Analysis Of Assimilation, American Style By Peter Salins

Improved Essays
In “Assimilation, American Style” Peter Salins distinguishes the differences between what assimilation genuinely means vs. the unreliable metaphorical meaning of “the melting pot". To give people an idea of the definition of “Assimilation, American Style," the term “the melting pot”: a society where many different types of people blend together as one. America being one of those countries that is often viewed as a melting pot, because in terms of ethnicities, religion, and different cultures, America is made up of many different types of people. America is viewed as a melting pot because even with all the various types of people, everyone has managed to come together in unity. "The melting pot" has been used on behalf of assimilation in America …show more content…
Salins argues that assimilation is a huge part in the success of American culture, and to end it would only demolish the basis of the mutual benefits within the government and communities made up of immigrants and natives, and Salins' believes that this would also lead to an ending of the American culture all in all. Salins claims that the persistent growth in the immigrant population that have been Americanized, while still holding on to their previous cultural history, has advanced the country and because of this Salins feels that the use of metaphors like "the melting pot," fail the meaning and purpose of what assimilation in America really does or means. As mentioned in the article, "The greatest failing of the melting pot metaphor is that it overreaches." Salins believes that the melting pot defeats assimilation because the melting pot is more about being able to differentiate non- native folks from the indigenous. Moreover, the melting pot term is also about being able to distinguish those of different cultures and natives, then trying to change them for example, a pack of skittles with a variety of colors, being forced to assimilate to all becoming only red skittles. This change is meant forcibly, which is the total opposite of assimilation in America. In America the skittles would only have to assimilate if they want to. In the article, Salins states "Assimilation, if it is to succeed, must be a voluntary process..." Salins argues that assimilation is more of a choice then being an involuntary choice or an obligation and the metaphors fails to describe the purposes of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Assimilating the Natives in the U.S. and Australia The reading Assimilating the Natives in the U.S. and Australia written by Gary Foley in June 2000 interrogates, from an indigenous perspective, the suggestion that Assimilation means different things to Australian and United States governments. In Order to do so Foley examines colonial origins, notions of race and white supremacist mythology. Foley looks at how each of these perceptions resulted in the treatment of indigenous people and draws conclusions on whether there is a difference in the intent of assimilation as well as exploits some possible long term implications in today’s society. ‘Origins of American and Australian colonies have a common European heritage of imperialism and racial…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Without farther study, or evidence, readers should not be made to believe that most people associate the word “assimilation” with the year 1950, whose ideals are sixty-six years old. Jacoby (2004) makes her opinion on assimilation clear when she states, “As for the melting pot, if anything, that seems even more threatening: who wants to be melted down, after all- for the sake of national unity or anything else?” (p. 423). This quotation creates the feeling that individualism is far more important than the unity of the country to the author. Although individualism is an extremely important concept, it is crucial to have national unity in a country as large as the Unites States.…

    • 749 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Roger Daniels, in his novel, “Not Like Us: Immigrants and Minorities in America”, highlights the terrible conditions and undertakings immigrants and minorities had to face through early to modern America. He presents his argument through different people, starting with the Chinese and Chinese Exclusion Act during the industrial era and going on into detail with the treatment Native Americans, African Americans, and other minorities throughout time. He states in his thesis that he simply wishes not to “negate or minimize other aspects of that turbulent and dramatic period.”, but instead to emphasize the side of history that is usually glossed over by historians. He does successfully in context highlight the true reality minorities and immigrants faced throughout this specific time period, and while he does have a compelling argument and evidence to back it up, there are some minor critiques in an otherwise beautifully constructed novel.…

    • 641 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Speculating about causes can be interesting assignments to complete. This type of essay demands a structured format and thinking process. The essay I choose to write about, “Hispanic Pride vs. American Assimilation” by Stephanie Cox talks about an issue that is growing among Hispanic immigrants to choose not to learn English. Cox wants to learn and know more about the subject before she judges the decision. Why are they not making an effort to learn to speak English like all other immigrants do?…

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Immigrants In The 1920's

    • 1047 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In 1915 Woodrow Wilson Spoke about the great melting pot of America; “Where men of every race and origin ought to send their children, where being mixed together, they are all infused with the American Spirit”. In the early 20th century most of the ‘True’ Americans where in fact the 2nd or 3rd generation of European immigrants who came to the United States for a new start, A better life. However this ‘Open door’ policy America had dramatically changed seeing a lot of hostility build up towards what where known as ‘new’ immigrants especially throughout the 1920s and 1930s.…

    • 1047 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Race In The 1890s Essay

    • 595 Words
    • 3 Pages

    For decades this country had been referred to a melting pot because of the vast array of different cultures, customs, and ethnic groups; and the 1890s to 1920 is when most of that…

    • 595 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    David Cole in “Five Myths about Immigration” simply takes about the five common myths of immigration in the United States. The five myths being that immigrants are overrunning the country, immigrants take jobs from natural born citizens, immigrants drain societies resources, aliens and immigrants don’t assimilate to our culture, and immigrants are not entitled to constitutional rights. All of these myths are displayed to be completely wrong and were created out of ignorance fueled by fear/lack of education on the many benefits immigrants have on United States society, economy, culture, and unity of our nation. Immigrants do not and are not overrunning the country in fact first-generation immigrants make up only had made up in 1990 only made…

    • 1093 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    America is often described as melting pot. However, I believe America is better described as a mosaic with the different people and different cultures meshing together but still maintaining their distinctness. Each group that makes up America has their own story to tell. Within the social foundations of American education, there is the plight of African Americans fighting to end the racial segregation of schools; Native Americans pushing back against the efforts to assimilate them, Catholics who fear that Protestant dominated schools will threaten the religious beliefs of their children and women who wish to be seen more than domestic servants. There are also socioeconomic factors involved that hinder the educational obtainment of children…

    • 2381 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Un-Affordable Health Care Plan The Affordable Care Act is a universally mandated act that allows for every citizen of the United States to obtain healthcare at a low and affordable price (Obamacare Facts). It was created mainly to help the lower class and those who could not afford the kind of health care available at that time. This can seem to be a great way to boost the unfortunate; but with it comes the countless disadvantages and unmoral regulations. The unconstitutional values of Obama’s Affordable Care Act infringes on basic human rights written in the U.S Constitution, and forces taxpayers to pay for the inhumane procedure that leaves around 1.5 million people dead each year (CDC). America is, and always has been known as the melting pot (Joyce Millet).…

    • 1170 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In order to put some of these bias’ to rest, more research needs to be done. Studies and evidence needs to be present in order to help everyone feel comfortable with the ideas of foreign-born people coming to the United States. Educating others will be one of the key components in order to help with assimilating and get everyone on board in wanting to help make assimilating easier for New Americans. On top of educating everyone, I strongly encourage other students in the community to reach out and look for programs to see the resources available for New Americans.…

    • 149 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Assimilation means multiple groups become mixed by obtaining each other’s social and psychological characteristics, such as how waves of immigrants have been assimilated into the American culture. Richard Rodriguez, the writer of “Blaxican’s and Other Reinvented Americans” is telling the readers about mixing race in America and belongings of immigration. Cultural assimilation in Rodriguez’s view is the processes by groups of cultures that comes from different countries and speak different languages. Rodriguez points out that assimilation happened naturally over time.…

    • 1419 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    David Brooks, who is a successful journalist, columnist, and self - described “comic sociologist” at The New York Times, communicates the dilemma of diversification in his expository essay “People Like Us”. The writer thinks that people should encourage diversity to perceive and esteem each other 's different reflection. David Brooks demonstrates why all different kinds of humans are attracted to identical and similar races, ethnicities, religions, beliefs, political values, and classes in his essay based on typical examples surrounding us. Author’s convincible thoughts give interesting questions to readers include me, and it makes us reflecting and considering one more time with the necessity of diversity in not only America but also the global…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The idea of assimilation comes in when many Immigrants, children of immigrants and those with Hispanic background begin giving up their native tongue as their primary language to assimilate better to American culture. I have family members that have been living here in America for 30 plus years and barely know any English, many have trouble learning a new language and some just don’t care to even learn English. Like Arellano my primary language is English and my Spanish speaking skills have diminished over the years because of how rarely I use the…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Melting Pot

    • 969 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Since 1776, the United States of America (USA, US or America) has been a country of freedom and hope. Throughout the years, the United States has strived to be the most diverse and accepting country in the world. So it is no surprise that a common nickname for America is the “Melting Pot,” which was coined around 1908 by Israel Zangwill. This name was coined in an attempt to reassure newcomers that America would welcome them with opened arms. However, through the years the “melting pot” nickname became a burden of tolerance and approval that many Americans did not want to carry.…

    • 969 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Be American,” Carlos Bulosan reveals the lack of choice a Filipino had at the time through the story of someone’s cousin, Consorcio, and his struggle to gain citizenship in America. Bulosan’s short story shares this idea of no choice with a political cartoon known as “What Will He Do,” which depicts President McKinley deciding whether or not to keep the Philippines or “send them to Spain” while the globe watches for his decision. Through the visual of President McKinley making a decision for the Philippines, the political cartoon “What Will He Do,” argues the Philippines are deprived of choice. “Be American” mirrors this argument by linking the Consorcio and his cousin to the idea of lack of choice.…

    • 1274 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays