Michael Pollan Paradox Analysis

Great Essays
In the “American Paradox,” Michael Pollan confronts the “American Paradox: a notably unhealthy population preoccupied with nutrition and thee idea of eating healthy” (268). Americans are obsessed with the trend of healthy eating that they fail to see the unhealthy results it has on them. The unhealthy trend of “healthy diets” is a result of the rise of multi-billion dollar food-marketing business and the “shifting grounds of nutrition science” (268). Michael Pollan believes that Americans focus too much on the scientific aspect of food that they fail to concentrate on their own health and happiness. Americans have misconceptions on the way Americans eat because of the rise of nutrition science, flawed data on healthy eating, and the redefinition …show more content…
Belasco believes that food specialists are “useful to have around…since modern life is far too complex…” (300). The world is changing and growing at a faster pace making the simple task of eating food complex. The need for specialists in today’s world can be argued. In the past, specialists have made many assumptions on what is beneficial to human health and what is harmful to human health. For example, during World War II specialists have guaranteed that the first pesticide was safe to consume. Pollan states that major food businesses and nutritionists have managed to complicate the simple act of eating. Again, in today’s world people question why people need “investigative journalists to tell us where our food comes from…” or why we need “nutritionists to determine the dinner menu” the real reason is that there is no reason (300). I believe that there are some benefits to having nutritionists; however I do not think that specialists need to instruct people how to eat healthy for people have done it for a long time without the guidance of these “specialists” …show more content…
At home, my mother is the one in charge of the menu. My mother is from Seoul, Korea a nation where food is exotic and traditional. She has learned to prepare Korean meals from her mother. My mother left Korea with my father after they got married. In America, my mother stuck to her cooking and continued to prepare traditional Korean dishes such as kimbap (Korean sushi rolls) and kimchijiga (kimchi stew). Even to this day, my mother continues to prepare traditional Korean meals instead of low-fat diet influenced meals. As a child, my mother would always gather the family together and pray before every meal because it was a “ritual” we performed as a family.
In Marcel Danesis’ essay “Food as Myth” he supports Pollan’s idea of culture being the origins of eating food. In the past, families would eat together, but now with the ever popular “two-person, working household” the tradition of eating as a family has lost its value (323). In correlation, fast food companies such as Mcdonalds have been on the rise making meals with the family affordable and quick. Pollan believes that the way Americans eat today in comparison to the past is that Americans today fail to eat for the purpose of starting relationships and gaining happiness through these

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Part I Chapter 1: This chapter discusses how our food industry has changed of over the course of the years, and how we are now more concerned about nutrients than the foods we eat. He discusses how the science in our food has created food our ancestors wouldn’t recognize, and it is due to bad policies pushed by lobbyists. Chapter 2: This chapter discuss how trends in our nutrition are made up by scientists and journalist. He claims companies and marketers have done a great job pinning macro-nutrients against each other as one being…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Omnivore's Dilemma is a book which modified the way people looked at their food and also what they ate. In Chapter 8 “The Omnivore's Dilemma”, Michael Pollan explains that omnivores like the modern day American can eat just about anything, but the problem is that they are uncertain of what should be eaten. Americans obtain a variety of choices when in a supermarket, but do they recognize what is good for them? Michael Pollan also argues that the reason we experience so many diet fads is that Americans have no food culture to fall back on. So, according to Pollan, the omnivore's dilemma is that the modern-day American doesn't know what to eat because we have no food culture to fall back on.…

    • 478 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Escape from the Western Diet,” was an article written by Michael Pollan to inform Americans about the dangers of the western diet and believes that it would be beneficial to escape from it. In Mary Maxfield’s essay “Food as Thought: Resisting the Moralization of Eating” she talks about the important reason why people in America are overweight. She explains the mistakes that Americans make about how to…

    • 531 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Encumbered by highly advanced agricultural inventions, the American diet has evolved into a dilemma producing detrimental health affects for our nation. While a plethora of food choices, from chicken nuggets to Twinkies, may appear to be a dietary utopia; the technological advancements in the food industry have produced food-like products rather than authentic food. This nation-wide eating disorder has kept Americans in a cyclical process of attempting to achieve a thin figure while still gaining pounds. Through the course of his book, The Omnivore’s Dilemma, Michael Pollan investigates four meals: a meal from McDonalds eaten in the car, an organic based meal from Whole Foods, a meal from an organic, sustainable farm, and lastly, a meal that Pollan hunted and gathered himself.…

    • 626 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Michael Pollan expresses the need to address and fix the problem with the western diet. He starts by reminding the readers of all the nutritional theories that try to explain the health diseases that are affecting American people. The author challenges these theories by placing the blame on the health and food companies, because they create new products and medicines instead of looking at the root causes. Although an easy solution would be to not eat as much processed foods, the author points out how even nature things like soil condition and livestock feed can make that task harder than it should be. Michael Pollan suggests that the consumers are part of the problem because they do not spend enough time or money on our food preparation because…

    • 158 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pollan also quotes that dieting shouldn’t be focused on nutrition but the overall diet, including fats, sugars and processed food. His argument is that if there were more available fresh foods and less fast food places people would be more willing to stop eating the western diet and eat a healthier diet. Pollan’s writing should affect everyone eating the American diet. His writing is about our health and wellbeing. Knowing this information can provide us with a better understanding on how to diet and how to get out of the western diet.…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pollan states, “People eating a Western diet are prone to a complex of chronic disease that seldom strike people eating more traditional diets” (435). The only reason to not get these chronic diseases mentioned is only by stopping to eat the Western diet. The foods and meats American’s put in their bodies include one or all antibiotics, hormones, and waste products. It is also known to have lack of transparency, which means the people don’t tell the customers what is exactly in their foods. They tend to hide the main information that people may want to know before buying the item.…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Pollan’s essay “The American Paradox”, he defines the American Paradox and discusses how to fix the American diet. He explains how too many unhealthy Americans are preoccupied and obsessed with nutrition facts and the idea of eating healthy. He also mentions that the food industry, nutrition science, and journalism are the parties that have been the cause of this confusion about eating healthy. He thinks that worrying about nutrition facts and living a so called “healthy” lifestyle is the wrong way Americans think about eating today. I agree with Pollan’s argument because focusing on nutrition facts and dietary foods can mislead the consumer and create some health problems.…

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the beginning of Escape from the Western Diet, author Michael Pollan introduces the thought that nutritionism is one of the most used sciences used to categorize food today. Moreover, Pollan’s main claim is that nutritionism and the Western diet are not forms of dietary rules that we should follow. Pollan himself writes, “Scientists can argue all they want about the biological mechanisms behind this phenomenon, but whichever it is, the solution to the problem would appear to remain very much the same: Stop eating a Western diet” (Pollan 421). To me, I believe Pollan makes a very convincing point to stop eating a western diet, due to the examples he shares. All throughout the article, Pollan shares his various opinions on the western diet like how it leads to western diseases and thoughts on how the medical and food industries are affected.…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Correlation Between Health and Diet & How Our Surroundings Have an Impact Mary Maxfield, author of the article Food as Thought: Resisting the Moralization of Eating and graduate of Fontbonne University, advocates the neutrality and meaninglessness of moral labels on the food we consume. Mary complicates matters further as she writes, “When we attempt to rise above our animalistic nature through the moralization of food, we unnecessarily complicate the practice of eating,” (Maxfield, p. 444). In making this comment, she urges us to comprehend that our knowledge of foods considered healthy should not be founded by customs, but rather by scientific evidence. My attitude towards the issue that there is no relationship between diets and health…

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nutritionism Theory

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages

    While nutritionists are interested in health beliefs in regards to food, nutrition and physical activity, they must also be interested in why and how people make choices on a regular basis. It is very evident food is often eaten the most in social contexts and involves negotiations within themselves or with outside parties. Being able to draw on theories is critical to gain full understanding of why people eat and how they change. Main parts to a theory are the constructs and variables. Constructs are mediators of the change.…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From being named on Time Magazine’s top 100 Most Influential People in 2010 to writing many books about food and eating Michael Pollen goes on to explain how to escape the Western Diet in his essay “Escape from the Western Diet”. Pollen points out how the food and health industries impact peoples diets, how to escape the Western Diet and the 3 rules he proposes. Pollen has many great points but lacks convincing evidence in many of his arguments. Although Michael Pollen lacks some strong evidence he is still able to lure the readers in with solid points such as the two industries, so therefore making his argument somewhat convincing to the readers. Pollan succeeds in pointing out how industries should be blamed for people not being able to…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The documentary “Food Matters” examines how the food we eat can hurt us as well how beneficial they can be. The film inculcates that we should be cautious in what we eat to live better life’s. The overall theme of the film is the importance of nutrition. However, nutrition is not given any importance’s in college campus, the media, and by doctors. The documentary displays how universities excluded nutrition courses and if they do offer a nutrition courses it leans toward medicine.…

    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    In everyday life, dieting is the food a person consumes that can show what is and what is not healthy to eat. So, how does someone determine what is healthy or not because everyone in this world has a different body type. However, two authors have set out to write on such a topic. Michael Pollan, a nutritionist (Bullock 850), writes “Escape from the Western Diet” which is about Americans should completely cut out the Western diet because it consists of mostly processed food that is unhealthy for the body (Pollan 851). On the other hand, Mary Maxfield’s, a graduate student (Bullock 872), writes “Food as Thought: Resisting the Moralization of Eating” which is about how people should not moralize food because it is their body and they should be…

    • 1294 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Food and nutrition are imperative to life, not only sustaining life but also for quality of life. For thousands of years medicine has worked to find cures for what ails the human race, from the common cold to the most complicated genetic conditions. The practice of medicine has focused on medications (drugs), procedures (surgery and radiation) and even mental and physical therapy. Food Matters is a documentary that discusses an obvious omission in our health care, nutrition. Food Matters reveals that even Aristotle believed that the human body had a remarkable ability to heal and cure itself; the body however needs the proper tools of good food and nutrition.…

    • 715 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics