Battle At Nueces: A Brief Analysis

Improved Essays
Following the discussion on the league, McGowen proceeds to describe Brig. Den. Hamilton P. Bee appointment of Capt. James M. Duff to combat the open rebellion in the area around Fredericksburg, Texas. He provides a detailed sequence of events that occurred during the “Battle at Nueces” and the actions performed by Lt. McRae’s, Lt. Homsely’s, Tegener and his German Unionist, and Lt. Edward Lilly (Luck). Throughout his narrative, he debunks the myths and falsehoods perpetuated by authors, Bigger, Lonn, and Fehrenbach. They claim Duff “ordered the wounded prisoners killed and participated in the executions of the captured Unionist” along the Mexican border in October 1862 when facts prove that Duff was not present during any of these …show more content…
During the referendum, Cooke County voted 221 to 137 against secession. Most citizens of the county accepted the results of the referendum. However, tensions aroused when the Confederate Congress passed the Conscription laws exempting certain slaveholders and overseers from service. Unionist feared “they might be forced to die for a cause they did not believe in while some slaveholders would not even have to fear the draft.” Smallwood argues that due to the continuing controversy over the “Great Hanging at Gainesville,” a re-examination is required. The controversy stems from the differing accounts (published and unpublished) of those participating in the events leading up to the “citizens court,” and the actions carried out by vigilante mob or citizens’ group. Smallwood utilizes memoirs from key individuals who published accounts of the events occurring before, during, and after the hangings. The primary research material includes a juror of the “citizens court” Thomas Barrett, and George Washington Diamond. Secondary research material comes from town citizens Joe T. Roff, Lillian Gunter, J. E. Wheeler, Fern Suydam, and relative of one victim, L.D. Clark. John Diamond and other participants who “assisted in arresting members of the Union League” requested George (brother of John) “to write an account of the affair and was given all records pertaining to the …show more content…
One of the foremost scholars who adds to the historiography on this subject is Richard B. McCaslin. His book, Tainted Breeze: The Great Hanging at Gainesville, Texas 1862, presents a more detailed analysis than those introduced by Smallwood’s article. His research material utilizes the primary works identified by Smallwood, above. Plus, he analyzes editorials and the census and land records of the victims and their executioners. He provides a background history that cultivated an atmosphere of hysteria among the slaveholders in the area. Providing the political and social status of the victims, the jurors on the “citizens court,” and the vigilantes. McCaslin asserts that repercussions continued to affect the counties and Texas well after the event and the end of the Civil

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Giavanna Hunt Mrs. Schools APUSH 18 December 2017 Antietam Book Review Crossroads of Freedom: Antietam by James McPherson September 17, 1862 is remembered as the bloodiest day in American history. On this fateful day during the American Civil War, Union and Confederate soldiers clashed in Sharpsburg, Maryland along the Antietam Creek. In total, approximately 23,000 American lives were lost on this gory day, including 12,400 Union soldiers and 10,300 Confederate soldiers. Although the Union claimed this battle as their victory, the Americans on both sides suffered great losses that changed the course of the Civil War and altered American history. In choosing to read this book, I knew that I would gain a greater understanding of the military strategies and actions performed by both the Rebels and the Yankees.…

    • 1110 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Civil War was a devastating war that wiped out much of America’s population. The book written by James M. McPherson, What They Fought For 1861-1865, describes the views of the soldiers that fought in the war. McPherson uses letters left behind written by different civil war soldiers to portray a more round view of actions that took place on the battlegrounds. McPherson’s thesis does not present from both sides of the war what the soldiers, volunteers and enlisted men, of the Civil War had to faced, how they dealt with their emotions and experiences, the bond made between comrades, and how it affect their overall psychological, physical, and mental well-being of each combatant. This book contains diary entries from Union soldiers that were from the northern states.…

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the book “Apostles of Disunion,” by Charles B. Dew, we are presented with ideas of secession, slavery and racism. The overall goal in this book was to prove the causes of the Civil War. We are given experiences and background from southerner, Charles B. Dew in order to justify the underlying reason for the cause of the War. During this time period of 1860-1861 there was a lot of talk as to what the real cause of the Civil War was, in which there have been many theories and hypothesis’ from historians as to what was the true reasoning was behind it all. Being a southerner, Dew is passionate about his facts, and researches to better support his argument.…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Civil War was the darkest and bloodiest period in American history with 620,000 lives lost. After it’s end America needed a period of rebuilding, Reconstruction. Reconstruction lasted throughout the U.S. from 1865 to 1877. Who, the North or South, put an end to America’s reassembly in 1877? The South killed Reconstruction through violent, political, and social conflicts.…

    • 376 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1866, one year following the civil war, Memphis broke out suddenly and dramatically with a three-day outbreak of racial violence. This included the whites rioting through neighborhoods that consisted of black people. Forty-six freed people were murdered by the moment the fires destroying black churches and schools had been put out. Congress was irate at the fact white opposition in the conquered South initiated what was called the Radical Reconstruction. This was a policy put in place to safeguard the freedom of the region’s blacks.…

    • 843 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the book “Midnight Rising: John Brown and the Raid That Sparked the Civil War” written by Tony Horwitz who is one of New York Times bestsellers. Horwitz began his profession as a newspaper reporter and issued many stories that dealt with conflict and working circumstances in America for The Wall Street Journal. Yet, throughout the book the author writes about an abolitionist named John Brown who has greatly impacted the start of the Civil War through a diversity of raids. Horwitz’s thesis is that Brown had ignited the nation’s extensive rivalry specifically with the implausible attack on Harpers Ferry.…

    • 844 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    John Brown’s Raid on Harpers Ferry was marked as one of the most important event that happen in the United States’ history. The event lead to the most memorable war of all time, the Civil War. In a book by Jonathan Earle, “John Brown’s Raid on Harper Ferry,” tells the story of John Brown and his journey from birth to his trial. Throughout history, many historians wonder if what Brown did was a correct decision. Is he a murderer?…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    James McPherson’s What They Fought For shows readers an inside look of what Civil War soldiers experienced on the frontline. McPherson does this by using diary and handwritten letters soldiers would send home. “The principle sources for that book, and this one, are the personal letters and diaries written by soldiers during their war experience.” (1).…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The essay, “Long-Legged Yankee Lies” was a surprising essay – not what I expected to read after reading James M. McPherson’s other works. The focus of this essay was to thoroughly explain one of the main interpretations of the Civil War – the “South’s Lost Cause.” The Lost Cause, as the Southerners perceived themselves after the Civil War, is explained in that the South was incredibly outnumbered by the North in both men and resources. The South perceived themselves as righteous men who fought for state’s rights, freedoms granted by the Constitution that cannot legally be infringed upon by the government, and the approval of the people with actions taken against them by their government.…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Midnight Rising Analysis

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Midnight Rising: John Brown and the raid that sparked the Civil War is written by Tony Horwitz: a bestselling author and journalist who has taken the time to tell an essential American story. The book covers the events surrounding the raid on Harpers Ferry and the complex character of John Brown. Horwitz thesis explains that the raid on Harpers Ferry is the spark that lit the fire of secession and Civil War. John Brown grew as a descendent of Puritans and soldiers from the Revolutionary War, and his upbringing created his “burning hatred of racial oppression” (Horwitz, p.16) and “determination to help slaves” (Horwitz, p.19). He believed that the dissipation of slavery would fulfill America’s founding principles, so he began to lead raids…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    President Abraham Lincoln flirtation with African- American Civil Rights, John Wilkes Booths undying love for the confederacy, and the ultimate fall of the Confederate army. Independently, each of these points hold little weight of importance, but together these three points created a fire storm lasting close to six years, costing more than 620,000 Americans lives, and two faiths’ that will ultimately be entwined with each in the history book. A collision of two people that will be forever attach with each other in the history book a faith where you can’t talk about one without talking about the other. In this essay, we will discuss each of these points; Booth passion toward the Confederacy, the fall of the Confederate army, and Lincoln wanting…

    • 381 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the summer of 1917, British forces launched a strategic offensive campaign near the town of Ypres, Belgium, against the German Army resulting in approximately 200,000 dead German Soldiers, and nearly 300,000 dead British Soldiers. The British aimed to relieve the worn-out French forces already in place, and then take possession of the areas above the plain of Flanders, mainly the city of Passchendaele and its surrounding areas. The result was a sound beating of the British forces by the German forces, with the British having to be bailed out by other Allied Forces, largely French and Canadian, in order to even come close to achieving the original objective. This was the third battle of Ypres, officially known as the Battle of Passchendaele…

    • 2279 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    What led to the American Civil War is a topic of debate which lacks a simple answer. There is heated debate whether the war was fought for emancipation or to preserve the Union. Historians can advocate for either argument since both sides have ample evidence to support their respective standpoint. Both Hollywood and scholarship agree that the Civil War is a war to preserve the Union. While the issue of slavery was a massive factor in the war, it was not the defining factor.…

    • 1806 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Civil War Perspectives

    • 1870 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The Civil War was a pivotal moment in the United States’s history being a high point in a sectional discord that’s affects have continued to be evident in several issues in today’s society. As most wars, there’s at least two decidedly divided and biased sides to the story. With two perspectives coming from one country America had to decide how they wanted to remember this war. Being such a complex dispute with two very distinct viewpoints, each side had their personal view on the reasons for the war, the events throughout the war, and the effectiveness of reconstruction. Through extensive measures by multiple people, each side go their story out and shaped how others viewed the war decades after the fact, no matter how contrasting these memories…

    • 1870 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Battle of Gettysburg is perhaps the most famous battle ever to be fought on American soil. The three-day long struggle, which saw intense fighting that pitted friend against friend and brother against brother, holds a special place in the American psyche. In the span of three days in July of 1863 the entire tone of the American Civil changed from certain confederate victory, to an impending federal rout. What happened over this time span that caused the sudden shift in momentum during the civil war?…

    • 1612 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays