning less upon graduation – trends that have led many observers to question whether a college education remains a good investment” (Karageorge). If the price of college continues to increase, the value of a college degree will decrease, because there will be less people attending college. According to Richard Vedder, who wrote “Going Broke by Degree: Why College Costs too Much”, the current system of financing for college is extremely negative.…

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Summary In the essay “The Uneducated American”, Paul Krugman develops an argument dealing with college education in America. His main point is that Americans need a college education which is essential in American’s society. Krugman’s position on college education is clear and he is supporting college education. However, college education is slowly decreasing over the years: “In fact, we have a college graduation rate that’s slightly below average across all advanced economies” (126). Americans are not attending college and getting a degree and this is leading to problems concerning money: “But these days young Americans are considerably less likely than young people in many other countries to graduate from college” (126).…

    • 868 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the United States of America today there seems to be this expectation that one must go to college or they are considered unsuccessful and looked down upon. There are numerous reasons I believe college is not for everyone. Every person is unique, school may not be there thing, and in my opinion, there is nothing wrong with a person going directly into the work force after high school. Also college degrees are becoming worth less and less as more people attend college and end up in careers that have nothing to do with their degree or dropping out which is ultimately wasting their own and the government’s money. A majority of kids chose to go away to college for the “social aspect” so they say, which we know just means partying and drinking.…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some people think if students can not doing well in college, why should we let them go to college? Why not go to vocational school instead of college ? Dale Stephens describe in her article “ College is Waste of Time”, she claims, “College fails to empower to with the skills necessary to become produce members of today’s global entrepreneurial economy” (38). Also, they think college can be replaced and that social experience is more important than college experience. Marty Nemko in the article “ We Spend Too Many Students To College”, she points out “if you graduated in the bottom 40 percent of your high school class and went to college, 76 of 100 won’t earn a diploma, even if given 8 1/2 years.…

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To emphasize her views Bird shares her research which shows that not all students belong in college. In her research there is evidence that once students are in college they become depressed, not all students are entering college for a higher education, and the belief that all students will benefit from college is untrue. For these reasons, Bird strongly believes that college is not worth the risk of being unhappy and in debt. Another key point that bird focuses on is the fact that Americans today are more concerned with their job than the pay, they desire a psychic income. Overall Bird is against students believing that everyone is fit for college and they have to go to college to have a decent…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays